Opinion
Wild Jewish imagination?
Shaul Rosenfeld
Published: 11.05.10, 19:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
10 Talkbacks for this article
1. Totally digusting and revolting.
Resistor   (05.11.10)
These lousy ingrates need to take stock on just how good they have it in Israel, and if they're not happy they can move to an Arab country. Oh I forgot, nobody wants these pathetic wretches.
2. Israeli Arab acts of sabotage documented
Ron B ,   Lod   (05.11.10)
An investigation conducted this year has proven that Israeli Arabs have been actively working to sabotage state institutions to weaken Israel ahead of a general Israeli Arab uprising set to coincide with a unilateral declaration of independence by the Palestinian Arabs. No one should miss this video: http://tinyurl.com/87ysfd
3. Shaul, Israel is supposed to be an example...
Michael Hess ,   Charlotte, NC   (05.11.10)
...and so it is. Nearly every single thing you gathered above as Arab statements you consider to be incitement are true. See, that's a big problem. Dozens of reports and commissions and news articles have articulated that Israel is brutal towards the Arab Israelis within Israel, and even barbaric towards those Arab Palestinians kept trapped in the occupied territories. Since all this is true, it's simply not incitement to point it out. It is just pointing out the facts of Israel's horrendous policies of today, and how by getting worse, those policies are what is killing Israel. Not the claptrap you are trying to sell. It IS the occupations stupid. No matter how you try and make light of it.
4. We let arabs do whatever they want, and then act suprised
(05.11.10)
when they do.
5. Don't pretend war is peace
Tommy St. John ,   nyc, usa   (05.11.10)
The comments from the arab "Israelis" show they are in a state of war against the patrons that support and protect them...OK, wouldn't that mean they are traitors and should be treated as such? Just because people tend to back the weak ones in such conflicts doesn't mean they are in any position to make outlandish demands that would make the host country less safe and are therefore absurd to even utter much less demand. If they feel justified in their beliefs then they have to understand they are putting a huge target on themselves and other fool hardy instigators. If they were treated the way their brothers handle such "traitors" this wouldn't be the story, it would be the tale of countless murders that pass for justice in the highly-civilized race-blind world that existed before Israel came along and brought the area into the first world.
6. PALESTINIANS & ISRAELIS LIVING TOGETHER IS DISRESPECT
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.11.10)
LET ME EXPLAIN. *** I dont accept the word of arab-israeli or I dont accept the word israeli-arab *** BOTH PEOPLE MADE TOO MANY MISTAKES. BOTH PEOPLE'S MISTAKES HURTED ALL WORLD'S FEELINGS. SO ! LETS ESTABLISH THE FREE INDEPENDENT PALESTINE STATE WITH THE 67 BORDERS THAN EVERYONE GO TO ITS OWN LAND. you dont deserve eachothers company you both dont deserve eachothers love and respect.
7. michael hess
abraham ,   toronto   (05.12.10)
'occupation' is in the minds of those who hate
8. Michael Hess...you're avoiding me!
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.12.10)
It's definitely not the occupation, otherwise you'd have left Charlotte NC years ago and gone back to Europe. However, we all know the American settler occupation continues to be a success story. Be that as it may, you still haven't replied as to whether or not you'll meet me here in the Holy Land as proof that I am indeed a law-abiding tax-paying Israeli citizen. How about we grab a Whopper at the Malha mall before Burger King closes down? Or do you want to meet me here in the high hills of Judea where Arab armies slaughtered the legal Jewish residents in 1948 and then occupied the land? Yea yea I know, one person's settler is the other person's freedom fighter and all that. But I'm still p.o'd that you accused me of not living in the Holy Land. Shows either you can't argue your way out of a wet paper bag, or you're just a spite inspired instigator.
9. The more the Arabs cry "wolf", the less we trust their
Howard J. Gill ,   Madison, WI USA   (05.12.10)
cries, even those of us who are more liberal, those who would stand by the underdog, or at least those we have believed until recently that they are the underdog and we gradually find that they are equal citizens of Israel.
10. Brian at 8
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (05.15.10)
Michael Hess uses all kinds of journalistic tricks to avoid those able to disprove his tempered rants. He's obsessed with the Israeli 'occupation' yet can't refute Dr Jacques Gautier's legal findings...I stress legal...not religious or polictical...that Jerusalem belongs to us, the Jews. These findings also point to Jordan (included in the original Mandate for Palestine) also being intended for us. He answers questions with questions and wants definitions for ownership and sovereignty and pulls the 'appeal to authority fallacy' card in order to evade responding. I've never professed to be an expert on Jerusalem....Dr Gauthier is and I'd take his word any day against Hess's mumbo jumbo and gleanings from Wikipedia. Shevua tov l'cha, Brian
Back to article