News
Suspicion: Palestinian killed wife because she was carrying girl
Ali Waked
Published: 13.05.10, 14:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. The murder just the tip of the iceberg.
me ,   here   (05.13.10)
The woman had endured continous violence from her husband in the past, as read in the article, and the murder was the final point. I sincerely hope the social authorities there step in and take the children away from the relatives, especially the left behind daughter. The relatives expressedly show understanding for the idea of favorizing sons over daughters, and the father's view of women is very clear... They are in no way suitable to take care of the surviving children. As for the father - I truly wish the law of "An eye for an eye..." was valid. He deserves to get no better than what he gave.
32. No.22
KH ,   USA   (05.13.10)
No.22, Life is fragile, I have a little boy a girl, and I would hurt somebody if they every tried to harm my kids, I feel the same way he should die horribly. I was just trying to tell people to see the bigger picture that it's about a sick murderer not about his orgin.
33. Girl-child killing and the Qur'an
Raheema ,   USA   (05.14.10)
This man will go to hell. The Qur'an (Chapters 16 and 81) makes it very clear that the killing of girls is a grievous sin. Infant girls were often 'exposed' to die in pre-Islamic Arabia, but not since. The Qur'anic prohibition is why, although boys are prized in both countries, there is abortion of female fetuses in India, but not in Pakistan.
34. RE: WHY KILL
MW4PEACE ,   LI, NEW YORK USA   (05.14.10)
TYPICAL MALE! TO KILL A FUTURE WOMAN WHO COULD' VE POSSIBLY GIVEN HIM GRANDSONS - IDIOT! YES, IT TAKES A WOMAN TO GIVE U LIFE!
35. #33 - does that include the terrorist who shots girls in Gaz
William ,   Israel   (05.14.10)
at point-blank range and their pregnant mother? Or will Allah welcome him because those unarmed girls were....Israelis?
36. Woman carrying female child
Sondra George ,   Springdale, U S   (05.14.10)
The male is the one who determines the gender of the child, not the mother.
37. the real problem is
Momof3palstiniangrlz ,   USA   (05.14.10)
There is a strong pattern of cultural acceptance to certain crimes against women and children in many Muslim countries. Until the culture finds this unacceptable, the acts of violence will be supported. In the USA, men kill their wives for all kinds of reasons every day, but our culture views these acts as unacceptable-no matter the reason-be it infildelity, abandoment, etc. There is no act short of murder can one commit that will beget murder and even that is argued as wrong. The real problem is accountability. Will this man truly be brought to justice? Who will raise the children? The dad's family, not the mom's. What will that family tell those children? That there dad did right by God and their mom was not worthy of him. My kids were kidnapped by their dad--he left the laws of the USA that protected them and me and took them to Palestinian camps under Muslin law where he had all the power. Women have NO rights in Muslim countries. If they try to divorce an abusive husband, their children have to go to the dad and a wife is not allowed to leave the country without his approval. Men need to lose their power over women in these countries by having equal and fair laws for both sexes. Its nothing different than what slavery was in the USA. Give women the right to divorce abusive husbands and raise their own children--and set up laws to protect them--- then you will find a very different kind of thinking in the Middle East.
38. There is some real weight to your words, #37
Cameron ,   USA   (05.14.10)
I remember having a discussion some years ago with my father about the reasons the Islamic lands seem so troubled & dysfunctional in our times, and he held that the answer & true key to transforming the Islamic world towards a healthier, happier reality lay within Muslim women. That increasing the educational and economic power of Islamic women would, without fail, begin to seriously steer Islamic culture away from it's tribal and ultra-patriarchal values, and tendency towards violence that often borders on the irrational. A powerful argument, and one of the deep, 'unspoken' reasons (so I believe) why Muslim culture lashes out so against the standards, and modernism of the West.
39. To: No. 37
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (05.14.10)
What a heart-wrenching post! Kudos to you for speaking the truth about a culture that is so weighted against women. I have a friend, a lovely Arab woman. She told me once that she was the property of her father until she married, then she became the property of her husband. Should her husband die before her, she will become the property of her son. How does one go about fixing a mindset? These are the same people that consider so-called "honor" killings to be necessary and appropriate. I just don't understand.
40. To #33: there's an evil twist.
Max ,   Atlanta, USA   (05.14.10)
What you should say is that according to quran a muslim goes to hell if he kills a "virgin" girl. That's why many girls are raped first before they are killed. This is well-documented about the executions of political prisoners in Iran. A girl suspected of being a virgin is first raped by prison guards (mock islamic marriage ceremony performed to make it legal in the eyes of their god) and then she's executed.
41. What happens to these people?
jimmi ,   Barcelona Spain   (05.15.10)
I do not understand the news... how can some people do such things? Killing a pregnant wife because he is carrying a girl...
42. What a stupid man!
minnierv ,   USA   (05.15.10)
#12 - maybe the family can pitch in a make sure this pathetic excuse of a man never impregnates another woman for the rest of his life.
43. Muslim women must DEMAND thing change.
minnierv ,   USA   (05.15.10)
#37 & #38 both great posts. You both understand well this problem with the Muslim "faith". But until the women in this culture stand up to these injustices and start fighting for their own rights nothing will change. We, who are not associated with this twisted belief and ways of oppression can get as angry and upset and say whatever we want to express our disapproval but until the women trapped in these situations decide to stand up and demand equal treatment and justice and respect for their value from the men of their own society i’m afraid nothing will change. They must make the demands for their own freedom. It’s all up to them.
44. Ignorant barbarian
Nowonmai ,   Perth, Australia   (05.16.10)
He should have strangled himself as it's his sperm that determined gender of the child. I hope he is punished in the same way he murdered his wife and child.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article