News
Navy prepares for Gaza flotilla
Ron Ben-Yishai
Published: 30.05.10, 13:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
61. you have to read this!
(05.31.10)
This is the exact translation of an Israeli Arab woman named Samar's response to the article: "Liberman, we shall yet trample you down" and the subsequent reply she received from a Jewish Israeli woman called Drora... SAMAR (Israeli Arab from Haifa): "We are not Israeli Arabs...We are Palestinians who are citizens of Israel. Our citizenship is a technicality which includes an Israeli passport and I.D. which we exhibit in accordance with institutional demand. W-E have a nationality according to which we are Arab Palestinians. We are not Arabs of this state, and we do not agree to be associated wit it at all. Y-O-U have no nationality. Y-O-U have a religion which you call Judaism!! And you belong to it, and nothing else!! Your only creation has been the Hebrew language. Apart from that, there is not one thing that you have succeeded in creating during the 58 years you have spent here as conquerers upon the land of a different people!! You are simply a people without culture and without any past to justify being proud of. You are just individuals who gathered in exile, arrived with impudence in order to realize your right to self fulfillment at the expense of another people's right to the same. Rabin's version of peace-you have murdered forever! So be ashamed of yourselves, for we have no reason to talk to you anymore. And I am avoiding any sweeping generalizations. I have Jewish friends who are like my brothers, and I appreciate them very much, but there are some peoples that in order to survive, negate the existence of another people." ...and this is DRORA'S reply: "Samar from Haifa, Neither in the state of Israel nor upon the land of Israel is there even one Arab who does not have a native Arab motherland. (That is what makes you Arabic). You trickled into, penetrated, and invaded Israel with the sponsorship, encouragement and support of the Ottomanian conquerers and the British conquerers, but that did not make you the owners or lords. Open a map of the world, Arab woman from Israel. You will find that the area of the Arab states (22) is bigger than the entire European continent and that the area of all the Muslim states (56) constitutes about a third of the entire planet. A huge and indescribable area. With resources of oil and unfathomable wealth. So on the surface it would seem as though it would be okay for the Jewish people to have one tiny little country of their own without having to share it with another Arab Muslim people, no? And let me tell you a few words about the Palestinian "people". You are not a people at all. You are a fictitious Muslim invention with only one sole purpose: to conquer the land of Israel. Let's begin with your name. The Romans who conquered Israel renamed it " Provincia Palaestina" on account of the *Fillastines who had settled along the coastal regions of Israel. The *Fillastines were a red haired seafaring people who had arrived on the coasts of Israel from E-U-R-O-P-E and vanished from the region approximately 1600 years before the birth of Muhammed. The Arabs who originate from the Arab peninsula have absolutely no connection to the *Fillastines-neither genetically, religiously, culturally, historically or geographically. You are Arabs not *Fillastines. The Romans could just as well have named Israel "Provincia Switzerland" would that make you Swiss? And about israel, Samar of Haifa-Choose any historical documentation, any historical map, any accredited historian acknowledged by the international academy to show us where Palestine is, when in the history of mankind there has ever existed a land or a state called Palestine,
62. continuation -you have to see this!
(05.31.10)
when in the history of mankind there has ever been a "people" called the Palestinian people. Who are you? Where did you come from? And what is your connection to the territories and land of Israel? I cannot find even one detail anywhere in the world, including with Muslim and Arab researchers (including the Koran in which Israel is called "The land of Israel-the land of the Israeli people") to support your assertions. There is British documentation from the era of the British mandate, Turkish documentation from the Ottomanian era, and documentation of all conquests that have ever occurred on the land of Israel-there is not one trace either of a Palestinian people nor of a Palestinian state. So, let us agree that if you can find any kind of documentation whatsoever (that is not part of the Palestinian propaganda which alters historical facts retrospectively) to your being and existence in the land of Israel-then we will have somewhere to begin. You are a random cluster of branches and phalanges from all over the Muslim world that hate each other almost...almost as much as you hate us. Actually, the only thing that unites you is the hatred of Zionists. That is an extremely miserable basis on which to constitute a people! In 1948 the number of Arabs inhabiting Israel was identical to the number of Jews inhabiting Arab countries. The 20th. century was a decade of migration and population exchange all over the entire planet. All the Jews from Arab countries immigrated to their motherland-Israel. All the Arabs from Israel were supposed to immigrate back to their Arab motherlands...Not only did you not do this-but you continued to infiltrate and penetrate Israeli territories in any clever ways imaginable and that the weak policies of the state of Israel would allow. Actually, today you have a Palestinian state which is Jordan. But you want to have three Palestines for yourselves- Jordan, a "New Palestine" to be established in the Gaza strip, and the West Bank. And of course the Arab Israelis who consider themselves to be Palestinians will continue to inhabit Israel and bring more and more of their Palestinian "brothers" from all over the world. So that within a decade or two the Jews will be a minority in their own country and Israel itself will become Palestine. This does not suit us and so this is what will eventually happen, even if our left wing parties continue to spread illusions that fill your hearts with great hope: you will have to return to your motherlands. This will occur either with good will or with weapons. Over the years (with the Zionist settlement) you have adopted the Jewish ethos which is-the sanctity of Jerusalem and the right of return to Zion. So you built a temple right in the centre of the holiest of holiest Jewish sites (a common Muslim tradition in our world) but your sacred city is Mecca and not Jerusalem and your right of return is unto your Arabic motherlands and not unto Zion. In summary, I will direct you to a nice book filled with humour. It is called "Pleasure Excursion To The Holy Land" and was written by Samuel Langhorne Clemens (otherwise known as Mark Twain) in 1867. He explored the length and breadth of Israel and did not find any Palestinians, nor flourishing gardens, Arab villages or bustling cities. Nothing. What he saw and describes is a wasteland, swamps, cholera, fevers and plagues. "The land of tears" is what he called Israel. Everything that we have here in this paradise called Israel was built buy Jewish genius. It is no wonder that you and your brothers covet it! And if you are sitting in your home-connected to electricity and typing a reply on your computer, it is because the Zionists arranged a state in which you can live at a totally different level than that of 99% of your sisters in Arab countries. Signed: A Jewish Israeli citizen- Owner of the place.
63. Support
San ,   The Netherlands   (06.01.10)
Support Israel!
64. free gaza
michael ,   rotterdam netherland   (06.01.10)
so now the turks show their real face it looks ugley
65. Free Gaza flotilla
David ,   Ashqelon Israel   (06.03.10)
Gaza copes Hamas - hostile to Israel and not recognising for Israel the rights to existence. We are at war with them and the siege is legitimate way of conducting war. Humanitarian cargoes arrive to Gaza in full volume but only after check by Israel. The Turkish flotilla is pure provocation and its European participants or as well as Turks mercenaries or have simply been deceived. If Turkey directs its military ships to support to the future flotillas is finally will lead to the big war as Israel will not admit passage of unchecked cargo to Gaza Strip
Previous talkbacks
Back to article