News
Casualties reported during IDF raid on Gaza sail
Roee Nahmias
Published: 31.05.10, 06:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
196 Talkbacks for this article
1. "Don't poke a lion with a short stick"
Eron ,   Ramle - Israel   (05.31.10)
"This is a crime against humanity"; "arabs, protest with rage"; "UN: do something". When the lion (Israel) reacts, you see these "activists" screaming like babies. Porrr favorrrr!
2. Usual BS headline from Ali Waked
ben yaakov ,   herzliya il   (05.31.10)
3. Israel biggest Criminal on Earth!!!!
Paco ,   Canada   (05.31.10)
4. Israelis,what else can one expect??
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (05.31.10)
Not even the Taliban would kill activists carrying food and supplies to their enemies.
5. Flotilla, 2 deaths
Jim Kendall ,   San Rafael, CA, USA   (05.31.10)
"Israel" is about to commit-Suicide.
6. Why were there killed and injured?
Israeli 2   (05.31.10)
They thought they could resist the Israeli navy?
7. This Idiot Government Must Fall
Jerry ,   NYC, USA   (05.31.10)
You don't kill people trying to bring supplies to people, even if they are not acting legally. Bufoons. This hurts Israel far more than letting the supplies come in by land.
8. SHAME ON YOU YNET!
luiz eliezer ,   ramat gan   (05.31.10)
ARE U AGAINST ISRAEL? WHY YOU DON[T TRY TO BE THERE FOR ONCE? YOU HAVE TO LISTEN TO AL JAZEERA AND TURKISH TV TO WRITE THE SAME THING THAT THEY SAY? ARE YOU CRAZY! SHAME ON YOU! Ali Waked and Ahiya Raved WELL THAT EXPLAINS! SHAME ON YOU!
9. Israel made a smart decision, successful operation!
Historical Observer ,   USA   (05.31.10)
The protesters knew they weren't going to make it to Gaza, so they pull this publicity stunt to grab attention and make Israel look bad. Israel knew there would be a confrontation, so rather than play into their hands and have it occur in daytime they boarded the ship and ended the nonsense under the cover of night. They could not avoid the inevitable, but who knows if there would have been more or less casualties (on either side) if this had happened during the day. The camera crews must be disappointed they could not have this during prime time. What a waste of effort!
10. Hurray! Let the Terrorist Supporters Get their well Deserved
Meir Elazar   (05.31.10)
Punishment. NO MERCY! Arrest them all. Hold them until Shalit is released. Now lets see the mercy of HAMAS and if they let Shalit go finally.
11. Ships to Gaza
Armadillo ,   Anaheim, Ca.   (05.31.10)
If they try to run thru the blockade...Sink ' em Israel. This is just a front for them to establish a route to bring in contraband. They want to send aid?...Hold a music concert or something.
12. Once again, Apartheid shows it's true colors
Nour ,   One State   (05.31.10)
2 activists killed by the Apartheid Club. This is horrible and will backfire. The mission to liberate Palestinians from siege and occupation lives on. Remember we never give up and we have so many friends unlike the Apartheid Club which denies our Right of Return on basis of religion and ethnicity.
13. We need to wait
Ze'ev ,   Lod   (05.31.10)
and see these dead walking again. This is a known trick to shout "dead, dead!" to create a PR impact. No matter that later these dead will turn out to be alive, the damage will be done.
14. Are these confirmed figures or just pigyback journalism
Stuart ,   Yeruham   (05.31.10)
from panicked people and hamas soapbox preaching ?
15. they werent even in israeli waters ?
eporue ,   europe   (05.31.10)
the last position of the turkish ship was 150-200 km off the israeli coast at ashdod... whatever... this for some aid ships, whose freight you were free to security check, trying to break an illegal blockade on civilians. this cabinet kills you.
16. i thought the flotilla said they were non-violent?
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (05.31.10)
oh well, we should have known that anyone who supports terrorists will most likely have violent tendencies. i'm glad the idf did the right thing and trusted their word as much as they trust the word of the gaza terrorists.
17. WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING?!?!
Jeff ,   US   (05.31.10)
If you want to take the ships over and deport them, that's fine, but WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU POSSIBLY BE SHOOTING AT THEM?!?!? THAT'S PLAYING RIGHT INTO THEIR HANDS.........
18. just barberic wow
syria eagle ,   homs   (05.31.10)
attacking civilian fleet in international waters wow piracy bloody wow
19. this war declaring war on turkey
reza shah ,   tehran   (05.31.10)
israel gonna lose big turkey shall smash israeli navy
20. Hanan Zuabi, MK Knesset (Balad) was
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (05.31.10)
one of the protesters aboard ship set to sail to Gaza. His actions and the intent of his activity were not only illegal but treacherous. He must be stripped of his Knesset seat and should be arrested as well. We cannot afford to put up with this flagrant saboutage of our country.
21. HURRAY!
Thomas ,   Dixieland USA   (05.31.10)
Little by little Israel lost all respect because she always caved in to the worst scoundrels worldwide - most recently to Obamao's Antisemitic coterie. Israel is degenerated to the point that a bunch of private idiots had the temerity to declare war on a sovereign nation, amassed a flotilla of fools and charged an attack. Imagine what would occur if a group of pissed off crazies tried to attack Britain or Russia from the sea! It's time for the Jews to step up to the plate and start kicking @rses, including the trash at Haaretz Oberkapo 101. And start deleting the Antisemitic, hate spewing resident trolls that overtook this publication: they add nothing of intellect only regurgitation of vile hate.
22. What did they expect?
R ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
What did they expect? Despite their claims of "humanitarian" aid, the flotilla may very likely be carrying more arms and weapons for Hamas to use to attack Israeli civilians. Israel has finally learned that it is the only country in the world who will be castigated for defending itself, and castigated for not defending itself, so better to defend and fight.
23. Kol Hakavod IDF! These Gaza-Hamas supporters are evil.
BJL ,   usa   (05.31.10)
Free Gilad Shalit....Stop terrror rocket attacks on Israel...Stop indoctrination of children...Stop supporting Iran.....then maybe you can have visitors. Anyone who is on those boats should be tried as a crimal in support of terror and genocide.
24. Acceptable proportionate response? Could be...
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.31.10)
When Gilad Shalit was kidnapped, Hamas dug a tunnel under the Israeli border and blew up an army post on the Israeli side, killing two Israelis and then capturing Shalit. So is today's response simply the totally legal and legitimate exercise of "proportionate response" that the international community demands from Israel? Actually, to make it proportionate we'll have to hold one or more of the "protesters" prisoner, but not tell anybody where they are, and not allow any visits - although in a year we'll let them write a letter, and in 2 or 3 years we'll take a video of them. Sounds good to me!
25. Congrats
Art ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.31.10)
I don't know all the circumstances of the clashes yet and it's regrettable if there have been deaths, but let me be the first to congratulate the IDF on standing firm and preventing this gang of marine criminals and anti-semites from getting near Gaza It was important for the IDF not to back off in this case and to set an example for any other idiots who want to repeat this stupid exercise No doubt there will be the usual uproar from leftist and Arab circles but too bad. The IDF has done what it has to do Now I suggest that the cargo be confiscated and distributed to poor Israeli familes. GO IDF!!
26. #4: right!
Bill   (05.31.10)
You're right: taliban would only behead activists carrying food; the eventual death is itself not their responsibility.
27. Jim Jerry Peter and Paco listen up
Yosi ,   Kfar saba   (05.31.10)
You are reactionary talkbackers who are highly uninformed. Fact: This entire flotilla demo is a farce. Israel's only blockade of Gaza is against terrorists and their arms. Israel delivers TONS of food and medical supplies on a daily basis (what most people might call "humanitarian aid", but when delivered by Israel, it is non-existent for some strange reason). And by the way, Jerry, tell me what would happen to any idiot who tries grabbing a NY cop's gun? If a demostrator tried grabbing an IDF soldier's weapon, THAT IS NOT passive resistance! That is exactly the same as drawing a gun and he is responsible for the result. So stop with the bleeding heart crap!
28. so that is easy, what they expected hugs?
ghostq   (05.31.10)
the demonstrated went to get troubles and whine on the outcome, if they didn't want to get hurt don't go to military zone, and they r unemploy so they realy got nothing to lose. sound pathetic.
29. Turkey
R ,   Israel   (05.31.10)
Turkey has lost any ability to mediate in the Mideast.
30. How could anyone attack innocent people on a ship??
Evan ,   Australia   (05.31.10)
I think now the Israelis would be telling the whole world that they encountered gun fire from a ship carrying food and supplies to innocent people. Have you no conscience?
Next talkbacks
Back to article