Opinion
A new approach to Gaza
Giora Eiland
Published: 03.06.10, 11:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. What will be the best PR and the only
Ron ,   Tel Aviv   (06.04.10)
Solution. Liberate Gaza. There are no other thing. What do you think? Perhaps give Arabs Ramat Aviv and will peace in our time? May be it is the second choice? Arabs know that Barak is very weak. Remove him and liberate Gaza. Send Arabs to Sudan (where hamas people came from). The rest (4 or 5 thousand) send to Cairo.
32. Giora you also fall in the enemy's trap
ARIEL   (06.04.10)
We don't need to be regarded as the goods because we will never be so in the eyes of the Oil controlled press or Eurpoean Union; but we should do what is strategically good for us and our allies, ergo: the Christians and Druze in Lebanon, the Jordanians, and the Egyptians. We should close completely our border with the Gaza strip and prompt the Egyptian occupation and anexation of the whole territory by Egypt's police. Gaza is unsustainable and unjustifiable if not bound to Egypt! It is that or expulsion.
33. The Author is Deranged and Dangerous
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (06.04.10)
Ah we Jews, cutting our noses so to speak. Fatwas (Hamas clerics) call for death to every Jew worldwide, beginning with Israel. We will be walking int ogas chambers or worse, our women raped, our children split by the legs (a la the SS). "Work Makes Free" was taken literally.. 3m dead Israelites. Germany had designs on Palestine's Jews (Rommel and the Grand Mufti), This author is insane, dangerous and simply stupid. I believe Hamas/Hez/Iran..the Taliban/insurgents/Al Qaeda..in their goal of finishing Hitler's job. To Israel: wake up. Go in and destroy Hamas..once and for all. Complete Operation Cast Lead. Use your 400 nukes on any entity (Turkey, Iran, etc) that intervenes..it's your necks guys ultimately. Millions of Jews/Christians are tired of the Islamic Fascists..we will help you.
34. New approach to Gaza
David Thomson ,   Scotland   (06.05.10)
I notice that there is no provision for Hamas or the P.A. to inspect for the thousands of tons of munitions (including white phosphorous) shipped to Israel every year.
35. to Giora Eilan
Realist2 ,   Israel   (06.05.10)
Despite your fresh approach and logic, any strategy, including this, will be turned against Israel in the continuing struggle for Israel's elimination "no matter what".
36. to 31
muna ,   jerusalem   (06.05.10)
realy do you think that hammas came from sudan ..iam laughing for your pr .i think the best pr is to know what you are speaking about then you can lie or twisted the truth but to apear so ignorant is a funny post becouse of that i was laughing
37. You are forgetting one thing: Hamas declared
Vardina   (06.05.10)
its aim to destroy the state of Israel , wipe it off of the map and settle "Palesinians" in our land. Are these the people you suggest to negotiate with? I think that you should reconsider matters in a more realisstic way.
38. It's just another twist on Guy Bechor'd dream like scenario
Lee ,   Manchester UK   (06.05.10)
Hello! - you CANNOT REASON with these 'people'. History tells us Israel cannot trust anybody else other than Israel for it's security. It's a real quandary, i keep praying for a tsunami to sweep gaza into the Sinai under hundreds of feet of water ... it's not happening. Israel must understand that many people throughout the world love and pray for you with no conditions, God bless. Shalom.
39. Any Gov't That Defines Itself as Genocidal is NOT Legitimate
Dallas ,   Canada   (06.06.10)
Hamas will never, never abandon their sole purpose, the genocide of Israel and Jews in particular. The purpose in life for Hamas is on those terms only. Like a punch-drunk fighter in a bar, it is their sole focus until they are taken down. That is the reality, no matter how anyone wants to sugar-coat it. So where do we go from here? You can talk all you want but it's just a matter of time until they will have to be removed for good.
40. Reassessment of a miserable situation
montasser ,   gaza   (06.06.10)
In fact Israel must reassess its approach to the whole conflict about palestine and palestinians. The whole world will admire both people ,Jews and palestinians, if they decide to solve the problems once and for all times. This can be achieved by sitting down in any place here without the interference of any foreign country. The basics for a permanent solution can be summarized in one point.: a confideration between two states like or similar to the european union.
41. to 23
------------------   (06.06.10)
abou mazen will refused ..............do you know why ..........................asked netenyahu ........................and who will pay it costs ................................mubarak wants more money ..........................saudi wants it in lasvigas .............sure you are not from the middle east or the west ..
Previous talkbacks
Back to article