News
Vatican: Israeli occupation politically unjust
AFP
Published: 01.06.10, 23:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. Pope making it difficult for Christians
Claudia ,   Tampa, USA   (06.02.10)
of other denominations that do love and support Israel and should keep his freeking mouth shut. After his churches scandels his moral authority is nowhere. But of course because the Franciscan order manages ALL the Christian religious sites he is being prompted to speak against Israel, just as they do. Once I thought it was to protect Arab Christians, now I no longer believe that. I think they are trying to make a deal with the Muslims, it will be their undoing! Scripture is scripture, and they can not change that!
32. What does the Vatican know about justice other...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.02.10)
... than how to corrupt it. with all the scandals their papacy and priesthood is accused of they should really think twice about pointing the finger at anyone. But then again when have they ever been known for their wisdom.
33. Never trust a pope, especially if he was a Hitler youth ...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.02.10)
involved in scandals with young boys.
34. I'm glad the Vatican is not on our side...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.02.10)
I don't want any association to them anyway.
35. if the whole world becomes like the vataican
tony ,   ny usa   (06.02.10)
would they be any birth??? how in the world we pay attention of what they say...plus thats why they become childs molestors....give me a break ..the whole world is becoming upside down< people cant see the truth in front of them
36. Since When Is The Pope Relevant?
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (06.02.10)
The Pope needs to mind his own business and go back to protecting the warped pedophiles who follow his bizarre doctrine.
37. Lack of access to holy places??
moriah ,   sacto calif   (06.02.10)
The Vatican document deplores lack of "access to holy places,... What about our access to our holy sites? What hypocrites!
38. #16
mark ,   ca   (06.02.10)
esh lo ma she ein lah. sehel :-))
39. Look here Mr. Pope
Shmuel ,   Maale Adumim   (06.02.10)
keep your comments to yourself. Let me remind you that forced conversion of Jews to Judaism was unjust, and will always be just. Don't think that we have forgotten! Next time you think about opening your mouth first think about what your church has to apologize for!
40. Israeli do not miss opportunity to creat more ennemies.
George ,   Canada   (06.02.10)
Here we go Vatican stepped up for a just cause finally. It is late ,but enough is enough. Occupations never was human or just at all times in all centuries at all places .Israel isn't an exception. The whole world is turning against Israeli. Israel need to be saved first from the Zionists themselves before it is too late.
41. #14 Zionists aren't the Nation of Jesus
George ,   Canada   (06.02.10)
Jesus will never belong to a nation guided by a racist ideology..
42. time for mossad bloggers to bash christians
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (06.02.10)
go for it! gain more enemies! lol
43. The Church never misses a chance to disseminate their hate
Howard ,   USA   (06.02.10)
The Catholic Church is not done with the Jews yet. After centuries of torture, persecution, the Inquisition and more, they're still eager to take any chance to continue disseminating their hate. Six million Jewish lives lost and they did nothing. At the end of WW2 they helped SS criminals to escape using their "rat lines". Shame!
44. The Nazi Poop can go to hell.
Wise Saba ,   Eretz Yisrael   (06.02.10)
Let him go & look after his pedophiles & mind his own business.
45. Interpretation of the word “occupation”.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (06.02.10)
We must at least respect the religious mind of Hamas enough to understand it on its own terms. It may seem too strange to us to believe, so we impose our own reality on it. That is foolish and perilous. We must not ever forget that in the Middle East the word “occupation” has a double meaning. To the West, it means Israel’s presence in the West Bank and Gaza. That is not what it means to Hamas. To Hamas, “occupation” means the existence of an entity that defies Islam. And when Hamas fights to end the “occupation,” obliterating that entity is precisely what it aims to achieve. So, the chances for peace : http://xrl.us/ostjf
46. Occupation?
Ron B. ,   Lod   (06.02.10)
Plenty of UN members, from the US, UK, Russia, Turkey and China - to name just one handful - occupy the territory of others without incurring extraordinary wrath or even a negligible demerit. Plenty establish settlements on usurped lands - the above handful comes to mind again, but not only it. Worldwide, untold millions of noncombatants were evicted, indeed entire ethnic populations. None of the dispossessors are expected to accept dislodged enemies or even innocuous refugees back. No way will Poles, Czechs and other Europeans take back expelled Germans (and rightly so). What's done is done. As to the facts : http://xrl.us/bkj57
47. Occupation?which Bible does he read,
goy ,   zambia   (06.02.10)
Even Cush ascribes to the G-d of Yisrael. Rome is a seat of the mother of Harlots. Shut up Man of Sin.
48. oh not the baseless pope
Clint ,   london uk   (06.02.10)
The Holy Scriptures,the Bible(Torah & New testament) says,'he who have an ear let him hear,and he who are blind let him continually be blind.Isnt that statement so true.Is the pope taking an active part in speaking out against the ilegal activities of piracy of the coast of Somalia?Is he speaking out against the evil and ilegal captivity of Gilad Shallit?Is he speaking out against the defiling of the human body by gays?Is he apeaking out about the increase in crime rate?No i dont think so.He has no right to speak out against Israel.He is unjust,he has no relevance.I am a christian but i dont believe in a catholic pope.But i believe in a mighty GOD of ISRAEL,Abraham and ISsac,who will judge the earth unlike the pope and catholism who believe in a dead lady mary.GOD BLESS ISRAEL and HE will show the world through ISRAEL that he means business one day.
49. On the contrary Turkish occupation of...
Matt K. ,   Victoria, BC, Canada   (06.02.10)
... northern Cyprus since 1974 and western Armenia since 1917 has beeen just and correct from the vey beginning...
50. Hypocrites!!! The Church has asked the state of Israel ...
EST ,   Miami USA   (06.02.10)
to deny permission for Muslims to build a huge mosque right next to the church of the Annunciation .... They don't want people to know about it....sure...that way Israel gets blamed; hypocrites!!!!
51. Nice try, pope! Lets divert the attention from child abuse
Sam ,   USA   (06.02.10)
to Jews.
52. HAVE YOU READ THE BIBLE?
sarah   (06.02.10)
LIER!!
53. POPO RAT- SINGER
Milly   (06.02.10)
hidden under the skirts of the VAT-ICAN.
54. fun fact
roli ,   miami beach, USA   (06.02.10)
he owns more real estate than anyone except a shareholder in McDonalds(MCD NYSE).
55. Dear Pontiff
joe   (06.02.10)
For 2000 years, your kind, predecessors, have slaughtered Jews. Of ALL the people, you are the last one in a position to preach to the world regarding morality, injustice, bigotry and the like. You have been spreading it, and still do, throughout the world in your churches, your monasteries, your schools. I don't want to dwell on your faithful priests " penchant" for children. If not to busy, your god will pass judgement. 2000 years ago, Roman killed a Jew named Jesus. Unabated, the slaughter went on without respite; just like pagans, who thousands of year ago, sacrificed their enemies to the altar of their own private gods. With all the hi-tech, the experts at your disposition, could you please tell us, tell the world, how many Jews have been slaughtered for the last 2000 years, in the name of your religion of peace, love, understanding (just like Islam's). Also why are you and all your predecessors so afraid to open your manuscripts, parchments, documents.?.hidden in your vaults, so that scholars can find what you have been hiding for centuries. A reply would be appreciated.
56. Ye without sin
Josh   (06.02.10)
Benedict, you better spend a lot more time looking in the mirror before you go trying to cast any more stones. Better spend your efforts getting your own broken house in order.
57. before you draw the rasist card, notice
ghostq   (06.02.10)
he wants to win arab sympathy and even make catholic influence there since, people running away from the catholic church due to the last money and pedophile activities, sound like he desperate.
58. Leak?
Shaul R ,   USA   (06.02.10)
Vatican is possibly THE most secretive organization on the planet, with very deep pockets and a rigidly enforced hierarchy. As such, I find it extremely difficult to believe that any leaks from Vatican are unintended. Given its timing, it certainly appears that this leak was put out in order to demonstrate Vatican's position on the current Gaza crisis without taking a responsibility. Vatican has historically been extremely hostile to the State of Israel and has always acted against it in the most despicably underhanded manner. This "leak" is hardly surprising. On the other hand, I do pity the Catholics for being led around by such perfidious, perverse and avaricious organization.
59. Firs accuse the Jews, then ask questions
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (06.02.10)
First the UN Security Council condemned Israel's response to the international violent law-breakers on board of the Turkish ship and only then it calls for a probe. This is the skewed logic that only the UN and its agencies, e.g. UN Human Rights Council, can apply: First blame the nation-state of the Jewish people and only then ask - or not ask at all - the questions on the basis of which responses condemnation was to be based. What a cynical world! What a cynical world, indeed, that has changed only little with its attitude towards the Jewish people and its right to defend itself in the face of those who call openly for the annihilation of its only tiny home, Israel, and who have attempted to do so time and again for the past 62 years!
60. Pope
Marty ,   USA   (06.02.10)
Cut the guy some slack, will you. A few years ago he published a paper which accurately described the death cult of the worshipers of a certain 7th century genocidal maniac child rapist pedophile, the Pope was informed by the jihadist Organization of the Islamic Conference that criticism of their death cult was dangerous for his health and the health of all Christians living in muslim countries. and that he better wise up and toe the OIC line. He is another casualty of the religion of peace.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article