News
Raed Salah released to house arrest
Shmulik Hadad
Published: 03.06.10, 13:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Its a pity they didnt throw that lunatic into
Eric........ ,   Israel..........   (06.03.10)
the sea.Its just one less problem for Israel.His one big trouble maker,he will do anything to cause violence.
2. If troops wanted you dead you would be dead
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & New York   (06.03.10)
Get real, if the troops wanted you dead they would have gotten you. No claims of double or look alike will make anyone believe that the IDF would not have taken you out if that was their goal. Further proof that the IDF was not looking for violence, or Salah would have been first to be killed.
3. Statement
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (06.03.10)
..They fired in the direction of someone else they thought was me.. What a statement!! How diid he know what have they thought? Do IDF soldiers were a LCD showing their thoughts? In Arab? I am sure that this statement would support very much his case in any court. In Hamastan, that is..What a Joke!!!
4. Yeah sure...
Poitcha ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
"I am prepared to die !" So why were you hiding in a wardrobe on board ???
5. Saleh
zznhl   (06.03.10)
Believe me hamood, if that was their task, they would have done it!
6. punish the soldiers
(06.03.10)
for missing you
7. Salah
Nili   (06.03.10)
If Israeli troops "tried" he would already be dead. It is a shame is is not deported!
8. Be sure that if they wanted you dead...
me   (06.03.10)
You wouldnt be interviewing for TV, maybe as food for the fiahes. A lot of other and bigger "heros" than you felt the long arm of the IDF in more complex situations and places. So don't be happy, be ready, maybe you wish will come true.
9. it is our right to help the weak.
Galut ,   Selah   (06.03.10)
this mission is not about delivering Humanitarian supply, but rather about breaking the Israeli siege,' as Greta Berlin, a flotilla spokesperson told the media last week." ============ Israel offered the supplys a channel for delivery -the floatilla refused...it appears Greta was right it was not a humanitarian mission but rather a designed confrontation
10. #1 into the sea?
London man ,   London   (06.03.10)
"It's a pity they didn't throw him into the sea"... do you mean as happened to Klinghoffer? Is that your solution for people you don't like? Throw them into the sea? Interesting to know under which statue of international law, troops have the right - in international waters - to throw people overboard to drown. I look forward to reading your response.
11. the commando can aim a gun
yaya   (06.03.10)
If the navy commando would have been wanting you dead, you would have been found with a bullet in your head.
12. Don't make a hero out of him
Rami of nazareth ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
radical measures only help radicals like him. Nutralize him by showing he is wrong and Israel is not a brutal occupying force.
13. # 10
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (06.03.10)
It is not about how you treat people you don't like. It is how you treat enemies: the guy is a sworn enemy of Israel. What do you do with enemies in the war?
14. in the next official war
judge   (06.03.10)
he must be next to be assassinated, along with mashaal.
15. so what's the problem?
tom ,   toronto, canada   (06.03.10)
mr salah should make up his mind, either he wants to die or he doesn't.. is his complaint that the israeli soldiers shot at the wrong person, or that they missed their target? if he truly believes the islamist ideology that he spouts, that death is so much better than life, why doesn't he take matters into his own hands? just so long as he doesn't harm any innocent bystanders, i'm sure nobody would object...
16. Just another Arab lie to whip up emotions
William ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
This type of incitement IS outlawed and should be dealt with harshly. It's the same type of lies Salah spouts to whip up emotions, like "Al-Aqsa is in danger and Israel is trying to destroy it". No proof, just lies to the willing masses who want to hate, who need to hate. It's the same lies that led to massacres of innocent Jews in 1920, 1929, and the same lies that brought the birth of the OIC. Believe me Salah, you're not that important.
17. "it is our right to help the weak." - Salah
William ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
Where were you after the Haiti Earthquake? Where were you when Sderot was bombarded with rockets and many were living in poverty in Israel? You lie, Salah. Your interest is an Islamic State in place of Israel and you rush to the aid of terrorist regimes. A true peace activist sees no gender, racial, or religious lines.
18. "I am prepared to die"
William ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
Ever notice this statement is often used by those who really have no fear of dying, either that they are in hiding (usually behind women or children) or the threat really isn't there?
19. Salah
Shalom ,   U.S.A / Israel   (06.03.10)
If the troops want you dead you will be dead a long ago...
20. i wish they had succeeded!
(06.03.10)
less filth to walk our streets, spoil our air!
21. TO #10, LONDON MAN
OZ   (06.03.10)
by the same statures that guied the arabs terrorists who trew mr. klingohoffer over the achillis laro into the water... by the same primitve brutality that guides you and your like in attacking jewish and israeli civilians, for the sake of killing as many of them, and by the same barbarism that you ad you moslem bretherens displayed when you fllew jets in building, or sucide bombed pizza parlors and buses.
22. #10 - did klinghoffer incite racist violence?
William ,   Israel   (06.03.10)
I had no idea this wheel-chair bound man, on a cruise ship on vacation, was a mastermind behind racist violence and supported known terror groups in their goal of genocide. I assume that's what you meant when you compared him to Salah (being thrown of a ship).
23. Reponce to 10# from1#.Its a pity you
Eric... ,   Israel....   (06.03.10)
have a short memory.Those people who blew up those good people in London are the same type of people we deal with everyday of our lives in Israel.The English better start takeing there country back before it becomes a muslim state.
24. Salah
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (06.03.10)
If the Israeli troops tried to kill you, believe me, you'd be dead and buried already. What is this, all this whining like babies. You stick your big toe into hot water, you are going to get burned.
25. He Said...
Natan ,   Haifa   (06.03.10)
Raed Salah said: "I am ready to die for god. May you get your wish, ASAP!
26. #13 enemies
London man ,   London, UK   (06.03.10)
"It is about how you treat enemies" - well, aside from the dirty war in Argentina, I can think of no other nation which throws its enemies into the sea, as suggested by #1. If you would care to suggest under which article of international law "throwing elderly enemies into the sea to drown" might fall? I would add, that it is an atrocious and inhumane suggestion, and that whether you like him or not, Raed Salah is an Israeli citizen (admittedly not Jewish which reduces his rights somewhat), and if you think that the Israeli government assassinating its own citizens is a civilised form of government and acceptable to world opinion, then that is really sad. In addition, his crimes seem to be exactly those claims to freedom of speech which I believe is guaranteed by the Israeli constitution. Freedom to express opinions, really, when we think about it carefully, should not be punished with the suggestion of throwing the person, whose speech you don't like, alive, into the sea to drown.
27. I demand an immediate and partial investigation on why IDF
Genuine Moshe   (06.03.10)
failed to send this joker to hell.
28. To all those who said
TheCountDown ,   Mother Earth   (06.03.10)
"If IDF wanted to kill you, they would have done" rofl.. What do you think they are ?Supermen ? They can get whoever they want ? Let's make a test: Tell them to go and free Shalit ! Ah sorry.. they already tried.. Ooops...
29. #21 and "primitive brutality"
London man ,   London   (06.03.10)
If you cared to read anything I wrote, you'd notice that I always speak against "primitive brutality" i.e. I am the one saying - oh you can believe what you want. Not much basis in reality anyway in the hysterical note you almost wrote.
30. #23 "takeing there country back" [sic]
London man ,   London   (06.03.10)
The English should start taking their country back, from whom? From the Huguenots? From the Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe? Oh, no - you only mean from the Moslems. Perhaps that's why you left England, to get away from Moslems. Good move. Now you got loads of 'em on your doorstep and you probably live in a house built on a Moslem cemetary. Good move! A question. Should the Scottish also start taking back their country? And the Welsh? The Cornish? The Channel Islands? From whom? Or is it only ethnic-cleansing of Moslems that you support?
Next talkbacks
Back to article