News
Helen Thomas: Jews, go back to Poland
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 05.06.10, 20:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
278 Talkbacks for this article
31. Helen is absolutly right, European Jews should go back to EU
Moise   (06.05.10)
Arab Palestinians should not pay for the crimes committed by Europeans. Well said Helen, we love you!!!!
32. Sharmuta Mishuga.
Rosenvald ,   Brasil   (06.05.10)
I pray to Obama go out and dont whin again.
33. thank you Helen
turkish ,   palestne   (06.05.10)
palestine is for palestinians. this will be the end of the story, she knows what she is talking about
34. R. Haymond, CANADA #13: What you fail to understand
Steve   (06.05.10)
Helen Thomas = Barack Hussein Obama Obama is the anti-Semite you wish us Jew to bow to. This is the man you want Netanyahu to meet with Mr Haymond. I wonder Mr. Haymond, whose side are you on? Helen's side? Barack's side?
35. fugly biyatch!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(06.05.10)
36. HELEN TOHMAS PROVES...
OZ   (06.05.10)
that eeven after years of growing up here in the usa, 2nd generations for arab immigrants ,their vehemnt hatred of the jews still burning bright. this old rag should be fired immediatley!
37. To #17
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (06.05.10)
When are you planning to move the hell back wherever your forebears came from? I'm sure the Indians would appreciate it. Don't throw rocks, while sitting in a glass house!
38. she is right jews should back to poland PALASTINA 4 ARAB
RON ,   haifa   (06.05.10)
39. i am sorry Ms. Thomsas but my parents were not born in Germa
Efrat ,   a proud israeli   (06.05.10)
and we will return to "where we came from" when you do the same! you go back to Ahara deserts. why don't you jsut say that u want execute Jews again instead of sending us back to out "homes"? how dare you be so unbalanced as a top-reporter? don't you have any professional integrity? no? nothing? thanks for letting us know what your real face is... ANTISEMITIC RACIST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
40. 9#,Ivan, and 22#,Avi, why are you in Israel???
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (06.05.10)
If you agree with this nutcase Helen Thomas then why are you living here? Airplanes are leavng everyday. Just get one one and get the hell out of here.
41. Proof - that wisdom doesn't necessarily come with age ...
lee ,   Manchester UK   (06.05.10)
how can the Jews from arab lands go live in Poland or Germany- they have never even seen Poland or Germany?! What an ignorant old women. Just cos you have Jewish blood doesn't exempt you from being a disgraceful anti-Semite. What a disgraceful old hag, is it time for her meds!
42. "go to plastina"
rachel ,   florida   (06.05.10)
this is what the germans wrote on public seats all around germany in 1939. even they claimed jews belong to israel and you say they where wrong? president obama should exile her from the white house!!!
43. ashes to ashes
scarlet ,   LA, U.S.A   (06.05.10)
i should go to Germany and Poland so a NAZI like you can kill me peacefully, right? the ashes of my ancestors cries ISRAEL is the only place for the jewish people!
44. #26 C. Linthwaite is out of rehab again
Israeli grandma   (06.05.10)
I notice that Linthwaite is out of rehab again and venting his poisonous prejudices as usual. He contributes nothing to rational discussion, only airing his distortions on a "Jewish" website.
45. On the same time please kiss some Kurds and Armenians
Heine   (06.05.10)
46. with pleasure
chen   (06.05.10)
it started 2000 years ago and ended in 1948 we cant be occupiers in our homeland btw what about america which occupies former native american soil? it will last forever
47. Kudos to her! She speaks the truth
Nour ,   Palestine   (06.05.10)
48. To # 28 She got a hell of opinion and rightly so.
Brod ,   USA   (06.05.10)
49. #21 YOU MEAN COWS' ARSE
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (06.05.10)
Sorry to insult innocent cows.
50. #26 The Origin of European Jewry
Nour ,   Palestine   (06.05.10)
They came from Khazartsan. They are Khazari converts and have nothing to do with this land. This lady is only saying the truth and it bugs the he'll out of them! Now excuse me I'm assisting and helping organize Freedom-2 Flotilla to free Gaza from Khazar siege and strangulation.
51. Love H.Thomas she tells it as is(end)
farrokh ,   Iran Usa   (06.05.10)
52. IS SHE RELATED TO hELEN kELLER ?
GAYS4ISRAEL ,   TORONTO   (06.05.10)
i THINK SO viva siraeal
53. Hey Jude
Tel Aviv citizen ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.05.10)
Great idea! But the problem is tehat nobody wants Jews in Europe. I propose a better solution: to sell all assets that are now in Israel to Arabs,, and for this money to buy a land in Africa from some poor African country. So, Jews will live there, from the money they will receive from selling their assets in Israel they can build there the same Israel, and nobody will fight with them, as they will be far away from their enemies and can live there in piece. I am sure it's the only solution that Jews should embrace.
54. ignorance
Dawn ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (06.05.10)
Yes, sure, all the Jews should go to Poland and Germany. Makes sense. Especially the Jews who came from Iran, Iraq, Yemen, Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, and Egypt. I'm sure they'd be as welcome as the Jews were 60 some years ago. What an ignorant suggestion to make.
55. Linthwaite (# 26), the former Jew from Yorkshire.
flyingdoc57 ,   Florida, U.S.A.   (06.05.10)
What took you so long, Linthwaite? This one's right up you alley, isn't it, coming to the defense of a senile old Arab pig calling for Jews to return to the scenes of their extermination. As for "Shows the desperation of the Zionists that they have resorted to attacking an 89 year old lady for having the audacity to ask if a massacre had taken place", where are you getting this crap from? She didn't "ask" if a massacre had taken place. Everyone knows that killing 9 terrorists on a ship carrying 700 terrorists is hardly a massacre. No, she didn't "ask", Linthwaite. She DECLARED that a massacre took place, even before anyone knew what had really happened (via the video clips proving the attempted massacre against the unarmed IDF troops). You have earned an infamous reputation in Jewish circles, Linthwate, due to your 24/7 devotion to posting vile hatred of Jews on Haaretz talkback. And, as if to provide some sort of sick defense for your anti-semitism, you claim to have converted from Judaism to Christianity. You are nothing but a societal outcast who spends every waking hour of your worthless existence spewing your hatred of Jews on the internet. It is, therefore, quite doubtful that you are an authority on the "DNA" of "European Jewry". Most of what your know, and that isn't much, is derived from Al-Jazeera and the left-wing rags of your soon-to-be Islamist-ruled U.K. Best stick to Haaretz, where your Jew-hatred is welcomed. Here, you will be chewed up and spit out like a stale piece of gum.
56. History
Nicolaas Boontjes ,   Holland   (06.05.10)
Looks like she took the wrong pills against dementia.
57. What she really meant: go back to the ovens
Jake ,   USA   (06.05.10)
With age she lost all sense of propriety. But she has held those feelings all her life. People, those other nice White House correspondents think along the same lines, but they are more diplomatic. When they want the Jews to die, they call it "Peace".
58. #50 learn your own "history"
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (06.05.10)
Before the British occupation, Israel was an empty land with a tiny population of Jews, Turks, Druze, Bedouin, Christian Arabs, Christian Europeans and a few Arab muslims. The world decided to help the Jews go back to their land and the British volunteered to help. The British, famed for their dishonesty, cruelty, colonialism and racism prevented Jewish immigration and imported hundreds of thousands of Arab colonists to occupy Israel. I challenge you to agree that a "Palestinian" is a Muslim Arab who lived in Israel before 1920, and that all the Arab immigrants since 1920 should be repatriated.
59. the old hag....helen..
susan peretz ,   kiriat shmona israel   (06.05.10)
please .....this is the common material that obama keeps surrounding himself with...shame on the u.s. government....that allows anti semitism to be expressed.... and that is supposes to be"Israel's friend" ?? friends like this...who needs enemies.....and to all those who share their thoughts here on those pages.....Israel is a reality, a homeland for all jews .....bringing to life..... home of the brave....and making history come true !!!!! racism and prejudice shows just how low you writers are.... the fact that you are writing on a computer....is the invention of an israeli..... and so are the 90% of all inventions of the programs ....so its also the home of the genius....
60. why don't you ...
debra ,   U.S.A   (06.05.10)
give the native amrricans their lend (and the keys to your house) and come back to your home land, the place where you came from: LEBANON!!!! really, why don't you?????
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article