News
Thomas apologizes for saying Jews don't belong in Israel
News agencies
Published: 06.06.10, 07:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
106 Talkbacks for this article
31. her nose
.................... ,   desert   (06.06.10)
say that she can smell very well
32. Take a broom and fly to Lebanon, ma'am...
Matt K. ,   Victoria, BC, Canada   (06.06.10)
... damage is done...
33. Ugly Old Bat
Madeleine ,   Israel   (06.06.10)
Was she born that ugly or did she have plastic surgery to get that ugly? Or is it one of htose rubbery mask things?
34. The real message
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (06.06.10)
This old woman is really summarising her true feelings, after 90 years she still carries a inferiority complex toward the southern neighbours of her ancestors. Really a compliment to the srate of Israel.
35. Awww, somebody is on too many pills...
Sinan ,   Istanbul, Turkey   (06.06.10)
Yeah, Helen.. Your retirement is long overdue sweetheart... How about moving to a Muslim neighborhood in Lebanon, so that you can appreciate the Muslim "tolerance" and maybe start a grassroots organization for Gaza!! No one needs to heard your voice at the White House conference room anymore.. It's so irritating
36. What is said is said
Shalom Freedman ,   Jerusalem Israel   (06.06.10)
The apology is face- saving, and perhaps an effort at job- saving also. But she said what she said. She will in fact get many new anti- Semitic fans for her remark. Nonetheless her reputation is gone among those who care for fair and objective Journalism.
37. Make no mistake.
Wael ,   Palestine   (06.06.10)
She is not sorry, she just succumbed to threats and said what she was asked to say. Her mind and heart is with the Palestinians. The entire world is. Chew on it.
38.  Thomas apologizes for saying Jews don't belong in Israel
summer ,   israel   (06.06.10)
ms thomas go the hell out of the us and go back to lebanon where u belong and learn in ur 90 years of life that? israel is the homeland since 3000years for the yews or is ur brand with all ur years demaged???
39. Notice how she never took back what she said.
Jonathan ,   USA-ISRAEL   (06.06.10)
40. #14 that is why saying nigger in America is acceptable
golan ,   modiin   (06.06.10)
because "freedom of speech" or why South Park can "show" Muhammad or even say Muhammad, or why the US administration cannot come to terms with "Islamic" terrorism as opposed to "some-very-few-individuals-who-call themselves-Muslim" excuses...
41. What the Hellen
BAB ,   jerusalem   (06.06.10)
"Mutual respect and tolerance" is exactly what did not characterize her remarks.I guess I'm a doubting Thomas. I don't believe her. It's only a matter of time before she inserts her other foot. Time to step down.
42. Little Helen
Yochi in Israel ,   Hadera, Israel   (06.06.10)
Say 'Thank You'. Little Helen finally came out of the preverbal closet and is now the poster child for the Obama administration. I have one thing to say to all Jews still living in America: Yiddin, leave America NOW! Leave while you can still leave with all your belongs, your families, your cat and your dignity. Remember that 'little' tefillin incident on Chautauqua Airlines - an affiliate of US Airways - back in January? "Misunderstanding" our basic religious practices? Now Little Helen "misunderstanding" the basics of Jewish history? How many 'incidents' and 'comments' will it take before you understand that we only have ONE HOMELAND and it ain't the golden medina. Remember, your parents/grandparents/great-grandparents came to America with NOTHING; no money, no connections and not even (in many cases) basic language skills and now look where Jews are in America. Now it's your turn. Come and make Israel strong. You have so much more to offer than any previous generation. You owe it to your kids/grandkids and great-grand kids.
43. TO HELEN THOMAS
THE ELEPHANT MAN ,   UGLY LAND   (06.06.10)
From one extremely "cosmetically challenged" fellow to another , WILL YOU MARRY ME?
44. EVEN I HAVE STANDARDS YOU KNOW
ELEPHANT MAN ,   LONDON HOSPITAL   (06.06.10)
And Helen Thomas is brutally ugly.
45. #20 Peter Jennings and Hanan Ashrawi..
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (06.06.10)
Were not so secret lovers. It reflected in some of his reporting.
46. Anti-Semitism comes in all shapes and sizes!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (06.06.10)
Even little old ladies who say what the mean and then "apologize". I think what she meant was Auschwitz and Dachau! Israel is an Israeli mother who sometimes forgives but never forgets!
47. She said: " deeply regret my comments" so some can move on
Ann   (06.06.10)
48. helen thomas
scott ,   usa   (06.06.10)
She did not offend the Palestinians. She offended the Jew! Helen Go back to Lebanon!
49. to #14
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (06.06.10)
No Mamud, there is all the freedom to say what you think. But nobodyin the US (except for a few racist fringe elements) has any patience anymore for this kind of racism. No one will put her in jail, but she is totally discredited.
50. Baseless Outrage
Levent ,   Istanbul   (06.06.10)
This entire storm is based on the lie that she said Jews do not belong in Israel. Despite the headline, the article eventually abandons that lie halfway through when the inclusion of the clip forces them to admit she was talking specifically about Palestine. "Get the hell out of Palestine." This had nothing to do with Jews in Israel proper. The accusation is a shoddy excuse for propaganda and does your credibility no good at all.
51. To hell? Lady's first! Though, are you really a lady if sayi
Yon ,   Haifa-Kiev   (06.06.10)
To hell? The lady's first! Though, are you really a lady saying such things?
52. She needs to learn history - read a bible - Jews FROM ISRAEL
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (06.06.10)
53. Helen Thomas
Ben ,   Monterey USA   (06.06.10)
I am shocked at the ignorance that a veteran journalist show. Don't they teach history in Journalism school? Or did she snooze at those classes
54. she is right!!
ayalonnnnn ,   poland   (06.06.10)
All she is suggesting is for them to go home. To their real homes, in poland, russia etc.. What is wrong with that? Do you hate your homes so much that you want to murder and steal the homes and land of others? Is that what Moses asked you to do? To kill innocents and pretend to be victims? To spend millions on learning the "art of spin"? Just go home and leave the world a better place.
55. no 4
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
To think that naive leftist looneys voted this nutcases,s boss ,Obama and his merry bunch of looneys into power ,how ludicrous but more and more of those previously blinkered leftists are waking up to reality so roll; on mid term elections and bye bye nutcases like Helen Thomas .
56. no 16
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
She dare not return home to Lebanon ,not with Islamofascist Nsarallah drooling at the lips .
57. no 34
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
Maybe shes related to Hanan Ashrawi ,the witch of Palestine as she sures looks like her?
58. no 50
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
Just another example of Muslim lies and distortions ,not so Levent ,you don,t fool anyone ?
59. no 48
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
Helen Thomas is only saying what the leftist looneys of the Democratic madhouse would like to say but cannot for fear of losing more Jewish votes in the November midterm elections ,how revealing ?
60. no 5
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (06.06.10)
You left out Barack,s main man Rashid Khalili ,Nerm ,the MUSLIM mouthpiece of the Democratic madhouse .
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article