News
Students plan counter-flotilla
Yaheli Moran Zelikovich
Published: 06.06.10, 17:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. Armenians, Kurds & jews have all suffered
zionist forever   (06.06.10)
Hopefully it will make us some friends in Armenia or Kurds. The Armenians & Kurds have both been victims of genocide and as the jews have been victims of genocide themselves then we should try show a little solidarity with these people. Good relations with the Kurds especially could be very beneficial to Israel. So go for it guys do Israel proud.
32. Students plan counter-flotilla
evi ,   london   (06.06.10)
If anybody knows where the support is needed most, i.e. where to send money, please publish. For f....k sakes we are to old to fight, but we can donate... let's get doing what we do best!!!
33. Kurds will never forget the support...
Citizenof ,   Kurdistan   (06.06.10)
Israel gave Turkey over the years. Neither do we forget that it was with Israel´s help that our leader Ocalan was captured by Turkey. How hypocritical of you to remember Kurds and Armenian as soon as relations become sour with your ally of always Turkey. Wasn´t it Israel´s lobby that stopped the USA to recognise the Armenian genocide as such? Things will soon be back to normal and Turkey and Israel will become friends again.....NO ONE will ever remember the Kurds nor the Aremenians!!! So THANKS BUT NO THANKS.......
34. #15 Historians say the opposite.
(06.06.10)
Oh William, just one question, how could Turkey or anyone else kill millions of Armenians while there were not even one million Armenian in Ottoman Empire? Armenian population in Ottoman Empire were around 800.000. So, can you kill non-existent people? Oh, have you ever heard of Guenter Lewy, Avigdor Levy, Stanford Shaw, Alon Ben Meir? They are all respectable historians, and they are Jews. They claim exactly the opposite. They prove that Turks, Circussians, Kurds and Jews were massacred brutally by Armenian terorist Tashnak, Hinchak and Armenian Fedayeen groups. Also, read Justin McCarthy, Norman Stone, Bernard Lewis all prove that there was no such a thing called Armenian genocide, but Armenian themselves were masscaring others in collaboration with Russia, France and Britain. As for Kurds, as I said, it's gonna be the scene of the century watching Israelis bringing a ship of aid to Kurds :) It's like Israelis bringing food to Ismail Haniya and Nasrallah. Israelis wouldn't only commit a suicide by that, but also make a fool of themselves. My Kurdish business partners in London refuse to sell goods and do any business with Israelis since Gaza operation and they keep forwarding anti-Israeli messages everywhere, you can imagine the rest.
35. #29 Your dreams about Hatay are only dreams.
(06.06.10)
It looks like you really made a lot of efforts to explain it but you miss imortant points. Syria and Turkey have absolutely no problem over Hatay. Hatay has some Arab population and they are Allawi Arabs, secular and deeply loyal to Turkey. Syria and Turkey recently removed visa regulations, signed military cooperations, trade and economics agreements. So, your words of 'occupied Iskenderun' etc are all your dreams. No problems between Turkey and Syria now. As for Kurds and Kurdistan help, haven't you heard a Kurdish politician was very harshly criticised and even banned from politics after he suggested a possible friendship with Israel. Can you imagine Israel sending aid to Kurds? They would wait eagerly, but not for the aid, for the Israelis to fight. But, go and try, it will be a scene to watch.
36. Israeli aid to Kurdish Hizballah too?!
(06.06.10)
Israelis, you are full of hatred and primitive instincts such as 'my enemy's enemy is my friend'. That's why, you are willing to support anything to kill Turks. This is not surprising though, you are a tribe from the Middle East jungle after all. But, you are really ridiculously making a fool of yourselves. Haven't you heard of Kurdish Hizbullah? Haven't you heard of Kurdish Islamists such as Ansar al Islam, Kurdish Hizballah and Erdogan's Kurdish ministers? You want to help them to create a real enemy?
37. We Armenians from France are ready to join you in your ship
Harutyun   (06.06.10)
Great idea. Just tell us where to be and what to bring. IT IS TIME WE CLAIM DIYARBAKIR (east anatolia) for Armenia
38. stupid
turkey/ armenian   (06.06.10)
a fake aid ship to pretend turkey treats people like the israelis do. go ahead, spend all that money and aid. LOL. give it to turkey, they will be glad. but one will have to inspect the goods to make sure the israelis and jews are not up to anything nasty. also, IT IS so funny that usually the jews try to keep the Armenian holocaust quiet, because it takes attention from the 'vicitims of the world' the jews, but now i guess its convenient to bring it up . LOLOL
39. The BBC won't report this if it happens ...
Lee ,   Manchester UK   (06.06.10)
those Israelis on that boat will be murdered, please reconsider this suicide mission.
40. counter flotilla to counter students one
mahfooz faaz ,   egypt   (06.06.10)
our students from all across egypt are planning the same and came in contact with greek and syrian students to organise a counter flotilla against flotilla from israel and send it to gaza.we will do it faster and better .
41. Jews' love for ARMENIANS: EMMANUEL CARRUSO!
HAYK   (06.06.10)
JEWS TOOK PART IN ARMENIAN GENOCIDE, JEWS WERE LEADING FORCE IN YOUNG TURKS. JEWS REFUSE RECOGNIZING ARMENIANS GENOCIDE. ONLY NOW THEIR RELATIONS WITH TURKS ARE BAD, SO JEWS TRY TO FIND ALLIES BUT ARMENIANS DON'T TRUST JEWS.
42. Israel's hypocrisy reaching a new low
ahmadinejad ,   iran, teheran   (06.07.10)
armenians and Kurds of Turkey enjoy a healthy and nice life in turkey, this is unecessary This is misinformation
43. Student flotilla? Somebody in authority had better check
Harry Wright ,   UK   (06.07.10)
this out. Is this a field trip? Are the Kurds and Armenians in need? Of what items? Which village will they be going to? Or who precisely will receive the items and where - the docks? What about customs? Hm! Where is the planning for this trip? This needs adult supervision because it can turn out into a huge embarrassment for the students and Israel. Enthusiasm is fine but common sense and practicality must prevail. From a distance, this sounds like a bad idea.
44. So proud to be a Jew!
Susan ,   DC, USA   (06.07.10)
I hope my children grow up to be this brave, clever and moral!!!
45. Seriously?
John ,   Chicago, USA   (06.07.10)
So it's okay to oppress a group of people because someone else did it in the past before you? How many nations oppressed others, but came to their aid in WWII? Britain, the US, France, etc? Genius Israel, genius. You can see that their ignorance stems from their "well" educated youth
46. Students plan counter-flotilla
tom ,   tokyo japan   (06.07.10)
excellent news. now when they fail to get slaughtered by turkish commandos, we'll see about that hypocrisy.
47. Re: PRICELESS !!!!
tom ,   tokyo japan   (06.07.10)
North Korea takes a similar stance; fighting back to gain respect. I'm interested to know your opinion on North Korea taking that stance, and if it is different that your opinion of Israel doing the same thing, why?
48. You are welcome
Nicolae Tufar ,   Athens Greece   (06.07.10)
Having lived in turkey for 10 years, I don't see any reason to not be able to do it. There is no blockade or anything. Bring your aid, and deliver it whenever you want. You will not see any resistance.
49. we kurds dont want anything
kurd ,   turkey   (06.07.10)
we kurds dont want anything from you! we kurds and turks like brothers.first clean your own s**t. if you want help,then bring it to gaza not to us kurds.turkey is not a terror state ;) we dont want anything from you!!!!
50. good job!
Moritz ,   Germany   (06.07.10)
Sending humanitarian help to Turkey is a nice idea! We wrote an german article. http://www.ein-schuh-fuer-schaeuble.de/?p=1298 peace! moritz
51. That so funny
Eme ,   Spain   (06.07.10)
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/58/Kurdish-inhabited_area_by_CIA_(1992).jpg By flotilla they mean "by car", don't they? That's so stupid...
52. no way
youngturk ,   turkey   (06.07.10)
thats not a good idea..gaza flotilla was also not a good idea..dude dont forget why turkish troops are in cyprus pls do some research before leaving emotional comments..turkey and israel have been allies since years, wait until erdogans goverment gone next year there are elections, everything will be ok i hope.. and last of all not everbody is supporting that gaza flotilla in turkey..
53. is Part of international flotilla from Limasol
Rafiq ,   Amsterdam Netherland   (06.07.10)
not only israeli students but from all over the world people from all kind religions are joining an international flotilla from Limasol to South Kurdistan. medio august people from all over the world with all kinds of backgrounds and religions will come to Cyprus and joint the Peacefull Kurdish Flotilla. So these Israeli students will not be alone and will have full support on this 100% peacefull flotilla.
54. Bad idea
Hakem ,   Belgium   (06.07.10)
turkish kurd people are free to get aid, to leave the country or to do anyting they want. ... as opposed to Gaza people. I suggest that Flotilla goes to Gaza, it is cheaper and more practical ....
55. Thanks
huseyin ,   switzerland   (06.07.10)
Im Kurds im refuge in Switzerland , Thanks alot of for this idea
56. to Hakem Belgium
Rafiq ,   Amsterdam netherland   (06.07.10)
It is worring how many excuses the world have to close their eyes for the suffering of the Kurdish people. And how many excuses for Turkeys behaviour toward the Kurds. Israel and the Palastinians wants peace but this is blocked by the Hamas who is supported by Iran and Turkey. Also Iran occupies part of Kurdistan and yesterday evening and this morning they have killed several kurdish civiliens. i think it is normal that israel wants to control the import to Hamas. Every normal country would check ships going to enemy harbours.
57. Israel-Turkey arms deal
Mitch ,   Berlin Germany   (06.07.10)
Talking about hypocracy: The students should ask the Israeli gov. not to deliver the surveillance drones that Turkey ordered, but has not paid yet. (source: BBC world service radio) ...If the students are seriously interested in helping Kurds...
58. Please make a change!
Israel ,   Israel   (06.08.10)
59. Turkey's Responsibility for Armenian Genocide
(06.08.10)
Tukey must stop denying and lying about its genocide of the Armenian people. Call them the Ottomans or Turks, same difference - they must be made accountable in the eyes of enlightened nations.
60. Contact info for donations
David Oliver ,   Boston, MA, USA   (06.08.10)
"For the flotilla to work, we need three elements: Money, logistics and balls," he said. "We're bringing the balls and some of the logistics, but we need lots of money." I think what the press, etc.. has been doing RE Palestine is ridiculous. I would like to donate to the cause of the student flotilla but there is no info where to do so.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article