Culture  Music
Folk singer Devendra Banhart cancels Israel shows
Or Barnea
Published: 16.06.10, 15:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. You must encourage local artists,
Salma ,   Palestine   (06.16.10)
This is the best solution :) Fun for all !
2. Who the heck is he? Only claim to fame is he dated Portman.
American ,   Miami   (06.16.10)
3. one more artist victim of cultural terror
jason ,   israel   (06.16.10)
another sad day NOT for israel but for the cesspool called islamic fundamentalism, bringing nothing but darkness and evil to this world. this artist had a choice, maybe not an easy one, but his choice made his visit political by succumbing to muslim threats. meanwhile hundreds dead and thousands fleeing islamic warfare in central asia. slayings in sudan for watching the world cup. the sooner the world wakes up to this evil and understands how to counter it the better.
4. Let's hear it for Geva Alon!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ecr   (06.16.10)
5. BDS Movement Is Working
World Citizen ,   the world   (06.16.10)
An artist may not want to be involved in a political dispute but when faced with an economic boycott by an enlightened, knowledgable clientel he will pick money over Israel everytime. Clearly the BDS movement is winning the day. It has has been able to define performing in Israel as a political statement. Be thankful for Jewish Klemer bands and has-beens like Madonna or Elton John. They will come. I doubt very seriously if groups like U2 or an Arcade Fire calibre band would ever play in Israel. I know that John Lennon, if he he were alive, wouldn't.
6. good news for our ears ! You will never be welcome here !
(06.16.10)
7. message
Dan   (06.16.10)
"we tried to make it clear that we were coming to share a human and not a political message" Oh yeah? And cancellation is not a p[olitical message? You have been used by Arab terror, you nitwit!!
8. Bottom line - he lied
R ,   Israel   (06.16.10)
If he said cancellation was not an option, and then cancelled, I can't think of another word for it.
9. Just another shallow hypocritcal artist
Jacob Blues ,   New York City, USA   (06.16.10)
Not even four months ago, Banhart posted the following request on his website "Help My Friend Help Haiti! Posted on Wed, 02/10/2010 - 4:40am Help my friend help Haiti! Hey y'allz! Check out the auction my dear pal Binki Shapiro organized! Alot of sweet stuff that benefits Haiti. Here's the link and THANK YOU!!!!!!!" Was it not Israel that sent a fully operational field hospital and 240 medical personel to help the Hatian people? Yeah! The old "what have you done for me lately" ideal shows Banhart for the fraud he is.
10. devendra who?
dennis greenstein ,   nj,usa   (06.17.10)
not much more to add to prev posts except that who the hell is this yutz? never heard of him. obviously, Natalie was smart enough to ditch this loser. HE is the loser in all of this. He's destined for the dustbin of history, along with the other losers who succumbed to this Arab cultural terror. This only soldifiies my choice to spend my vacation dollars later this year in Israel as opposed to some American or European site. Am Yisrael Chai!!!
11. I agree with talkbacks 1-9 thus far.
Israeli 2   (06.17.10)
I had the same exact things to say. Especially that of #2. Great American
12. This is disgusting..
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (06.17.10)
and cowardly beyond words. I cannot believe these people cave in to pressure from a bunch of a--hats. I'm normally not big on conspiracy theories, but I'm honestly starting to wonder, if they're not getting paid not to appear in Israel with the BS excuses thrown in for a bonus. Either way, to hell with them!
13. A STAR ? WHO IS HE ? NOT KNOWN IN CANADA !
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (06.17.10)
HE IS A PERSON WE NEVER HEARD OF. DOES HE SING, OR DANCE, IS HE A JUGGLER, A MAJICIAN ?? THE TEST OF A " SOMEBODY " OR A " MENSCH " IS HOW HE BEHAVES UNDER PRESSURE. THIS PERSON IS A WEAK COWARD, HE FAILED THE TEST .......... WOULD I GO SEE THIS PERSON EVEN FOR FREE ? .... NO !!
14. devendra-something...
tom ,   tel aviv   (06.17.10)
to all of you, fellow "commentators": the next one that cancels- let's NOT comment on it at all! We are rehashing the same view-points and maybe the best "revenge" is to keep silent....? Let's try , just once
15. Concert in Mecca
James ,   Herzeliya   (06.17.10)
devandra is going to perform in mecca instead of Israel... that's why he cancelled.
16. Who?????
hannah ,   ny,usa   (06.18.10)
Seriously, Who??????
17. And this is who again??? Has anyone heard of this unknown?
Confused ,   American   (06.18.10)
Should I be devastated??? Nothing like the Israeli media making a big deal over these nothing people no one (at least Americans) have ever heard of.....
18. Never heard of him!!
HG ,   NYC   (06.18.10)
19. Wow...
Yours Truly ,   LOS ANGELES   (06.18.10)
All of you guys need to get out of your bubble! Devendra Banhart is an amazing musician... His reasoning for not performing is completely logical and if you guys can't see that, you're blind... Free your minds!!! Get out of this world of pop culture and propaganda that makes us blind! Do some research people...
20. Palestinians and their supporters
Mary Elizabeth   (06.18.10)
They are bullies, anti-democratic thugs. Shame on them!
21. wow, Devendra sounded like a female
meg ,   israel   (06.18.10)
because NEVER HEARD OF him! OK read the artical, now know but really is nothing i am going to remember!
22. Boycott the albums of those that cancel
meg ,   israel   (06.18.10)
and are we really missing anything?? go spend your money elsewhere, like going to see "home grown" entertainers. Elvis Costello sucks, santana is ancient and the pixies...who are they? also the others mentioned, wouldnt pay good money to see them. WTG Geva, also kudos to Metallica, Elton John, and all who so come.
Back to article