News
Neturei Karta attack MKs
Ronen Medzini
Published: 24.06.10, 18:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. Oposition to the State of Israel???
Keren ,   IL-BR   (06.24.10)
Listen,in these cases I am all in favor to put them in a prison *of Israel *or deport them to their (or their parents)country of birth,untill they repent, or untill Israel is the way they believe it should be. If they are not happy here and can not struggle to the benefit of all Jews living in this country,inclusively going to the Army,send them out! Frankly,this is revolting.A Jew is not supposed to be like this,even if being sometimes quite stiffed necks. All have limits and a beam of our faith is Justice!
2. The huge majority of Haredim are not like this.
Keren ,   IL-BR   (06.24.10)
These ones are sick and must be treated! What are they ?Made of ciment? What is that that they can not speak to other Jews to reach a just agreement? What´s that??
3. We really can't afford to be allowing these
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (06.24.10)
people (Neturei Karta) to continue residing in Israel. If they cannot be deported, we can at least require them to live well within the restrictions of the law. But they do seem to symbolize Israel today: Anarchy.
4. Koch Never Met With Israel's Enemies
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (06.24.10)
Here in the states, it is a major felony to throw a rock, pipe, brick or other potentially lethal weapon at someone. 3 strikes, (even non-violent) and 25d to life. A kosher owner in Iowa just got 27 years in jail for falsifying finanical statements to a bank (not prosecuted for hiring illegal aliens however). 27 yr, get it. and NOT violent crime. These anarchists (members of the thuggery group) can protest by their vote. They, AND similar incidents by Arabs, must be arrested, tried, prosecuted and punished. 3 times..you get 25 to life. What if the MKs had been hurt severely? These people meet with Hamas/Hez/and other Israeli enemies..yet are still legal in Israel. Stop them now!
5. #3 For all intents and purposes, NK are anarchists.
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (06.24.10)
Just religious ones, is all. Their approach to those who share their faith (and ultra-conservative lifestyle, even) but not their narrow views on the matter, is to dub them blind, treacherous to Judaism, and so on and so forth. We're fortunate that they're mostly ineffective and cowardly, else they would've shot people by now. And most likely, should they ever become *that* extreme, they'll start by "cleaning up" the so-called "traitors of the faith" - that is, all the religious Jews around who believe that they, the NK's, are complete and utter nutters.
6. NK is right !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (06.24.10)
The UTJ should leave the governement , so they will not be able anymore to "milk" the State's budget in favor of their non productive masses .
7. To Keren #1
Ariel ,   São Paulo - Brazil   (06.24.10)
This is their interpretation to the Torah. Unfortunately they are so intolerant as the Slonim Hasidic that not accept people different from them in the classroom. That's where it ends a society driven by religious laws where the words of the rabbis are more important than civil laws
8. Something DEEPLY wrong with these...
iObserver and News ,   USA   (06.24.10)
The behavior of these individuals is diametrically opposed to the Torah and any and all spiritual values it teaches, regardless of their adherence to the projections of the Neviim. There is something deeply wrong with them; echoing the behavior of the Sadducees and their blindness. While we Jews must have tremendous tolerance for each other, this behavior from this 'sect' reveals their inability to follow the Torah and its values, let alone basic human decency. They should be removed from Israeli society and shunned from all Jewish groups until they adopt a different perspective and behave as sons of Aaron, loving peace. Shame on these people; they're an embarassment to Hashem and the Jews.
9. Neturei Karta
Anna ,   Montreal, Canada   (06.24.10)
I hope they don't receive and monetary help from the Israeli government. What are they doing in Israel anyway? Don't they have better understanding in Gaza? Let Hamas and Iran pay them for their existence.
10. #7 Ariel
Keren ,   IL-BR   (06.24.10)
With patience and the help of those who are not like that,things will change. If we keep discussing,without hate and common sense,everything will be alright.
11. Neturai Darta (if you are sy- you get it)
andrew ,   NYC US   (06.24.10)
As a dati Jew living in the US, I have seen these disgusting low lives at many Israeli day parades and at pro Israel Rallies. The only issue is that they are always on the other side of the picket lines chanting, and holding up signs calling for Israels destruction. I never understood how the Hareidi communities in general (including the Satmar) allow such a perversed and vile group of "Jews" to reside in their communities. These are not our brothers. They lost that right when they began meting with our worst enemies, lending creedence to their ideas of a judenrein Palestine. If they want Israel to undergo drastic religious changes, let them become a viable part of the israeli community. Work, pay taxes, and VOTE. They can very easily begin to turn the tide to a more religious platform by gathering the masses and calling for a vote of their candidates. Instead they are rabble rousing rejects who coddle Israels worst enemies. until they learn how to treat their own kind they should be kicked out of the land that they so thoroughly are trying to give away.
12. #7 Slonim Hasidim and Neturei Karta have nothing in common
rebecca ,   Modiin   (06.24.10)
Slonim Hasidim live peacefully in and with the state of Israel. NK do not. Slonim Hasidim want to educate their children, preferably within the Israel Education system. Nk is more interested in removing the state of Israel. No connection. Please do not insult the Slonim Hasidim especially as all you know about them you get from bad journalism.
13. Natural Carter
Resistor   (06.25.10)
I like the name
14. all the jews saying to deport them back
HELEN THOMAS ,   USA   (06.25.10)
and telling then theu have them GO HOME. you sound just like HELEN THOMAS. see, what she said was the TRUTH. jews did come form somewhere like poland or germany or the USA, THEY DO HAVE A REAL HOME.
15. These neurotic karta people are TRAITORS of the State.
Lee ,   Manchester UK   (06.25.10)
what exactly are they about anyway, how can any Jew despise Israel so much and LIVE THERE ffs!
Back to article