Opinion
Where is the world?
Yoaz Hendel
Published: 30.06.10, 18:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. To: Golani at No. 23
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.01.10)
Rav todot, Golani. I hadn't known that. It would appear that Haman's people were bloodthirsty 5,000 years ago, and that nothing has changed. Haval.
32. Sagi, #20 and 24, I like it, but of course, it won't happen
Lobo ,   USA   (07.01.10)
The world won't do that to Iran because of Iran's threat with nukes, and of course their oil. On the other hand, I think that the punishment you suggested, "Deportation to the 'Zionist Entity'" would be fair. Israel would "suffer" from such advanced thinkers!
33. What will this rabid stone throwers do,
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (07.01.10)
when they finally can lay their dirty hands on some nukes...??? Their dirty hands must be cut off in time... Mr. Hussein Obama, You have extended Your hand to this criminals, would You please be so kind, to extend Your hand to this helpless woman...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
34. The Jews are indirectly to blame
Raptor   (07.01.10)
Hatred must be vented, it cannot contain itself within. The hatred of Israel cannot be vented against Israel itself so substitute targets must be found. We are to blame.
35. The World Doesn’t Condemn Iran? What!?
k1w1 ,   NZ   (07.01.10)
Is this guy serious? Does he really believe that the world doesn’t condemn human rights abuse in Iran? Unbelievable! And, judging by the comments here, most of the sheeple who read this garbage evidently believe it’s true. Unreal! [#22, Golani: the person at #4 is someone who also uses the name “Matty Groves” from “Fairport”. The difference between the two “Matty Groves’” is always obvious. For a start, the one at #4 struggles with the English language…]
36. #7 Nice one!!! These guys just have a big mouth!
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (07.01.10)
They should first and foremost clean their own backyard!
37. Stoning to death for adultry @ bible
sami ,   Edmonton, Canada   (07.01.10)
Stoning to death for adultry @ bible... note that here, GOD is speaking as a 1st person... so, there is no way for jews and christian to deny this as a 2500 yr old jews law... on the other hand there is not a single verse in the quran that promotes stonning to death. Whatever, they adopted... is nothing but adoption of some surrounding pagan, jews and christian culture. Stonning to death punishment for non virgin women. 22.20 But if this thing be true, and the tokens of virginity be not found for the damsel, (unmarried women) 22.21 then they shall bring out the damsel to the door of her father’s house, and the men of her city shall stone her with stones that she die, because she hath wrought folly in Israel, to play the whore in her father’s house; so shalt thou put evil away from among you. Death punishment for adultery. 22.22 “If a man be found lying with a woman married to a husband, then they shall both of them die, both the man that lay with the woman and the woman; so shalt thou put away evil from Israel. Stoning to death punishment for virgin women for adultery. 22.23 If a damsel who is a virgin be betrothed unto a husband, and a man find her in the city and lie with her, 22.24 then ye shall bring them both out unto the gate of that city, and ye shall stone them with stones, that they die — the damsel, because she cried not, being in the city, and the man,because he hath humbled his neighbor’s wife; so thou shalt put away evil from among you.
38. to 3
noran ,   halab   (07.01.10)
prophet mohammad said - once a woman was in the hell becouse she capture a cat do not feed it or lt it be free to find its food ... once omar bin elkhattab said -- i fear that god will adk me about a camel that fall in the dtreet of arab land ..the land which was under his rule ... they did not return to animal defen or organization of animal right .... i think this article is so cheap in laws and orders and so cheap in rights of human .. did the death of woman justify killing of innocents in any war .. at least it may be a crime .. like any crime any where . but war crimes is anothor thing .. if mr. hitler burned one jewish woman do you think it would be the same of 6 milion ... yes right of life is the same to all if it is one or 9 or 10 thousands .. if it is only shalite in prison or 10 thousand palastinians .. but sure it is under law and punishment .. be aware of your state and right of your son ....god will judge evry one not obama in the white house
39. The World Doesn’t Condemn Iran? What!?
k1w1 ,   NZ   (07.01.10)
Is this guy serious? Does he really believe that the world doesn’t condemn human rights abuse in Iran? Unbelievable! And, judging by the comments here, most of the sheeple who read this garbage evidently believe it’s true. Unreal! [#22, Golani: #4 is someone who also uses the name “Matty Groves” from “Fairport”. The difference between the two “Matty Groves’” is always obvious. For a start, the one at #4 struggles with the English language…]
40. the story is always about YOU !!
bob ,   New Zealand   (07.01.10)
Why dont you talkbackers protest about the STONING instead of crying about being the victims of hypocrisy. Unbelieveable!
41. YOU ARE HURLING STONER IN A GLASSHOUSE !!!.
Arn. ,   SWEDEN.   (07.01.10)
THIS WAS ALSO THE LAW GIIVEN BY JEHOVAH IN HISTORICAL ISRAEL. SHALL YOU NOT SPEAK AGAINST THE LAW IN THE TORAH IN THE BIBLE, AND AGAINST RELIGIOUS ISRAEL FIRST OF ALL ???. IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND WHY THIS LAW WAS GIVEN, YOU SHOULD NOT SPEAK OR WRITE IN THIS MATTER AT ALL. YOU ARE NOT SMARTER THAN JEHOVAH OR UNDERSTANDS SOCIETY AND HUMAN NATURE BETTER THAN HIM - DO YOU ???. I AM SURE THAT JEHOVAH CAN EXPLAIN THIS LAW, AND WHY IT WAS GIVEN, TO FULL SATISFACTION TO ANY SOBER MIND. I DO NOT REGARD YOU AS A SOBER MIND, AND WILL THEREFORE NOT THREEW THE PEARL OF EXPLANATION TO YOU IN THIS MATTER. Arn.
42. NR 19.
Arn. ,   SWEDEN.   (07.01.10)
YOU ARE DELUDING YOURSELF !!!. WHAT YOU ARE BRAGING ABOUT IS APOSTACY. ISRAEL IN THE TIME OF MOSES, WAS A WOMAN, PROMISED MARRIAGE BY AND BETROTTHED TO YEHOVAH. ISRAEL/THE WOMAN, WITH ONE VOICE, HAD SAID YES, TO THE CONDITION FOR THIS MARRIAGE, THAT IS, THE LAW SHOULD THIS WOMEN THEN, GO AND COMIT FORNICATION WITH ANOTHER MAN ???. IF SO AND EXCUSED, JEHOVAH WOULD NOT BE HOLY, BUT A FORNICATOR, AND HE WOULD NOT BE A GOD OF TRUTH EITHER. IF YOU ARE A BELIEVER IN JEHOVAH AS GOD, YOU WOULD KNOW THAT EVERYTHING IS EITHER, RIGHT OR WRONG, LIGHT OR DARKNESS, GOOD OR EVIL AND WHAT IS WRONG/EVIL , ACCORDING TO THE TRUTH/LAW, MUST BE PUNISHED, OTHERWISE SOCIETY WILL BREAK DOWN. MALAKI 4 verses - 4"Remember ye the Law of Moses, My servant, which I commanded unto him in Horeb for all Israel, with the statutes and judgments. 5"Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the LORD. 6And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers, lest I come and smite the land with a curse." NOW - IN THIS CASE - THE WOMAN HAS DELIBRETLY COMITTED FORNICATION, ALBAIT KNOWING THE PUNISHMENT FOR SUCH AN ACTION - WHAT THEN WOULD JEHOVAH DO IN THIS SITUATION ??? CURSE THE LAND/ISRAEL, AS IN MALAKI ABOVE, OR, SACRIFICE/PUNISH THE DELIBRET LAWBREAKER ???. ISRAEL/THE WOMAN OF TODAY, IS WILLING TO SACRIFICE AN INNOCENT LAMB, GILAD SHALIT, FOR HER THOUGHT OF SECURITY , BUT NOT AN ADULTERESS !!!. TAKE YOUR PICK !!!. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWSATpx7uzk Arn.
43. To: No. 36
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.01.10)
Excellent advice. I think that Austria should clean its backyard of all the Nazi collaborators and neo-Nazis. So, when are you planning to start?
44. #12
Phil ,   Ireland   (07.01.10)
I don't agree the Law ended with the birth of Jesus. What Jesus was showing was that all are guilty of breaking it and we need a Saviour/Messiah. The same people wanting to stone the adulterer were deserving of the stoning themselves.
45. This injustice is terrible, use it to defend your injustice
Miss Direction ,   USA   (07.01.10)
If other countries do terrible things, how can people criticize the terrible things that Israel does? It makes no sense, people should cirticize every terrible thing in equal measure
46. IRAN POOR WOMAN
PPP   (07.01.10)
YOU ARE SO RIGHT THE WORLD HAS ITS HEAD IN THE GROUND JUST LIKE A OSTRICH.. WHEN THEY TAKE THEIR HEADS OUT THEY WILL BE RULED BY THE MUSLIMS...... JUST LIKE THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE
47. Human Rights vs $$$? No Chance
B ,   Switzerlans   (07.01.10)
48. To Sarah
mssavion ,   houston, texas   (07.01.10)
Sarah, it is worth signing on to Y-net just to read your brilliant talkbacks...Kol Ha Kavod Lach! We need you to continue to spread the truth.... it is so refreshing to read your comments.
49. k1w1 #35 care to show us any condemnations?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.01.10)
How about something from the UN, or the so-called Human Rights Commission? I sure haven't read anything for them. How about the EU, no deep dark silence. Perhaps the US - no Odumba has said absolutely nothing. IRC - no. I have it Amnesty International - the silence is deafening. How about HRW - not much. Maybe the government of New Zealand? Do you have anything from those paragons of virture? I sure haven't seen anything.
50. Stoning in the Bible
Abie Dee ,   New York, US   (07.02.10)
Wendell, let's also remember that Judaism has not carried out 'stoning' in over 2000 years...so when will Islam become 'enlightened' ?
51. To: Ms. Savion at No. 48
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.02.10)
Thank you very much for your kind words!
52. #7
(07.02.10)
of course there were plenty of reactions during netanyaho's speech at the un general asembly exposing all the hypocricy of the world nations to these barbarian regimes and also saying that human rights in the un is a joke, particularly when lybia and cuba hold the podium there as well as IRAN JUST COTED TO BE THE HEAD OF THE WOMEN HUMAN RIGHTS ASSEMBLY. HOW ABOUT THAT ONE??? IRAN IS ON THE WOMEN HUMAN RIGHTS ASSEMBLY PANEL. IS THAT joke or what??? israel repeatedly warned the world about such cases as homosexuals being hanged in iran, of female circumcision there, of human rights abuses there of monorities. BUT NO ONE WANTS TO LITEN TO THE ISRAELI AUTHORITY BECAUSE EVERYONE IS TOO BUSY CONDEMNING THE ONLY DEMOCRACY IN THE MID EAST, ISRAEL, AND CLOSING THEIR EYES TO THE SEVERE HUMAN RIGHTS ATROCITIES COMMITTED BY IRAN, BY ARAB NATIONS AND BY MUSLIM NATIONS THAT SIT ON THE VERY PANEL HUMAN RIGHTS) WHICH THEY ABUSE WITH IMPUNITY! HAMEED ABOUGHAZE, IRANIAN
53. It the problem capital punishment or how its carried out?
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (07.02.10)
Here in Texas we carry out a lot of executions for certain crimes. Stoning, lethal injection, hanging or firing squad(like Utah just did) are all just ways to carry out capital punishment. I am not sure the crime it worthy of death but each country has their own laws. So is it the death penalty that is the problem for this crime or how it will be carried out?
54. to 52 hameed abou ghazi
noran   (07.02.10)
i feel .... that israili men writing against israil -somtimes as they think it is in benifit of their state but in case of hameed i think you get money in one hand and write with the same hand ..i think you have only one hand to write and get money .sure israil do not pay only after you are writing
55. What happened exactly?
Cynic #2   (07.02.10)
The situation requires clarification before passing judgment: 1-Did the woman connive with the two men to kill her husband and then had sex willingly with them? 2-Were the two men having sex with the woman willingly and then her husband discovered them and then they killed him? 3-Was the woman raped by the two men? Case #3 is very clear: if they was raped then she is innocent and stoning her to death is a crime. In the other two case, the woman is guilty of adultery and the Islamic law is clear: stoning to death for the married adulteress. As for the killers, it is the death sentence. In Islamic society, sex outside marriage (when caught and/or confessed) carries a punishment according to the status of the players. the Western values are for the West and not for Islamic society, so keep your Western values to yourselves. when in Rome, do (and behave) as the Romans do!
56. Gee is for Joke.
k1w1 ,   NZ   (07.02.10)
Do you want to know why the UN, the Human Rights Council, the EU, the US, Amnesty International and even the NZ government hasn’t condemned this brutal sentence handed down by the Iranian court? It’s because all those organisations and governments don’t care about human rights abuses in Iran. In fact, they all support Iran’s human rights abuses, especially this particular case! They all think the woman deserves what’s coming to her! That’s why the deafening silences. Furthermore, every one of those organisations and governments (and a few more besides, like the Red Cross) are actually incorrigible anti-Semite racists who tell terrible lies about Israel. Is that what you wanted to hear, Gee? Does that make you feel better? Good. Now, go away and play in your sandpit. [Aside to the adults: sometimes you have to tell these brats blatant nonsense just to shut ‘em up. And even then…]
57. k1w1 #56 big mouth no facts
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.02.10)
You made a claim and I merely asked for any of those condemnations and as usual you lies are proven for all to read. Why is that whenever anybody asks for proof, all we get is lies and evasions? Could it be that you have no facts? I wouldn't know because you have never offered any. What a stupid moron
58. #57. Gee.
k1w1 ,   NZ   (07.03.10)
What facts are you demanding I supply you with this time? Do you need me to prove that the West (US, EU, etc.) and the UN, Amnesty, HRC, et al, have, in fact, issued countless condemnations of Iran’s human rights record over the years? Try and Google it yourself, you lazy brat - you’ll find literally thousands of examples. Or are you referring to this particular case? Well, you’re quite right. It’s difficult to find any condemnation from any humanitarian organisations or from any government (including Israel’s) concerning Sakineh Ashitani’s sentence. So what’s your point? Are you trying to imply that Western governments and organisations like Amnesty aren’t interested in censuring Iran’s human rights abuse? That they’re only interested in telling terrible, terrible lies about Israel? Because they’re all anti-Semite racists? Is that how it goes, Gee? I’ve played this silly little game with you before (and Cynthia, too) - you know, when you demand proof and facts, and then when they are provided from sound and reputable sources (i.e., the Red Cross, the World Food Programme, etc) you simply dismiss them all as lies told by organisations that are anti-Semitic… [sigh]. Really, Gee, your childish behaviour becomes more tiresome with each post.
59. hey it's not happening in Ysrael!
jimmie c boswell ,   denver colo usa   (07.06.10)
so why would, the rest of the world even care? you know the ruckus, the world would make, if this was done in Yerusalem, by Ysralee's. it's ok for palestineans, to stone jews. but it is not ok, for jews to throw stone back. it is ok for them, to thow, firecrackes at jew. but it is not ok, for jews to pick em up, light em and throw em back. shalomcha!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article