News
Gazans: We were used as 'human shields'
Ynet
Published: 06.07.10, 00:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
1. :: The most cowardly soldiers in the world
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.06.10)
In March of this year two internal inquiries conducted by the Israeli Military police concluded that there was no basis for the claims that the IDF used civilians as human shields during Op Cast Lead. These inquiries where of course a complete cover up to hid the fact that the IDF do indeed systematically use innocent civilians as human shields while in combat zones. The IDF has gone on the record and admitted that it has used civilians as human shields a staggering 1,400 times between 2000 and 2005. Men, women and even children have been used as human shields by the IDF, forced at gunpoint to check for bobby traps or shield so-called professional soldiers from enemy fire. This morally sickening and cowardly behavior by the IDF has continued unabated for years even after the Israeli High Court ruled (in 2005) that this practice was illegal and violates international law. By far it is this utter disregard for human life and incessant need to cower behind innocent civilians which has earned Israel soldiers the reputation for being the most cowardly soldiers in the world.
2. Seek the source
Christopher ,   Boston, MASS   (07.06.10)
and note the question if truth was of any interest
3. THIS IS ALSO THE MOST (IMM)MORAL ARMY IN THE WORLD WHICH....
SINGER ,   SINGAPORE   (07.06.10)
STOLE CREDIT CARDS FROM THE PEACEFUL FLOTILLA ACTIVISTS N USED THEM........BRAVO WAY TO GO.
4. No wonder
Boris ,   Ge   (07.06.10)
They were scared of Goldstone. He was right all along.
5. Statements without Verification
Truthseeker45 ,   United States   (07.06.10)
Good reporting would empasize that these are unsubstantiated statements. Without mentioning that there is no proof these statements become the truth. A shameful piece of journalism.
6. Gazans used as human shields
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.06.10)
By Hamas.
7. German and Serb Intl Law Violators were Prosecuted
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (07.06.10)
Why is the world allowing Israel to protect the Israeli International Law violators, and those that gave them their orders and those that allowed this to happen?
8. This was war - Allies doing far worse in Iraq
Avi ,   Israel   (07.06.10)
9. the testimonies
natalie ,   molinari   (07.06.10)
by all the israelis hurt by plestinian suicide bombers and terrorist attacks, would easily top any other claim of being the "victim". if true or not, this article means nothing. as long as terror is still around the corner, we don't owe them a thing!
10. All wars that Israel has waged have been just, forced ...
Ron B. ,   Lod   (07.06.10)
All wars that Israel has waged have been just, forced upon it by the Arab leaders. War involves life-and-death situations; mistakes are made and innocents inevitably die. But in maintaining our moral standards, we should never forget that the IDF is an army of the people and we are also obliged to ensure that we do not go to the other extreme and endanger the lives of our soldiers by preventing them from defending themselves. As to the blood libels against Israel and the IDF : http://xrl.us/be8dzf
11. shields
colin   (07.06.10)
Hamas says. ONLY LIES FOR THE PRESS TO REPORT. The media are so anti Israel they twist the story and believe the arabs.
12. Israelis dont care
Michael ,   USA   (07.06.10)
Israelis dont care, they have no problem when Palestinians are abused and harmed by their soldiers. In fact, they are proud of it. This report is not worth the paper it was printed on.
13. :: No complaints when Hamas is them as shields
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.06.10)
Which is always.
14. :: Schalit also human shield but Arab NGO don't investigate
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.06.10)
15. OH MY GOD
(07.06.10)
this is sick. USA please drop Israel and have the Hauge investigate for war crimes.
16. hamass lies, they are alive and still complaining, what else
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (07.06.10)
17. So what? Palestinians use Israeli civilians as TARGETS!
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (07.06.10)
I'm sick of the Palestinian whining that yanks the heartstrings of liberal westerners and drives their IQ down by a factor of 10. Palestinian official policy is to use Israeli civilians as TARGETS! That's a war crime! It's been Palestinian policy for decades! It's time to put Abbas and Haniya on trial for war crimes! This is decades of policy for suicide bombings, driveby shootings, knifings in the street - all by Palestinians with the explicit target of killing Israeli civilians. Stop listening to the whining Palestinians and put them on trial for their crimes against humanity. If you don't like listening to me, then you'll just love Judge Goldstone: "... the [Goldstone] report contains the clearest finding that Hamas and other militant Palestinian groups committed serious war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity. The acceptance of those findings by the Human Rights Council and the General Assembly has been ignored completely..." Richard Goldstone, Interviewed by Ha'aretz, Nov 13 2009
18. yeah right, y a year after the war they complain
ghostq   (07.06.10)
because it never happened. I have seen photage of IDF in cast lead, there was no other human beside IDF soldiers, these palis forgot they can't prove their claim, people can say many things, but it doesn't mean it's true.
19. what did american soldiers do in irak
(07.06.10)
and to those in gueantanamo bay...and I don't just mean the rape of a iraki girl and the killing of her family. But at least there was in investigation and a trial. Those who comitted crimes had a chance to a fair trial. Commenters here already crucified israel again before it's even proven these allegations are true. I have seen so many pallywood lies already, but you don't seem to care Israel deserves a trial. You already made up your mind.
20. either stories are false or Hamas never used booby traps
observer   (07.06.10)
21. BOOO HOOO - I couldn't care less
Israel   (07.06.10)
Neither could anyone else.
22. matty/1
james ,   london   (07.06.10)
yes the idf enemy all wear millatary uniforms...this is not a conventional conflict but for the likes of you the idf should play by the rules while the outher side have no rules of engagement .....you just are so blind of the facts.
23. cowards
av ,   london.uk   (07.06.10)
matty groves. the US army are the only cowards see vietnam combodia ,korea ,iraq and afganistan the only victory is in grenada but this small country have no army only police forces
24. Brilliant British analysis of Hamas - watch this!
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (07.06.10)
http://www.youtube.com/user/nolaughingmattr#p/a/u/1/CIDLoUbS8YU
25. #20 what in hell are you refering to?
better observer   (07.06.10)
since logic has never been your strong suit, your condition in the asylum must have worsened and there is no light at the end of the tunnel
26. probebly wrong but even if thats true then nothing special
Omri ,   Israel   (07.06.10)
Look at it this way: if this was a lie would this still be worth saying? If its found true the soldiers would obviestly be put on trail but this isn't something an officer decided remember that, this is a few indeviduals who did decide on this sort of things. This kind of crimes are done in all wars of all countries really because not all soldiers are good people.
27. wrong headline
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (07.06.10)
To understand why the headline is wrong, we should look at some history. First there were two soldiers from a Leftist pre-military academy who said they saw war crimes. Turned out they rehashed false rumors to hit on some girls. Then "Breaking the Silence" organization, funded by the New Israel Fund (NIF) reported war crimes. These were also invented by "Breaking the Silence" members, two non-athletic people living in mom's basement. Then Goldstone wrote his famed report based exclusively on "evidence" from the NIF-funded BeTselem organization. BeTselem reports have been proven time and again to be false. Now PCATI and Adalah (both NIF funded) rehash the same lies. The headline should have been "European-funded NIF once again accuses IDF of war crimes" Yawn
28. "exclusively obtained by Ynet "
Efrat ,   Tel Aviv   (07.06.10)
Is it a joke or something? what to be proud off? Ynet - are working for Hamas or made it all by yourself to be "exclusive"? any source or proof?
29. The photograph of the blinded prisoners
Sean ,   Montreal, Quebec   (07.06.10)
..is a telling insight into the absence of humanity by the supposedly, "Moral Army". Are these degradable actions somehow easier to carry out if one doesn't have to look them in the eyes?
30. False testimonies
Xena   (07.06.10)
Reading this you think oh how awful and then you read again and think could this be true? Looking at who compiled the report, one could also think, well, witnesses can be coached to say anything, especially children and then you think oh well, this is just another propaganda report to vilify Israel and its army. Remember Jenin? Remember the Al Dura affair (French court concluded that the French footage was falsified) – just a few examples among many. Testimonies can be made up and sold as the truth. Unfortunately, people are quick to believe the worse of Israel and the relentless Palestinian PR machine (which includes many Israeli NGOs helping) keeps churning up lies and more lies.
Next talkbacks
Back to article