Opinion
Are we really war criminals?
Yoaz Hendel
Published: 07.07.10, 11:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
97 Talkbacks for this article
1. The most moral army in the world
Ann   (07.07.10)
2. Thr most immoral army in the whole universe
(07.07.10)
3. #1
Mike ,   USA   (07.07.10)
hahaha who are you kidding? You obviously don't pass through the checkpoints on a daily basis.
4. Ha hahahahahahhahahahaha ......:(
Salma ,   Palestine   (07.07.10)
Mr.Yoaz Hendel, the next time you have to respect the readers, and write to them without being drunk ! I'm afraid you are expecting someone to answer you, no, You're white peace doves!!!!
5. Accountable
Ussishkin ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (07.07.10)
We need to be accountable to ourselves, never mind to anyone outside. This is not about report writers, it is about being responsible for our actions.
6. The Israeli soldiers
Alistair ,   Scotland   (07.07.10)
Are a right bad lot.Have a look over youtube and thats only the stuff someone has managed to film. I'd say the IDF soldiers are comparable with no soldiers in the western world and russia
7. the i d f
a ash ,   newark nj   (07.07.10)
thank gd the tzahal is the most moral in the world . the code of ethics they work under puts them at risk and they are bound to it . kol hakavod
8. :: Yes the IDF have committed War Crimes
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
The title of this post is not an opinion it is a statement of fact. Yoaz Hendel’s article is a pathetic attempt at self-serving hasbara and obviously assumes that many readers are ignorant of the war crimes and human rights abuses committed by Israelis against Palestinians ever since the military occupation of Palestine began in 1947. War crimes themselves are very clearly defined within International law and the fact that the IDF has committed war crimes is not in doubt, for example: ‘Collective Punishment’ can be described simply as “punishing the majority for the crimes of the few”, Israel has committed this war crimes on a daily basis for the last four years by blockading the Gaza Strip in attempt to ‘punish’ the civilian population of Gaza in order to weaken the Hamas power base and secure the release of a captured IDF soldier. ‘Using civilians as human shields’, this cowardly war crime is actually IDF policy and is utterly unjustifiable. Hendel paints a picture of Palestinians ‘begging’ the IDF to act as human shields, this utter fabrication is laughable when compared to the reports of men, women and even children forced at gunpoint to enter buildings which may contain gunmen or bobby traps or act as actual physical shields to protect the IDF from live fire. ‘Targeting of civilians’ and wanton destruction of civilian infrastructure are clearly war crimes. Top Israeli generals have openly admitted that they have planned and committed attacks against civilian homes and infrastructure. For example General Gadi Eisenkot went on the record to state: "We will wield disproportionate power against every village from which shots are fired on Israel, and cause immense damage and destruction”. The utter obliteration of entire civilian neighborhoods in Gaza by the IDF/IAF was indiscriminate at best or deliberately planned at worst. The three examples of IDF war crimes listed above are all very well documented and condemned by such bodies as Israeli/International HR Orgs, NGOs, UN, Goldstone, etc. There is nothing hypocritical or hateful about acknowledging Israeli war crimes, such labelling is just an attempt to divert attention away from these war crimes and lessen their impact. Apologists like Hendel will try and defend the IDF in their cowardly and inhumane crimes by whitewashing the truth yet nobody is fooled except a small handful of Ynuts who lap up this hasbara as it reinforces their delusional belief that the IDF is ‘the most moral army in the world’. Until such time as Israel becomes something more than a failed military state and above all stops the occupation of the Palestinians and their land these war crimes will continue. Only by acknowledging, accepting responsibility and addressing these war crimes will Israeli society begin to fix the moral malady which has rooted itself so firmly within the Israeli psyche.
9. Israel’s media people…
Ron B. ,   Lod   (07.07.10)
One would think that Israel’s media people and academics would see the danger of allowing Israel to be painted as a genocidal occupier and would speak out and tell the world how tolerant and compassionate Israel has been towards her enemies — a veritable suffering Job among nations. Instead it is the same people in the media and universities who amplify the pro-Arab lies and distortions. They “admit” sins they never committed, and furnish intellectual rationalizations for the most convoluted arguments raised by their adversaries, rather than take up their country’s defense even when its conduct is beyond reproach as explained at : http://xrl.us/bi5da
10. #6 Alistair
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (07.07.10)
Have you heard of the atrocities UK soldiers are doing in Afghanistan? The number of civilians your troops murder just for fun is appalling, especially considering that no one (not even your PM) knows why you are in Afghanistan. And what do you say about the revelations that the UK tortures innocents so badly that you will now pay them reparations?
11. #8...
Dana Rothschild ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.07.10)
before you accuse Israel of war crimes, check your army in Iraq and Afghanistan... start to clean your own yard, before you clean mine....
12. YES you are
wert ,   us   (07.07.10)
convict idf war criminals
13. Mike @ 3, why do you go through check point?
leo ,   usa   (07.07.10)
14. what a delusional article
(07.07.10)
15. yes, you are. hope that helps
(07.07.10)
16. :: Israel Israeli - #10 - How is this relevant?
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
What has this to do with an article which is specific to Israeli war crimes? If you want to talk about War Crimes committed by UK soldiers in Afghanistan why don’t you go to an appropriate British website? Obviously you are just trying to deflect the subject matter, why are you trying to do this? Do you think that by shifting the topic this will make Israeli war crimes less of an issue?
17. IDF is truly the most moral army
Duchess   (07.07.10)
Yay! IDF!!!
18. Answer the title question?
Ilana   (07.07.10)
We are NOT
19. I wonder why the hamas
Ilana   (07.07.10)
never questions itself??????? That is the proof.
20. No ! You are not war criminals
DT ,   TA Israel   (07.07.10)
As far as I am concerned you are heroes and great ones at that. The ones that are criminals are the ones trying to bring charges against you
21. :: Ilana - #18
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
Thank you for your baseless opinion. Please feel free to back this up with facts at any stage.
22. NO! ...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.07.10)
But at least we're mature enough to ask ourselves the question. I'm sure it isn't that way on the other side.
23. #16, Alistair was claiming the UK was better
Danny   (07.07.10)
when it clearly isn't. The fact that not a single army in the world manages to never ever kill civilians when fighting this sort of war should tell you something about the "crimes" you whine about. Note to date not a single person in the world anywhere has successfully prosecuted an Israeli for war crimes of any sort whatsoever.
24. #21, pot and kettle
Danny   (07.07.10)
exactly what "facts" do you bring to bear? Mindlessly parrotting anti-Israeli propaganda?
25. to Matty Groves # 8
Ralf ,   Paris ,France   (07.07.10)
the true question is : what did preceeds what ? Cast Lead op. or thousand rocket firing to Israel from Gaza ? Think about it before ,whenever you can.Only smart people can.
26. matty matty
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (07.07.10)
The relevance is clear. You write whatever distorted out-of-context "facts" you want, but Israel is not committing any war crimes. If Israel is to be accused, it would make sense to first accuse and try countries which deeds are clearly far worse (US, UK, Turkey, Russia, Syria) before accusing Israel. Once a "bright line" is drawn as to what constitutes a war crime (Obama's massacre of 80 Afghans for instance) and what does not, we could discuss Israel's deeds. Unlike the self-righteous Alistair, you know exactly what I meant and bandy terms like "war crime" just for propaganda purposes.
27. The IDF
Mary Elizabeth   (07.07.10)
Answer: No they are not. And please note, at least they ask themselves and question and check more than any other army or terror group. How insane to expect a terror group to question its humanity!
28. :: Danny - #24
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
What facts would you like to deny? The fact that the IDF admitted that it used innocent civilians as human shields a whopping 1,200 times between 2000 & 2005? http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3154142,00.html Danny if it illegal and immoral for say Hamas to use civilians as human shields (as the IDF is on the record for saying) why is it okay for the IDF to use civilians as human shields? Why do the IDF force unarmed civilians to check for bombs and gunmen? For example why was this 11 yr old forced to check for bombs? http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3691073,00.html Danny why was this Palestinian kid tied to the front of a jeep to protect it from stone throwers? http://attendingtheworld.files.wordpress.com/2008/03/palestinian-boy-as-human-shield-by-nazionists.jpg
29. :: Ralf - #25
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
Are you trying to justify these Israeli war crimes because of rocket attacks on Israel? Are you trying to say that just because a militant group commits war crimes Israel is justified in committing even worse war crimes against a civilian population in response? I would also add that the use of human shields by the IDF far precedes these rocket attacks you mention.
30. :: Israel Israeli - #26 - Are you insane?!
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.07.10)
Are you utterly insane? Do you not realize that the current international laws which outlaw such war crimes against civilian populations were drawn up after WWII? Do you not recall that Nuremberg Trials which tried Nazi war criminals for war crimes?!!! Clearly you are ignorant on international law and your own history. Let me explain to you what ‘constitutes a war crime’: Imprisoning an entire civilian populace into an enclosed place and depriving them of basic human rights and basic sustenance. You may recall that this happened in Warsaw in 1940 and again in Gaza in 2006.
Next talkbacks
Back to article