News
Ahmadinejad: Palestinian refugees will return home
AFP
Published: 08.07.10, 07:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
31. for once he is right
Lisa   (07.08.10)
The era of dictatorship is over," just for once the monkey man is right- down with dictators! As for Palestinias returning - good- they can go to Jordan, Syria, Egypt etc... maybe even Turkey? Get out of Europe too... Life will be good!
32. Palestinian
KEEP DREAMING ABOUT ,   NOW JEWISH ISRAEL   (07.08.10)
keep dreaming.Israel will not accept them and they will never return same as the JEWS will never return back to their homeland in ISLAMIC countries
33. I rarely get hot under the collar but...
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (07.08.10)
I rarely get ‘hot under the collar’ but in this instance it’s a case of Here we go again with grubby interference into Palestinian affairs I posted a Talkback yesterday about the positive signs that Abbas and Netanyahu may recommence negotiations which is on the cards Agreements will be reached by accommodation on both sides But here is a CLASSIC example of that grubby man trying to wreck talks by trying to act as the Palestinian Representative speaking for the Palestinian people! Whether its Ahmadinejad, Nasrallah and his poodle Mashaal…their interest is NOT the Palestinians but their own self interest AT THE EXPENSE of Palestinians. They are the criminals holding the peace process back We elected Abbas to take the talks forward not that little jumped up mentally challenged upstart who is trying to control the self determination of the Palestinian people.
34. #1 - I'm not a Bedouin.
lara ,   Australia   (07.08.10)
My family name suggests that my family originated in a town called Al-Damoun but my family home was in Haifa, so when can i move back?
35. BETTER WITHOUT ISLAM
TROUBLE MAKER MUSLIM ,   THE WORLD WOULD BE   (07.08.10)
MUSLIMS ARE NOTHING BUT T R O U B L E IN THE WORLD TROUBLE MAKERS ONLY
36. #33 Thank you!
Yakov ,   Tel Aviv   (07.08.10)
The best comment yet. I hope both of our "sides" honestly sit down and work this out. Peace for all of us. Your children and mine should live in peace, see each other as friends, and rejoice at the beauty of each others cultures. I look forward to the day where my Palestinian neighbor and my family sit together for dinner. Peace to you and your family.
37. Lara ± 34
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (07.08.10)
That was history.Stay in Australia you will be much better off.
38. #9 - Why are you blaming us for the actions of Nazi's?
lara ,   Australia   (07.08.10)
What Hitler did was terrible, not only to Jews but to many others as well. But it was not our fault so do not blame the Palestinians for death camps located on the other side of the globe. Why should we be forced to absorb Jews who fled from Nazi europe only to be forced out of our homes? My family did not injure or kill a single Jew, yet we had to suffer because of the Nazi's. You got a Jewish state, our homes and billions of dollars in aid and repairations while all we got was a one way ticket to nowhere with only the clothes on our back. My family went from living peacefully, with money, jobs and a house to nothing, not even 1 dollar. It took us forever to rebuild our lives in Lebanon before moving to Australia and we were the lucky ones. Many others were not so fortunate. You have no right to blame us or even involve us in any argument backed by the Holocaust.
39. #37 -
lara ,   Australia   (07.08.10)
No, history was thousands of years ago. Palestine was 62 years ago.
40. To HOME we shall return
Nour ,   Palestine   (07.08.10)
Not because Ahmadinejad said it but because we love our beloved Palestine. Its touching to see young Palestinian refugees swear to return, their parents are obviously ensuring that our just cause is never forgotten. Oh and we shall also return because its our human right. Jews can also go back to Arab countries, actually they should because history will prove to them that Zionism was their death knell.
41. ±39 Lara from Australia
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (07.08.10)
Ok no history for you because it does not suit your claim.I am sure you believe in your holy book the NORTH KOREAN BOOK which says 'YA BNEI ISRAIL' who are these people and JERUSALEM IS THE CAPITAL OF ISRAEL WITH OR WITHOUT THE WORLD APPROVAL.JERUSALEM IS THE CITY OF KING SOLOMON AND KING DAVID.Who are these two KINGS.ARE they JEWS OR MUSLIMS OR ARABS.Please answer these two questions without MUSLIMS TWISTING.
42. Nour (To HOME we shall return)
JUDAH THE LION   (07.08.10)
Nour I wrote on talkback to you and Salma about this subject so many times but you both ignored to reply.The Palestinians will never return back to ISRAEL.The Muslims world can take them and they have huge land.This land is ours and no body else.Are you crazy that JEWS to back to the Arabs or Muslims land. You are suggesting JEWS to go back ONE WAY TICKET TO BE KILLED.Jews will never return back to Muslims or Arab land.jJEWS CANNOT LIVE WITH ARABS. JEWS WILL NOT BE AGAIN DHIMI END OF STORY
43. Here we go again - The ZERO SUM Game or
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (07.08.10)
Wishful thinking? Either way Nour it seems your position is a non starter - glad YOU are in a gradually disappearing MINORITY of Palestinians There are Palestinians who have lost ALOT more than you who want to make a clean break with the past and move on to a final settlement. Of course we have been wronged. But we need to stop propagating the idea that a Palestine will be born out of the destruction of Israel and focus on creating a Palestine born out of the coming together of two peoples
44. Yes go Home to Jordan and Sinai as a start
AlbertoGA ,   St. George, USA   (07.08.10)
All the rest is just Utopian Dreams dear Pals.
45. Jewish refugee from Aden
Jewish Refugee from ,   Crater ADEN   (07.08.10)
As a JEW I would prefer to live with my brothers and sisters in ZIONIST ISRAEL peacefully.In Aden Jews were living under threat and not in freedom. I will not go back to ADEN even if they pay me BILLION OF DINAR.No Jew will take risk to go back to Arab countries to live.We were lucky to escape Aden
46. #34 Moving back
Madeleine ,   Israel   (07.08.10)
NEVER!!! If your family home was in Haifa then the only people who forced you to leave were your own people fromJordan, Syria, etc. You all thought you'd be returning victorious, didn't you, after pushing all us Jews into the sea and when that didn't work out - well, you haven't stopped trying since. Israel said a the time that it wouldn't harm its Arab citizens and it didn't. witness those who stayed enjoy more rights than their brothers in any other Arab country. So stop whining, down there and keep quiet.
47. Bla bla bla
Johnny ,   Nazareth   (07.08.10)
So what ?? Iran is making these statements for 30 years now. Who cares what this madman has to say!! His words are bwaw bwaw bwaw to my ears , just like a dog.
48. Muslims hate Jews
INFIDEL (KAFER) ,   MECCA SAUDI ARABIA   (07.08.10)
why these Muslims want to live with the JEWISH KUFARIN ISRAEL.Go and live with your UMMAH
49. 26
zionist forever   (07.08.10)
UN resolution 194 is a General Assembly so it is not legally binding just a glorified proposal Israel is within its rights of rejecting. I am sure that most Israelis would have no problem with the REAL refugees returning if they chose but anybody under 62 who was born outside refugees in their own right they are decendents of refugees. Refugee status is not inheritable if it is then I am a German refugee with a right of return to Germany because my grandparents were refugees from Germany. The number of real refugees alive in the world today is probably in the low hundreds and they are not getting any younger. Why do jews have a right or return & arabs dot is simple .... Israel is an independent state and all states have the right to chose their immigration people decide who can live there and who can't. Israel was created to be a jewish state and so it chose to allow jews to move there if they wanted but not apply the same rules to non jews including the NON REFUGEE decendent of refugees
50. Salma ,Nour,& Lara
JUDAH THE LION   (07.08.10)
any comments from talkback nos 41,42,or you have agreed
51. Iranian exiled by Mollahs will return to their country
avi   (07.08.10)
well before arabs might come back here.
52. #41 - Firstly, I am not Muslim nor North Korean.
lara ,   Australia   (07.08.10)
So I have no idea what you are talking about. As for history... before your religion existed, it was the land of Canaan.
53. #42 JUDAH THE LION , There is poor understanding
Salma ,   Palestine   (07.08.10)
Nour, Salma and I did not say, we want to return to "Israel", but to Palestine our homeland
54. CLEAR THE RUBBLE
Ben S ,   Free world   (07.08.10)
Iranian nuclear sites will soon be all rubble. Once the rubble is cleared Ihmadinejad can have housing built for all the Trans-Jordanians he wishes. Bomby weather is on the way.
55. 53 There is poor understanding
JUDAH THE LION   (07.08.10)
As usual you are twisting things.There is no state called Palestine.The Roman Empire to punish the Jews have changed the name from Israel to Palestine.Palestine is part of Israel and Jerusalem the capital of Israel.Arabs have no claim whatsoever to the land of Israel.Israel and Jerusalem belong to us the JEWS and it is also written in your holy book THE NORTH KOREAN.BNEI ISRAIL WERE JEWS .and not Muslims or Arabs. Muslims and Arabs their land is in Arabia and thats why it is called SAUDI ARABIA. PLEASE DONT TWIST THINGS.
56. Lara 52
JUDAH THE LION   (07.08.10)
jEWISH RELIGION EXIST MORE THAN 5700 YEARS.The land of Canaan which is Israel was promised by the ALMIGHTY TO OUR FATHER ABRAHAM AVINU ABRAHAM AVINU GRANDSON WAS JACOB AND THE ALMIGHTY HAVE CHANGED HIS NAME FROM JACOB TO ISRAEL.Read the old testament
57. Hey #15
Ben ,   Earth   (07.08.10)
It's true "You shall return", but be careful what you wish for. You may return to your maker sooner than later if you and your Palis don't stop sending missiles into Israel.
58. Cheeky bastard "The era of dictatorships is over"
James ,   ISRAEL   (07.08.10)
Ooooh really,really?Silly fool forgets his is the BIGGEST DICTATORSHIP EVER! I am impressed [NOT]. The deluded fool forgets he is being pushed aside by the Western countries in not letting his airplanes to refuel.. Now I've heard it all from the man called: Mahmoud The baboon
59. That's a new one on me Leah? did you >>
KATE ,   ISRAEL   (07.08.10)
Leah did you per chance misspell Saeb Erekat,Or? No you are wrong about their arab brethern not wanting them sorry. The reason they are not wanted [anywhere] which includes the rest of the refugees in Syria,Lebanon since the RE-BIRTH of Israel is merely to keep them as pawns to pester the Jews/Israel and not as you surmize.
60. Salma a quick reply:
James ,   ISRAEL   (07.08.10)
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha HAH! In your worse nightmares!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article