News
Iran says US must state position on Israeli nukes
Reuters
Published: 09.07.10, 08:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel will NOT be the first to ever introduce nuclear...
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (07.09.10)
...weapons to the region!!! Furthermore, Israel has never threatened any country with annihilation, either through the use of conventional or non-conventional weapons, never. Indeed, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has never, never been involved in any attempt to conquer territory for territory's sake; to capture natural resources for the resources' sake; to subjugate people or peoples for subjugation's sake; to wipe off another state and/or people for the sake of wiping off the face of earth another state or another people. The comparison of Iran to Israel is pathetic and venomous!!!
2. Crime? WWII?
lenny ,   america   (07.09.10)
During WWII the Palestinians answered to the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Mohammad Amin al-Husayni.. During the years of World War II he was involved in recruiting Arab support for Nazi Germany. He was so close with Hitler that he was given a villa close by to the Fuhrer's. WTF!!!!!!
3. Go ask Allah.
Janice Cohen ,   ירושלים   (07.09.10)
Why should they occupy the land of the Palestinan people?
4. #1 iran says US must
Yonatan ,   Jerusalem   (07.09.10)
Don't bet on it
5. Israel is not signed Non-Proliferation treaty nor lied
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & New York   (07.09.10)
Israel is not signed Non-Proliferation treaty nor lied about compliance. Israel has never called for the destruction of another country. Israel has tried to offer a people who do not deserve their own country a state of their own. Iran on the other hand has lied, cheated, and stalled compliance with the Non-Proliferation treaty at every chance it has. Iran has called for the destruction of Israel. Iran oppresses its Arab population worse than any other country in the world.
6. Ahmadinejad : "Mr Mouth " and nukes
DT ,   TA Israel   (07.09.10)
If we have them we would not go around threatening to wipe countries off the map.
7. Ahmadinejad - We DONT want you ...
Sammy ,   Newcastle   (07.09.10)
We dont want you trying to CHAMPION the Palestinian cause WHO ASKED YOU? Because you are just using us to defeclt attention from your own inadequacies and trying to establish control over Paletstnian affairs Get out of our hair and go We dont want your totalitarian police state masquerading as a theocracy, or your extremist shia version of Islam imposed on our lives
8. #3 It's because no one else wants you anywhere close to them
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (07.09.10)
Get the picture?
9. #1 Like the case of israel offering S.Africa nukes??
Mark ,   Netherlands   (07.09.10)
Wow,so much for the most humane army of the world. Offering nukes to a dictatorship!!!
10. WHEN WILL THE US AND OBAMA WAKE UP !!!.
Arn. ,   SWEDEN.   (07.09.10)
THE HYPOCRIT SAYS - Speaking in Nigeria after a summit of the D8 group of developing nations, Ahmadinejad said Iran supported dialogue but blamed the United States for the failure of previous talks. Asked what conditions must be met for talks to resume, Ahmadinejad said Washington must make its position on Israel's nuclear strategy clear. -THOSE CONDITIONS WAS NOT MENTIONED EARLIER, SO HOW COULD THE US BE BLAMED FOR FAILED TALKS ???. FURTHER - http://www.soul.org/Legend2.html -THE WHOLE OF AFRICA WILL STAND TOGHETER WITH GOG AND MAGOG, (EZEKIEL CHAP.38-39), AGAINST THE US IN THE 3rd WORLD WAR. THE US SHOULD LEARN FROM THIS THAT - THERE IS NO OTHER OPTION THAN THE MILITARY ONE. FURTHER - THE MILITARY OPTION, AND RESORTING TO FORCE, SHOULD NOT BE THE LAST OPTION AGAINST IRANS NUCLEAR PROGRAM. THIS IS CIVIL THOUGHTS AND PRINCIPS OF CONDUCTING FORCE IN THE CIVIL SOCIETY. IF THERE SHOULD BE AN MILITARY OPTION AGAINS IRAN AT ALL, IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE FIRST OPTION AS A SURPRISE MILITARY STRIKE. NOW AS THE FOOLS AND IDIOTS THEY ARE, THEY HAVE WARNED IRAN MANY YEARS IN ADVANCE FOR THE MILITARY OPTION, GIVING IRAN MANY YEARS FOR TO PREPERE THEIR DEFENCE, AND CONTRA STRIKE. THEY WILL PAY DEARLY FOR THIS, AS IRAN WILL TAKE THE WEST IN THEIR SCROTUMS. Arn.
11. So much for isolating iran and this man!!
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (07.09.10)
He was just received with open arms in yet another country(regardless of the status of the host country). Oh,I forgot, He was also received in Switzerland with open arms!!! This only shows were your blabbering stands and were money stands. They have something very important to offer!!!
12. Talk about a brainless human being
Eric..... ,   Israel....   (07.09.10)
How the Iranian people can put up with this imbecile,I find it difficult to fathom.He wants too wipe Israel of the face of the earth,he has said this a millon times.The 3rd world war is on its way.This man is a threat to world peace,and the world are not doing a thing too stop this lunatic.
13. no 9
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (07.09.10)
You talk about dictatorships and humane armies etc. Mark,so why are most of the Islamic states around the globe dictatorships and what about the humane Afghanistan armed forces ,in fested with Taliban opium fuelled killers and spies,who only report to their sadistic tribal warlords in Swat whilst cold bloodedly killing innocent Afghans on their daily commutes or shopping at their local markets ,you really ned some therapy ,rather quick?
14. no 6
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (07.09.10)
I have yet to see these huge but silly May day shows of miltary might ,nuclear missiles etc. mounted on trucks rolling down the main drag in Tel Aviv ,have you ever seen them DT ,no so why do these dumb Palestinians like Peter in Vienna imply so?
15. What "Israeli nukes"?
(07.09.10)
16. Sad Peter..Supporter of Ahmadinejad
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (07.09.10)
As long YNET lets your dumb posts through, you're happy. BTW, for the record, here's a weapon we invented... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VH7MHFQYPs Your hate doesn't want you to believe we can create, sad
17. Mmm - Ah MAD inejad your hero Peter?
Mr Green ,   Manchester   (07.09.10)
Have him with our blessings! Please? Im sure Austria would love to have him And wed all love to see all Austrian men Peter walking around cloned with the same hilarious haircuts as your beloved idol Ah MAD inejad
18. Isolation
Tal   (07.09.10)
Can we isolate this guy's mouth? Do more for the goal of world peace than any other single thing. Good yuntef Mr. A.
19. reminds me of a storye
ghostq   (07.09.10)
one of the stories I was told before going asllep was about dav and golyeth, golyeth as a big strong guy with a big sward and dav was little but he had a catapul which he threw at golyeth and killed him. the moral of the storye is that israel is like golyeth, big and strong, and will be ok as long as the pals don’t trow sum thing at israel. they tried to destroy golyeth with boms and guns but trhey couldn’t same with israel.
20. Israel will hand over its nukes soon to UN body for demolish
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (07.09.10)
21. Logical question, Bravo Mr. Ahmadinejad
Salma ,   Palestine   (07.09.10)
"Israel's" nuclear weapons:The elephant in the room!! but unfortunately, no one cares!
22. If cops can have guns why can't criminals?
(07.09.10)
That's Ahmadinejad's line of reasoning, in blunt terms. And there is a sizeable portion of the Left who buy into this. Dennis Prager is right; we're living in an age of no wisdom.
23. The Ape man is a role model and an
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (07.09.10)
inspiration for a lunatic asylum...
24. Mr Nice Guy
EJ ,   UK/TA   (07.09.10)
I am sick and tied of Israel playing Mr Nice guy. Time to give this crook a taste of his own medicine. We dont have to justify any of actions to anyone in this world nor do we have to declare any of our bombs. Double standards? Too right it is on our part, but this is Israel, the greatest nation ever. G-ds land, OUR LAND, the Jews. Give this verminous drek, Iran, some attitude too. They dont scare us, no one scare us. NO SURRENDER Baruch Hashem
25. Israel should never.
John ,   Accra,Ghana   (07.09.10)
If Israel gives out it's weapons that will be suicide..The muslims nations are afraid to attack Israel because of it's nukes..build more nukes secret Israel.
26. supposed nukes
Non-Jew ,   England   (07.09.10)
I believe the comment from #9 is a result of a recent article in the British left wing (and venomously anti -Israel) newspaper 'The Guardian' , concerning some classified Israeli documents from the 1970s that have just , due to the time factor, become non-secret. One of them apparantly showed that, in the '70's, Israel was approached by S. Africa with regard to supplying S-A with some missile casings, of sufficient size that they could conceivably have been used take a nuclear payload. There was no eviidence in the original document that these cases were ever supplied, and also no evidence of what kind of payload the SAs actually intended to use them for - only that the requested casings weren't small! However, by changing a few key words and adding a few more that were not actually in the original document, the 'journalist' (and I use that term most loosely here) involved managed to give the impression that they were for nuclear use, and then leaped ahead in his article to suggest that Israel not only supplied the casings, but also their nuclear payload. This artical has already been completely debunked (pls. ref. the website of CIFwatch - I do not have a link to hand), but , as is usual in the case of israel-bashers, this has been ignored by the anti-israel mob, and sufficient bandying about of lying tittle-tattle has resulted in this now becoming their accepted version of events (little things like facts are such a nuisance to keep up with, after all). In my opinion, as soon as someone has to lie, or even distort the truth, to get their argument across, they obviously have no genuine argument to start off with - and that sadly seems to cover the vast majority of the c**p that disseminates from the muslim / lefty alliance of the anti-israel camp. But apparantly , If you throw enough s**t , some of it sticks, no matter what.
27. Just 1-2 months earlier Obama would be supporting the monkey
zionist forvever   (07.09.10)
Now though he has met with Bibi and is now on the defensive as a result of the approaching midterms and after that he has about 6 months before he has to start concentrating on the 2012 presidential election. With elections this close Obama can't risk calling for Israel to be disarmed and has to deal with Iran as an issue in itself and not linked to Israel. The west is now sick of playing the monkey games they have been since early in George Bushes second term and are in favor of sanctions and Obama has to continue to support them because if he doesn't the pressure will be on him to take military action. Here you go Ahmadinejad have a banana before they are banned.
28. #21 That's right, people just don't care...
Janice Cohen ,   ירושלים   (07.09.10)
and that's why we'll keep em, if we got em.
29. #25 Sorry you could'nt go further...
Janice Cohen ,   ירושלים   (07.09.10)
in the World Cup. I was pulling for you.
30. To No. 25, John, You are great...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (07.09.10)
and You have a lot of courage, to take such a strong position... It is clear: ISRAEL M U S T HAVE NUCLEAR WEAPONS...!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and Israel has the moral right to have nuclear weapons. Everybody who says otherwise, is an enemy of Israel and hopes for the destruction of Israel...
Next talkbacks
Back to article