News
32 homes approved in Pisgat Ze'ev
Ronen Medzini
Published: 12.07.10, 20:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel must offer an ultimatum.
Jake ,   USA   (07.12.10)
Take Jerusalem off the table, or WE will not engage in peace talks. I've always supported Bibi, but this man is a coward when it comes to Jerusalem.
2. Obama does'nt know ?
Janice Cohen ,   ירושלים   (07.12.10)
The question should be : Beyond rhetoric does Obama really care? After his latest meeting with Netenyahu he is slowly learning the parameters of his authority.
3. My answer to Meretz
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.12.10)
Who the hell cares what Odumba knows or thinks? It's our land and we will do what we want. If anybody in the world doesn't like that answer they can go take a flying leap.
4. Change in US tactics and this plays into it
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (07.12.10)
US still pushing for talks but now PA will likely declare itself a state, since Netanyahu has indicated that his hands are tied and if he agreed to 2 state solution now that his Gov. would likely fall. Looks like abit of trickery on both sides and continued building plays right into it. If US, EU and Russia recognize new PA state then Israel would have to seriously deal and Netanyahu would have some cover.
5. Anyone who thinks Jews, because they are Jewish, shouldn't
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (07.12.10)
move and live in a given neighborhood, be it in Washington, DC or Jerusalem, DC (Jerusalem, David's City) is a racist, and that includes the President of the U.S. and his Secretary of State!!!
6. Is Meretz even part of the coalition?
rebecca ,   Modiin   (07.12.10)
They just dont count, especially will dumb comments like that.
7. Jerusalem Planning Committee
Michael ,   Haifa   (07.12.10)
Some of us here in Haifa think that a tin-pot committee in the Jerusalem Municipality should not be running the affairs of the State of Israel
8. Traitors in Ynet? What a shock!
Ann   (07.12.10)
9. Here we go again,...
split ,   usa   (07.12.10)
Obama made a fool of himself undersigning israeli "good will" and the world is watching,...
10. Obamba And dumbocrats needs to help me find a job
New York, USA   (07.12.10)
And millions other Americans who are out of a job. The only place I did not try yet is McDonald's.
11. They started preparing the grounds two weeks ago
JO   (07.12.10)
I know, I live near and heard the noise. Two weeks ago they started clearing the area and preparing ground with trucks and tractors. I was surprised because it is situated on a community park way and no notice was given to any of the neighbours. It was sudden.
12. Meretz - Biggest Enemy To Peace
Rube Vogel ,   Jerualem   (07.12.10)
Meretz continues to be Israel's number one critic in the world. With them fanning the flames of the Palestinian conflict, there will never be peace. The Meretz Position: "Well we do think that Pisgat zeev should be part of Israel but building there proves we're not commited to the peace process. Don't even think abot making peace with us. We can't be trusted."
13. hallo split....
Dana Rothschild ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.12.10)
the world is watching Obama going slowly but surely down the drain and taking USA with him...
14. Jerusalem's special status
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.12.10)
Please do not forget that very shortly after Israel's stupendous victory in the Six-Day War, East Jerusalem was annexed, made irrevocably a unified city and equally irrevocably the eternal capital of the State of Israel. East Jerusalem has been ANNEXED. It is now forever a part of the State of Israel. It does not matter who recognizes this or who doesn't. What matters is that (i) Israel acquired the territory through fighting a defensive war and the land is therefore Israel's to retain and (ii) Israel is a sovereign and as such is entitled to full and fair exercise of eminent domain. Israel does not NEED anyone's permission to build anywhere in Jerusalem. And as Jerusalem expands and grows, certain areas are incorporated by geographical fact into the municipality of Jerusalem and, as such, become a part of unified Jerusalem. No matter what anyone else says. That's accepted international law and the accepted concept of eminent domain. Deal with it. It isn't going to change.
15. Palestinians to live in these homes, our land / homes
Palestinian   (07.12.10)
16. #1 - Jake: who the hell is "WE".....?
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.12.10)
You say WE will not negotiate, as if you are Israeli. As if you are here. As if you have any skin in the game. You don't. So nobody here cares about your support for Bibi or lack of support for Bibi. It's irrelevant.
17. My Answer to Meretz
Kathy Chriqui ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (07.12.10)
Does Meretz actually believe that Obama cares? Does Meretz actually believe that Jews should only live in certain neighborhoods and not in all neighborhoods. Should Israel actually have some land "Judenfrei?" I think not!
18. Long live Israel
vicky17 ,   USA   (07.12.10)
Jerusalem is a Jewish city.
19. #16, chill out Andy, "WE" is Israel, the Jewish nation
Jake ,   USA   (07.13.10)
20. # 14 nonsense
Indigenous ,   Palestine   (07.13.10)
No country in the face of the earth recognizes beloved Jerusalem as "Israel's" capital and no country would dare to, not even "Israel" it self. Do not hurry a war coming and will sort things out. Peace for Palestine and "Israel"
21. andy, just shut up would ya
doctor ,   il   (07.13.10)
since when does the place and time matter? he supports israel in general and thats what counts. i bet jake is even a better jew than you. get a job andy, don't jump your own ppl. cheers
22. Extremist Jews Building Masada 2
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (07.13.10)
CIA predicts that Israel will fall within 20 years.
23. Meretz's loyalty is to Obama, not to Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (07.13.10)
We all know Meretz has always stood among the looniest of the loony left. However, the interesting thing is that today, Meretz, and other leftist groups, don't even bother pretending to be patriotic Israelis. A couple of decades ago, Meretz would have tried to make the (ludicrous) argument that ceding Jerusalem is good for Israel. Today the thin patriotic mask has fallen off. The pretense of loyalty to Israel is gone. Meretz's loyalty is to Obama, and his ilk. Not to Israel.
24. The Important point and the RED Line
Handala ,   Jerusalem, Palesine   (07.13.10)
1. no matter how powerful is israel it cannot touch a stone of the aqsa mosque. 2. the palestinian state on 1967 borders is just what israel wants, unless your stupid u will know this.
25. Obama is irrelevant,Meretz is irrelevant...
Malone ,   Hfx   (07.13.10)
..does it matter what they think?
26. obaman knows?
mayer ,   usa   (07.13.10)
who is the PM? who gave us this land? why do jews have a right to the land? Obama?
27. To: No. 20
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (07.13.10)
Like I said, all that matters is what Israel -- as a sovereign state -- recognizes. There are any number of territorial disputes throughout the world which are not recognized by the prevailing international view. Doesn't change anything. And I have to tell you, Israel's argument is better than most. By the way -- indigenous -- since you identify yourself as such,permit me toI remind you that the "Palestinians" are, in fact, indigenous to the Hejaz in the Western Arabian desert. Jews are indigenous to Jerusalem. You claim that Arabs recognize a "beloved Jerusalem." Oh, really? Didn't pay too damn much attention until Israel acquired East Jerusalem in 1967. For that matter, how many times is Jerusalem mentioned in the Qu'uran? I'll tell you. Zip. Zilch. Nada. NOT ONCE. Contrast that with the thousand of references to Jerusalem in the Hebrew Bible. Contrast that with the prayers that Jews are required to say for the peace of Jerusalem. Contrast that with our annual prayer "Next year in Jerusalem." Find another line of reasoning, "Indigenous." Yours fails, on facts.
28. correction please
EG   (07.13.10)
NOT land conquered in 1967 but rather land LIBERATED in 1967
29. Yo ciucius !
split ,   usa   (07.13.10)
I'm glad to see you again, really ;) Going back to Obama, he can't do a diddly squat without an approval from Congress which is occupied (temporarily) by bunch of suicidal traitors and foreign lobby that don't give a sh*t about anything except little bully and re-election ,... Temporarily I said. -------------------- the world is watching Obama going slowly but surely down the drain and taking USA with him...
30. #21 Doctor
Yossef   (07.13.10)
Andy is right ! We israeli can count only on ourselves. No american, even jewish, nothing, just israeli. even jewish, Got it ? טוב
Next talkbacks
Back to article