News  Magazine
Leftists take Palestinians to the beach
Naomi Reichman
Published: 25.07.10, 19:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. Palestinians have a whole damn freaking beach for themselves
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.25.10)
It's called "Gaza"
2. If they want to go to the beach, move to gaza!!
Uzi ,   Beit Shemesh   (07.25.10)
Total leftist BS propaganda, How about caring more for the poor jewish kids that lost a parent due to a terrorist attack.
3. Very moving
harry   (07.25.10)
This a very moving article but even more so a hugely laudable initiative to let kids be kids and not politicians.
4. Take them to a beach closest to Ramat
jason white ,   afula, israel   (07.25.10)
HaSharon. If they return as terrorists, let them leave BatYam alone. This sure beats working for the "Make a wish" foundation. The palis are really going to love us. They will want to take over Bat Yam to get a beach of their own. How about shapira and afek taking their families and spending the day at the beach in gaza?
5. Why help Arabs
Avi ,   Israel   (07.25.10)
I'm sure there are many Jewish youths who cannot afford a day at the beach. Why not help them instead? Why do this for Arabs?
6. I Hope The Arabs Don't Retailate
emanon ,   USA   (07.25.10)
Imagine that, exposing kids to a beach where men and women expose large portions of skin, yet get along just fine. You know that arabs will claim that this is immoral and the Jews are trying to corrupt their children. Retaliation is probably being panned as we read this. If not, the harediem morality police will.
7. To # 1 and then, to #2
Mea   (07.25.10)
You know, this sort of remark is why people are starting to turn away from supporting Israel--your racism is showing and it's ugly. I suppose you hate blacks too, eh? No? You wouldn't be bothered with blacks on a US beach? I am a strong conservative supporter of Israel, but that does not equate to automatically thinking all Palestinians should go to Gaza, or that all blacks should go back to Africa. Think about what flows out of you because so far it looks like both ends match. And #2, you don't have to strap every Arab to a wall in a cell in order to honor the dead. Collective hatred doesn't result in a collective conscience--why? Because unless a person is actually guilty, they just think the truth, which is that they are being made to pay for what others have done. While I totally agree with the separation wall construction and house demolitions, these people merely desire to take their children to the beach under supervision. I have spent opts of time in Israel and it never occurred to me that Palestinians do not go to the beach. So this story is an eye opener. One last remarks is that the editor could have made this into a spectacular piece with some work on editing. It is a great story very poorly written.
8. Talkbackers are nasty
Israeli   (07.25.10)
These are children, keep your racism and stupidity to yourselves
9. Disgusting leftist women
Tony   (07.25.10)
shame on them for bringing enemies into the country. I can't imagine how the security establishment allowed such thing. These Arabs are stealing our homeland, and instead of sending them to beaches of Egypt or UAE, they bring them here? Some people have just no shame.
10. PATHETIC.
Sara ,   Spring valley, USA   (07.25.10)
11. nothing more then fool???
(07.25.10)
12. #7 yer look what they learn in school and on tv
(07.25.10)
13. I wonder how many Afghani women & kid have seen the beach?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (07.25.10)
Oh wait it is a landlocked land - so most likely a vast majority haven't ever seen it either. Guess the leftist will complain we had something to do with that too.
14. Kids in Colorado can't go to the beach
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.25.10)
I do not understand how you equate "Palestinians can't go to the beach" with racism, hating blacks and not allowing blacks on a U.S. beach? How to you make this idiotic connection? Where does this stupidity come from? Are you Eric Cartman? Kids in Colorado, Kansas and Iowa don't normally visit the beach either, I don't see anyone making a fund for ocean beach trips for kids who live in Colorado.
15. :: Posts of hate and ignorance
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.25.10)
Keep it Ynuts let the entire world read your hate filled spiteful comments about innocent children. No amount of hasbara/PR spin can lessen the disgust that normal people will feel when they read you sentiments - truly you are the worst ambassadors Israel could have.
16. Misplaced tzedaka?
m   (07.26.10)
How is the saying? Be kind to the cruel you will be cruel to the kind. I'm sure the same parents of children who are yearning their child's martyrdom are laughing their heads off. Can anyone imagine 1942, having German children to the Buckingham to see the king?
17. The arabs wan't to do the same...
Yisroel ,   USA   (07.25.10)
Drive the Jews to the sea and make them "swim."
18. Palestinian sea
sameer ,   jerusalem   (07.26.10)
I am sure it is a temporary situation, they will return to their homes, lands, petches, and all forigners will leave back, then we will invite them to our sea,
19. Racist pigs, no wonder there's no peace
lara ,   Australia   (07.26.10)
Your comments are disgusting. You don't want peace. You're driven by your greed and selfish desire not to share land and in this case, a beach. You treat these children like criminals for breathing the same air as you. The next time you complain about anti-semitism or peoples hate for you, refer back to your words, attitudes and actions, then maybe you'll be able to understand why you deserve it. What these Jewish women did for these children was show humanity, I wish there was more people like this and less people like those who make such hateful and nasty comments.
20. Well dont to these women a shinning example
Avi ,   Israel   (07.26.10)
These women are a shining example not only to Israel but to humanity. Despite all the hatred and religious differences they tore down the barriers which divide us and opened their hearts to helping others. They make me proud to be Israeli.
21. Oh come on now lets stop and think and see the facts as they
Don Saliman ,   Nahal Oz, Israel   (07.26.10)
All of Gaza is next to the sea and don't feed us the line they will never see the beach again These pictures from this site below shows children enjoying the beach in Gaza. http://www.upi.com/News_Photos/gallery/Palestinians-enjoy-a-beach-in-Gaza/3550/
22. I'll tell you all why....
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (07.26.10)
It's because these children are taught hate. They need to see a little love from somewhere! How can you expect them to not hate you if you won't bend a little and be willing to show them a little kindness. When you begrudge these poor children a little kindness you only prove to them and to the world that perhaps they have good reason to hate you. How can you expect others to treat you or your children with respect if you show so much hate yourselves?
23. Jewish kids
Bob ,   New York   (07.26.10)
There are probably more Jewish kids in Israel who haven't been to the beach than Arabs. This article is disgusting.
24. # 18 for Sameer
whatever ,   wherever   (07.26.10)
dear sameer look at the history you have never invited anyone to see your beaches you have always destroyed building, burned libraries, cut the head of resistance, and format of your logic has been "i will get angry, watch what your say and what you think" also you have destroyed civilizations...Zoroastrianism in Iran, Budhism in Afghanistan, Hinduism in India ( and creating pure land, ie Pakistan ), Byzantine Empire in Syria, Coptism in Egypt, ... the right thing to do, aknowledge your past crime, rest assure nobody wants to take any revenge ( this is an Islamic concept ), rest of the world wants to live in peace, and each culture strives to keep its standards, language, and its peace.
25. Hey #7 look what # 18 Writes
ariel ,   holon   (07.26.10)
26. #15 Posts of hate and ignorance
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (07.26.10)
Nothing can beat the sheer hate and ignorance of YOUR POST on the article about the Arab whose child received life-saving surgery at Hadassah hospital, who then went out and murdered an Israeli police officer. You made an insane, hateful and slanderous comment about the author of the article. You do nothing in this forum except spew hate and ignorance.
27. Umm...
(07.26.10)
Don't Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Lebanon, and Syria have beaches facing the Med? How about taking them to those beaches... beaches Israeli's cannot even go to!
28. #7 You have missunderstood something here
Omri ,   Israel   (07.26.10)
What you just read wasnt racism it was nationalism, where one loves and cares for people from his own country more then people from other countries. This is not a crime and is VERY common. And this is also something those leftis dont have for they seem to neglect the fact that there are also poor jews in israel that had never had the money to go to the sea themselves. The fact that they chose the poor palastinians and not the poor jews is obviestly becouse that will: 1. get more attention 2. serve their political view This nationalism is nothing special, if a british orginisation would take french poor people to visit the sea then im sure many british people would be angry for "why not take our poor british fellows to the sea? why french?" btw i've veen to the sea and I've seen many arab speaking people down there dont believe leftis propaganda that the beaches are only used by jews.
29. #7 Mea is quite right
Elmer ,   USA   (07.26.10)
I learned a lot about some of you individual posters, especially in your comments about the children. It reminded me of the old warning, expressed throughout history in different religions and philosophies, about becoming like your enemies. Some of you seem to be well on your way. From the best I can tell, and certainly to their credit, the vast majority of Israelis probably approve of this project, even if it IS organized by leftists.
30. in gaza they got [lenty of beach.
ghostq   (07.26.10)
I don't see y they should do it in Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article