News
Helen Thomas may get statue in museum
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 03.08.10, 08:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
147 Talkbacks for this article
31. Helen Thomas may get statue in museum
Rina ,   Haifa, Israel   (08.03.10)
Helen Thomas need to use her own advice. She and her family should get out of USA and return to Lebanon, where she was born. And she also should leave all her procession to Native Americans ob who's land she and her family live. People who live in glass house shouldn't threw the stones. She has as much right to live in USA as Jewish from Europe have right to live in Israel. At least this land originally belonged to Jewish, when land in USA belonged to Native Americans and was taken from them. If Thomas so like Arabs why she didn't live in her own country?
32. As an Arab American, I am ashamed of Ms Thomas's
Maria ,   Michigan, U.S.A.   (08.03.10)
vulgar expression regarding the Jews of Israel, which contributes, I am sad to comment, to viewing all Jews negatively, including two of my best friends here in the States, both of whom are loyal to the U.S. but also feel strongly about their historic connection to Israel, as so many other Jews do. I am not going to contribute any money toward this goal.
33. #16 well said. Some with call you anti Semite now
Margot ,   Jslm, israel   (08.03.10)
And the over use of it, is a real insult to people who really suffer anti semetism or hatred.
34. #9 thats becasue he isnt famouse only for the king david
Omri ,   Israel   (08.03.10)
hotel. That guy was a war hero back in the dark days. On the other hand the statue of her will mostly represent her anti-semetism and not her faminist actions. Thats probebly why the muslims want her statue and not a faminist orginisation.
35. #29
Omri ,   Israel   (08.03.10)
She did it because her reputation can influence many people. Its simple as that.
36. Helen Thomas is a racist, not because of her
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (08.03.10)
critical views of Israel, but because implicit in her statement is: 1) Israel, the nation-state of a people,m of the Jewish people, is illegitimate. And, 2) Its Jewish residents, regardless of their origin or perhaps even those born in Israel (I believe the majority of Israelis today) have no right to live in their own country, their own nation-state. If she expressed the same regarding Portugal, Greece, Denmark or Poland - all nation-states as Israel is - she would be considered not only racist but also crazy. She has chosen to single out Israel,m the nation-state of the Jewish people, and that makes her racist... as well as crazy!
37. to the artist
marco ,   pardes hana israel   (08.03.10)
Dear Ms. McElhinney You should be ashamed of yourself allowing your artistic talents to be used for such a discraceful waste of perfectly good art materials. Better you should keep your nose out of poltics,go and make beautiful sculpture instead of lousy attempts at a Halloween Witch.
38. Peter#7! With a LTTLE difference
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (08.03.10)
We build they (arabs) distroy.
39. Obama will contribute, as he has for the next
Amir ,   Chicago, IL   (08.03.10)
Peace Flotilla" organized by Rashid Khalidi. After all, these are his people..., right, Mr. barakeh hussein obama?
40. Monument in Disneyland
Ariel ,   Europe   (08.03.10)
as a perfect image of Wicked Witch of the West! LOL
41. Helen Thomas is an anti-Semite, and I say it as a gentile
John J. Dunn ,   Boston, MA USA   (08.03.10)
and American at that, but one who has read and heard Thomas talk for several decades. If the Arabs of America wish to honor an anti-Semite, it is their right. But they then shouldn't complain when people refer to them based on their deeds.
42. Dearborn, MI
SE ,   Holon Israel   (08.03.10)
Since the days of Henry Ford, I see this town hasn't changed it's views on Jews.
43. Christian and antisemetism
Micheal ,   Earth   (08.03.10)
For sure you will not post my comment You gave us headaches with the antisemtism thing, what about jews being anti christianity?
44. #18 - what a lovely person you are Salma
Simon ,   Sydney, Australia   (08.03.10)
You are a real humanist, love all fellow humans. God should show you the same kindness as you show others. By the way, where are you from? take your pick it's either Israel, Jordan or Egypt. I know which would treat you the best....
45. H.Thomas
Mike ,   Clinton, MA USA   (08.03.10)
Statue not to be confused with a gargoyle...
46. agreed bury the old bat and stick a monument on top
Avi ,   israel   (08.03.10)
47. I hope they can find granite that is old enough!
fantum ,   Schenectady, NY   (08.03.10)
I hope they can find granite that is old enough!
48. A valid point to press, #43
Cameron ,   USA   (08.03.10)
Never been a shortage of either, truth be told.
49. Helen Thomas
r Salter ,   Atlanta --- USA   (08.03.10)
Helen Thomas has been an embarrassment for many years over many varied subjects. I won't visit any museum with a monument to her. It would make me sick. She does indeed stand out. No other journalist has ever been so wrong-headed.
50. Save money ..call a Taxidermist..
gram ,   st louis mo   (08.03.10)
Wouldn't it be a lot cheaper just to get her stuffed and mounted ?..?
51. It is Freedom of Speech
Marc ,   Toronto, Canada   (08.03.10)
People have their own opinion and attacking her the way many are doing here is no different than someone being anti Semitic!
52. to #46 funny but palis also say that
ghostq   (08.03.10)
and you defend them. sound like you got selective reality.
53. It embarrassing to be an Arab American and be
George Khoury ,   Minnesota, USA   (08.03.10)
associated with Ms. Thomas.
54. They've already got Helen Thomas Statues
Tex Taylor ,   OK USA   (08.03.10)
I've seen plenty of Helen Thomas Statues around - you can get these "gargoyles" many places and place them in your gardens next to the Helen Thomas sister look-a-like gnomes.
55. the facts
SA ,   Washington, DC   (08.03.10)
Okay, I'm here to refute this oft-stated note about the term "anti-semitism." Jews did not "appropriate" for themselves: while yes, you are so insightful to note that Jews are not the only Semitic people, the term was coined to refer to Jews alone. So Arabs and others who claim that they cannot be anti-Semitic because "how can I be against Semites because I am a Semite myself" are purposely misusing the word and eroding it of its meaning. That's why we have other terms, like "anti-Arab."
56. statute belongs in a.....
john ,   naples, fl   (08.03.10)
witch museum
57. #43
Nick ,   USA   (08.03.10)
...and the same thing could be repeated to the years of Christians killing Jews for not converting. I'm pretty sure Jesus Himself would be anti-Christianity in some areas too, such as replacement theology, celebrating pagan holidays and saying they're from God, etc..
58. Candy Coated Left Wing Hate
Bryan Abbott ,   Los Angeles   (08.03.10)
Helen said what every Liberal thinks.
59. "Anti-Semitism" has been used historically to denote
Suzanne Spiegleman ,   Cleveland, OH   (08.03.10)
"anti-Jewish". Those who don't like the term are welcome to refer to Ms. Thomas as anti-Jewish bigot or anti-Jewish racist, or simply anti-Jewish. All of these terms apply to her.
60. Helen Thomas
Frank515 ,   Lynnwood WA   (08.03.10)
About the only place she should get a statute is museum of anti-semitism
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article