News  Magazine
Preparing for future wars
Alex Fishman
Published: 05.08.10, 15:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. silence is gold
mosh ,   israel   (08.05.10)
the least we talk the better it is
2. must remain classified
john   (08.05.10)
3. A bit more "paranoia" re Turkey would have been wise
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (08.05.10)
Now that Turkey has "tilted" toward Israel's enemies, it's now clear Israel should have been more circumspect in sharing its technology with them. Turkey now has extensive strategic relations with both Iran and Syria, so exposure of that technology isn't a remote possibility; it's a near certainty. Only recently, we've had reports not only that Israeli drones were used in operations against Kurdish rebels - even cross-border into Iraq and Syria - but that Syrian and Iranian personnel were at least present. No doubt Israel's military industries want to keep selling, and Barak and Ben-Eliezer still believe Turkey is a "strategic ally". But they are in denial.
4. Yes,yes of course, but...
Marcel ,   Florida   (08.05.10)
Since this time of greater openess Israel has become inept and incapable of defeating gowing armies of Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon. The new and improved Israel can't even free Gilad Shalit from next door Gaza as it's hypes up it's long range possibilities. So you've traded your unbroken record of defeating the enemy for semi-good but worthless in the end PR.
5. Bravo Israel!
AgentX ,   USA   (08.05.10)
Israel tiny but deadly, surrounded by a sea of Arab and Iranian bullies. May Israel live long and strong!
6. Dear marcel
David ,   Israel   (08.05.10)
Your wrong Israeli army can whipe the whole Hamas and Hezbollah militans in a press of a button but the point is that we jews (not as the media like to describe us) dont harm civilians and if we do that the price of the real inoccents in gaza and lebanon will be extrem God bless you and your family David
7. IAF:Very basic errors were committed
DT ,   TA Israel   (08.05.10)
First you never fly blind below your MSA. Second it seemed like a case of too many pilots were a major hindrance no doubt offering advice and effecting the decision and judgment of the a/c whoever he was.
8. We often get "expert" advice and opinions
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (08.05.10)
about Israel's military capabilities and what it's strategies and tactics ought to be and where mistakes have occurred. Normally (not always), these opinions and perceptions come from both pro and anti-Israeli Posters but do not reflect the reality of the situation. On the other hand, I believe that Mr. Fishman's column is replete with military knowledge regarding Israel and its capabilities; at least it rung true. So I found the article itself quite refreshing. I hope Ynet publishes more articles of this kind. Nonetheless, I recognize that much of the knowledge of Israel's military capabilities and strategies must, and will, remain secret. I also wonder at Mr. Fishman's own qualifications and his ability to source information. As noted, not that I doubt him but could Ynet publish something about that. Much appreciated.
9. Having Lost Turkey As An Ally ......
World Citizen ,   the world   (08.05.10)
The Israelis are trying for an operational capacity from Romania. With refueling capability it can be done. And the flight from Romania to Georgia is roughly 1000 km. From there to the border of Iran another 200 to 300 Km. The helicopters could operate out of Georgia in attempts to rescue downed IAF pilots from Iran. The question is will the Russians allow you to operate out of Georgia if you attack their ally Iran? Will they let you fly accross the Black Sea to get to Georgia? Sevastopol is less than 50 km from a direct flight path from Romania to Georgia. Many a helicopter and F-16 could "disappear" on a flight over that sea.
10. Doctored IFF codes in Turkish "upgrades" I suspect.
Ken Quinn ,   Amsterdam   (08.05.10)
Naughty, naughty. :))
11. Russia seems to know more of Israel's secrets than US
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (08.05.10)
Russia seem to be more interested in learning Israel's secrets of radar jamming and anti communication/control system methods. Fooling long range radar systems is key for many of these commando operations to work, also stopping Cell phones/radios from reporting sightings is equal important. Russia is working on new HARM missiles to target radar jamming aircraft and upgrading S-300/500 systems to make it harder for these type of operations and pickup transmissions from unmanned aircraft. Staying one step ahead is costly and getting harder for Israel to do now days.
12. What if....#9?
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (08.05.10)
What if...what if.... if what ? Whatever you conjure up in your mind, it won't be that. Russians allies with Iran? Were the French allies of Iraq because they were building Osirak? The Russians have simply taken a leaf out the French book...a very lucrative one. Your hate for us will be the source of massive disappointments for you over time.
13. war nothing but war
assasah ,   jenin   (08.05.10)
in due course, everyone should be prepared for war, i wonder if the word peace exists in any israeli dictionary? and if it does; i think it remains a word. as long as arabs(not denying being one of them) are making the biggest TABALA and the biggest FALAFAL Dishes or the longest Dabkah,
14. In a windy day israeli air force can be taken care of *end*
Ali   (08.05.10)
15. If finish the job the first time, ...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.05.10)
you or your children, grandchildren or great grand children won't have to do this over and over again!!! It's time we choose the end game before our enemies do for us. They're getting smarter you know and more and more support by the day.
16. Weapons, training are vital but remember
Shmuel ,   Montana USA   (08.06.10)
the victory belongs to the LORD...Israel must get right with YWH...and deporting children is very alarming to me as a lover of Israel. God cannot be pleased with this decision to deport these children. As a Jew I am totally stunned and ashamed. You can have all the best of weapons and whatever but if God so chooses my friends ... well, let it be said it has happened to Israel before when they disobeyed theri Maker....let it not be so this time in history is my ernest prayer.
17. they are preparing too bozos
jacob ,   encino, ca   (08.06.10)
your state run terror is running out of gas. You oppressor's of the poor, weak and defensless. Just to spite you ( I do not like iran), I wished they get 20 of the big ones. Someone has to put an end to your evil dominance.
18. # 13 War nothing but war
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (08.06.10)
assasah ! Does the word reason exist in the palestinian vocabulary ?,a palestinian complained,that, before he was liberated by the Alaksa intifada,he was working in Israel as a painter bringing home each day more than $80,today he is earning $5 a day,no denying with $5 you can buy a nice size pita with falafel.
19. #13
(08.06.10)
an myselkf, as an iranian muslim man, who knows both the arabs and israelis, i can tell you that it is not and has never been israel that was violent. if you look at history, you'll see, my friend, that it IS YOU THAT ALWAYS STARTED WARS FROM 1948, TO 1952, TO 1967, TO 1973 AND TO 2005-2009 (13,000 HAMAS MISSILES FROM GAZA INTO ISRAEL. ISRAEL RESPONDED FINALLY) FROM 2006 WHERE HIZBULLAH KIDNAPPED AND KILLED JEWISH SOLDIERS ON ISRAELI TERRITORY IN TERROR ATTACK, AND 2010 WHERE LEBANESE SOLDIERS ON ORDERS FROM SYRIA NAD IRAN SHOT AND KILLED ISRAELI CAPTAIN WHEN ISRAELIS WERE WORKING ON THE ISRAELI SIDE OF THE BORDER!!!!!!!! NOT ON LEBANESE. SO SAYS THE UN AND UNIFIL!!!!! NOT TO MENTION THE FEDAYIN TERRORISM BEFORE THE "OCCUPATION" FROM 1948-1967 CONSTANTLY TERRORISING AND KILLING ISRAELIS. NOT TO MENTION THE CONSTANT TERRORISM FROM WEST BANK AND GAZA KILLING THOUSANDS OF ISRAELIS THROUGH SUICIDE BOMBS AND TERRORIST ATTACKS ON ONLY INNOCENT CIVILIANS. NOT ONE ISRAELI MILITARY BASE WAS EVER ATTACKED BY TERRORIST EXCEPT FOR ONE SINGLE ONE TWO YEARS AGO. ALL THE TERROR WAS ON INNOCENT CIVILIANS. no, my friend, it is you who do not want peace and do not accept jews living near you in what your islam considers islamic territory, which is bs. jews have a 4,000 year history connecting them to the areas in palestine and to jerusalem. if you read your koran, it says so in there too. there is no need to reinvent your history over the dead bodies of jews. jews were there first and the san remo agreement says in law, in international law, that they hold the legal national deed to this whole land and more. it is you arabs that bring all the terror and war to israeli borders. it is you arabs that have media that encourages hate of jews and israelis, that denies the holocaust , that sends a message of hate towards jews. have you seen palestinian tv programs lately?, have you heard imams in your mosques and their messages against jews? have you seen your children's programs on al aqsa tv, on palestinian tv and in gaza where children atre encouraged to hate, to kill and to murder jews? have you see the latest military ca,p celebration in gaza that indoctrinates little children wirh guns and suicide belts and fills their head with only hate but no real education? have you seem thew HAMAM CHARTER? WHAT IT SAYS? THE DEATH TO JEWS MESSAGE IN IT?????? you are not the one tgo talk and blame jews here. look inside your society. you are violent, backwards, depraved, suicidal, hateful, uneducated, nihilistic and mysogenistic. work on yourselves first before pointing fingers. work on a civil society and humanity first with your people. get them ready for peace. tell them that no, no right of return and yes, the return will be only into a new palestinian state. finish your tv and media messages of hate and annihilation, build schools, library, civic building, charities (not for bombs and guns). build a society that can show it is ready for peace, not just for hate, murder and suicide bombings and terror. THEN, YOU CAN HAVE THE RIGHT TO POINT FINGERS AT ISRAELIS AND JEWS. hameed aboughaze, iranian
20. #14
(08.06.10)
on many windy days, the entire arab armies from all arab countries have lost all wars against the israeli idf and iaf and never won a single one since. terrorism is not war. military to military and jets to jets, israel beat you soundly in all wars. hameed aboughaze, iranian
21. #9 world citizen
tom ,   toronto, canada   (08.06.10)
as usual, "world citizen" is too eager to spout his/her anti-israeli drivel to actually bother reading the article. maybe a short course or two in reading comprehension would help? yawn....
22. Peparing for future war
Yousef ,   Hebron , Palestine   (08.06.10)
Isarel will aways search for wars , this because she is illegal at this region , she always fears her neighbours
23. To #19, the Iranian
FrumiousFalafel ,   USA   (08.08.10)
Thank you Baradar for your wise comments!
Back to article