Jewish Scene
Iran Holocaust-denying website angers Israel
Associated Press
Published: 10.08.10, 08:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
24 Talkbacks for this article
1. Switch this off
Ken ,   Australia   (08.10.10)
So as this works to the iranians advantage and it does fuel them, Switch this site of and send it a virus and blow it up. Switch of there anti- jewsh propaganda machine, and make it clear we will not tolerate this strategy, dont let them use this against us, its not right to let them continue this.
2. The site was great. Just saw it.
Ernst ,   Germany   (08.10.10)
3. Why the hell worry for what he says?
Daniel ,   Israel   (08.10.10)
4. professional work
sweeter than honey ,   far away   (08.10.10)
looks like they've been trained in western europe. and a reaction to the original danish jyllands-posten cartoon. the one where the headress has become a bomb really has become a CULTURAL ICON, like warhols soup-cans in its day, capturing the current zeitgeist of the west. that image is all over the place. in peoples' heads. truly. the iranians are maybe trying to do a mohammedan cultural icon, but as it does not have veracity, it has much less chance of catching on. i do note that though the cartoon comes from a danish privately owned provincial newspaper, and drawn by the danish gentile kurt westergaard. that the iranians turn upon jews-israel, now that really is revealing. including how succinct that cartoon was and is. now for some taffel akvavit from aalborg, cheers kurt and jyllands-posten.
5. To Ernst
Allan ,   London, England   (08.10.10)
Is your name really Ernst? Or are you one of the 2 million Turks occupying Germany? let us see your outrage at the occupation.. of Northern Cyprus...
6. 11 to 17 million murdered, not just Jews
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (08.10.10)
Both Iran and Israel are in denial of the true dimensions of the Nazi murder machine..."Some scholars maintain that the definition of the Holocaust should also include the Nazis' systematic murder of millions of people in other groups, including ethnic Poles, Romani, Soviet civilians, Soviet prisoners of war, people with disabilities, homosexuals, Jehovah's Witnesses, and other political and religious opponents.[6] By this definition, the total number of Holocaust victims would be between 11 million and 17 million people.[7]"
7. Proffessional and some of it funny
John ,   London   (08.10.10)
Well, debate, challenge and even "war of words" is always much more productive than violence and killing innocent people! I just looked at the site, it is not offensive and it acknowledges and does show respect to the people who died in WWII, while criticising many other acts and claims…… So, I recommend this site.
8. Good to see #6 acknowledging now that Holocaust happened
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (08.10.10)
after she kept denying it all along. BLOODYTHIRSTY SCOT GREATEST TEX-MEX BURRITO AND MIDDLE EAST EXPERT DALLAS, TEXAS
9. To #6 - Steve
Avi ,   Israel   (08.10.10)
Neither Israel nor Yad Vashem, or any credible scholars dispute that millions of other people died as a result of Nazi actions. What makes the Holocaust unique is the fact that it was designed to systematically eliminate a specific people - the Jewish people by trying to solve 'The Jewish Question' by employing a 'Final Solution'. Millions died during WWII, but the overwhelming majority of people sent to death camps were Jews who experienced what has been called 'The Holocaust'. If stretching that definition to apply to other Nazi victims makes you feel better, that's fine. But it shouldn't detract from the severity of Nazi Germany's actions against Jews.
10. To #9 - Avi
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (08.11.10)
Counting only Jews in the Holocaust and creating a sympathy industry around it, in Jewish dominated Hollywood, is disinformation at best, propaganda at worst. I went to Dachau when I was in Munich. It was the first concentration camp and held mostly German political prisoners for the first several years. No doubt Jews, a minority, lost a large percentage of their total population, half, and were hit the hardest. But it is a disservice to the other victims, the non-Jews, not to be included in the next Holocaust film coming out of Hollywood.
11. lets put a fatwa on him
(08.11.10)
12. Where is this site.
Fred S. Morrison   (08.11.10)
Any body know where you can find the site is it real
13. where is the site
Fred S. Morrison ,   Vermont USA   (08.11.10)
It the site real, Anybody know the link to it ?
14. to #9 tell that to palestinian who thinks they got
ghostq   (08.11.10)
clean past, they leader was nazi and he wanted to help hitler with the solution.
15. to #10 steve do better research 90%
ghostq   (08.11.10)
of the consentration camps were in Polin soil, germany didn't want the jews in her area(they were a few in austria but not many), many jews Germans found themselve transported by cattle traines to Lodz and from there to auwschwietz, Germans had policy against jews hitler didn't want the other germans to know what he was doing, in Yad Vashem there is map of all the concentration camps, you won't find any jews in germany at that time. they were all consetrated in polin, and another thing you missed, the othe1 11 millions were mainly in fact soldiers of the red Russian army who died during battle not part of the final solution. among the red army soldiers were jews, that is y when people say 6 million they round the number down, even though nobody counted how many jews were in the red Army, in reality the number of jewish victims r higher than 6 million, just to let you know, I know USA education is bad, I didn't think it was that bad.
16. The English website is horrid
Dudi ,   Jerusalem   (08.11.10)
I went through as many pages of the website as I could stomach and was forced to stop. The English is atrocious at points; very indicative of the level of education the author possesses. The spreading of vitriolic propaganda and lies is risible. It is sad that people believe this garbage. In response to the previous posts about the distortion of the Holocaust. Nobody denies that non-Jews were persecuted and died in the Holocaust. The argument is that 1. The Final Solution was aimed specifically at the Jews and 2. None of the other persecuted groups suffered to the same magnitude or proportion as the Jews.
17. #15
HS ,   USA   (08.11.10)
And lets not forget to mention the number of Jews murdered in the Ukraine, where gravesites are still being discovered today.
18. #6 - the rant of the intellectually dishonest
William ,   Israel   (08.12.10)
True - many more were murdered at the hands of the Nazis. Jews do not dispute this nor disregard their deaths as insignificant. However, no other group was systematically targeted for extermination like the Jews were. What makes the Holocaust so horrific was not that so many had died, but that great efforts went to build an infrastructure and plan the murder of so many due to religion, in a factory-like automation. Sorry that has no real effect on you.
19. # 12 an 13 its mentioned in the article...
(08.12.10)
20. #10 Benassi
Cynthia ,   USA   (08.12.10)
Name one Holocaust museum that counts and mentions only Jews? If you feel strongly that other victims of the Holocaust deserve more recognition, what stops you from raising money to build a memorial for them or get involved in a film project to highlight the subject? You can step up to the plate and do something productive for humanity. And frankly Steve, we don't need your sympathy. We can mourn the death by genocide of our relatives without you.
21. Iran
Hal ,   Usa   (08.12.10)
The Iranian regime is flirting with disaster. The earthquakes and economic misery are but a shadow of what's to come. Their main benefactors are fighting a firestorm, the likes of which are biblical in proportion. The Iranian regime can dance with the Devil all they want, but the price will be biblical as well! PS I find it rather comical that Jews are portrayed with big noses in a country where big noses are big business for plastic surgeons. Maybe the Assmaninajam can get his nosejob at a discount with a few cereal boxtops and a note from his boyfriend, the dentist?
22. # 10 benidiot
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (08.13.10)
To all the respondents to # 10 benidiot.Don't you see that this Antisemite is not the least concern with the none Jewish victims of Germany ,in every T.B.he is spewing his Antisemitic venom.
23. Disgusting site...
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (08.13.10)
Just got back from this garbage website. Got as far as page 41. Total and utter crap, reflecting what the appreciating Ernst and John@7 share for brains. Fui......!
24. #10 Benasswipe
Hal ,   Usa   (08.13.10)
Nice try at moral equivilance Stevie, but any person with a modest understanding of this period of time knows that despite the others that were murdered at these camps, Jews were the main target of Hitler's rage. Since when do Jews claim that they were the only ones to suffer? You are breathing you own waste gas, open a window.
Back to article