News
Hamas: NYC mosque must be built
Associated Press
Published: 16.08.10, 18:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
31. im shocked
Yaniv ,   Israel   (08.16.10)
32. dont the American people have a saying?
SHAME ,   WORLD   (08.16.10)
Terrosrsts brought down the towers- and now they are supposed to build a mosque near the sight ? A monument to their terror attack, a celebration to death that is all the basis to their culture? OUTRAGEOUS
33. How many Jewish Temple and Church in Arab Land ?
AlbertoGA ,   St. George, USA   (08.16.10)
In particular I want to see action in that direction around Mecca. All the rest is NONSENSE.
34. Laying it down for you all
Nate ,   USA   (08.16.10)
Many of you make an irrelevant and ignorant point over and over again. The building of a synagogue is not allowed in Muslim countries such as Saudi Arabia. The reason is that these countries DO NOT, and I repeat, DO NOT preach freedom of religion. This is a very ignorant point that many of you have been running with. Now this country (US) was built on religious freedom and anyone should be allowed to build their house of worship anywhere regardless of your own opinions. Everyone here attempts to be some kind of expert on this issue but are completely ignoring the facts and our unalienable rights. This issue is merely being blown out of proportion to shift American opinion on the Muslim community. The same goes with the handful of people recorded dancing in the streets after 9/11 by FOX news. This is one the lamest attempt to label Muslims I've ever seen knowing there are 1.5 BILLION Muslims in this world. These people don't represente the Muslim community whatsoever and groups such as CAIR have come out and condemned the attacks on the WTC. In case some of you forgot, many Muslims died on 9/11 and a list can be found below: http://islam.about.com/blvictims.htm I sit here and read these comments and I can't stop shaking my head. Shame on you all.
35. #27 SETTHERECORDSTRA
Nate ,   USA   (08.16.10)
Isn't that classified as terrorism.. err wait.. no.. only Muslims can be terrorists right? Two wrongs don't make a right. Crawl back into your hole please.
36. One Term President
Ron ,   OC, USA   (08.16.10)
Zahar and hamas are the biggest reasons not to build this mosque at ground zero. Hamas supports the mosque and the mosque will support hamas.
37. Just like Kahane doesn't represent the Jewish people . . .
noa ,   israel   (08.16.10)
Hamas does not represent the Moslems.
38. Hamas + Obama = 2 sides of a coin: WAR
aviG   (08.16.10)
(Obama/NWO)
39. America's Day to Wake Up !!!
aviG   (08.16.10)
Throw away Essav and Ichmael in the same shot ... for your own sake.
40. ***Sarah*** at 20
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (08.16.10)
My favorite as an observer of the election was also Mr. McCain...
41. #2 Agreed
Dov ,   Tel Aviv   (08.16.10)
42. See story in Pajamas Media about the Imam
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (08.16.10)
of the Ground Zero Mosque, Feisal Abdul Rauf, and his (possible) ties to terrorist organizations. It certainly looks suspicious and is of major concern.
43. To: No. 28
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.16.10)
Be nice. I am getting the distinct feeling that you don't much care for Jews. Well, you need to put your money where your mouth is. Which is to say, you better hope you never need chemotherapy, because well over half of the chemotherapy protocols in use throughout the world were developed by Jews. I certainly hope you never need a pacemaker. And I strongly urge you to throw away your mobile phone -- that one's ours, too. I'm certain that you wouldn't dream of innoculating your children against polio -- Salk and Sabin -- yup. Both Jewish. And of course it goes without saying that you would never think of wearing jeans, now, would you? Yeah, that one's Jewish, too. There's lots more. Here's a little tidbit very few people realize. Did you know that the eighteen Jewish recipients of the Congressional Medal of Honor makes Jews, by percentage, the largest single group of Medal of Honor recipients? Did it stop there? No. Think of all those Jews who fled Nazi Germany and came to the United States and developed nuclear technology from nothing. Did you ever bother to stop and thank them for saving the one million estimated lives it would have cost had there been an invasion of the home islands of Japan? Perhaps you should. I've given you a tiny taste. Why don't you google "Jewish Nobel Prize laureates?" Did you know that Jews constitute by far and away the single largest group of Nobel recipients by percentage? There are only 12 million or so Jews in the world, and we have contributed so much. So why don't you take your common, garden-variety anti-Semitism and shove it? Or is it genetic, hereditary and unlikely to change?
44. #34 Nate, If you think it was...
E ,   Al Khobar   (08.16.10)
...only a few on Fox News, you obviously were not here!
45. why is Hamas singled out?
Jared ,   Stillwater   (08.16.10)
Why is there an article about Hamas supporting the NYC Mosque? is there a single Muslem group in the world that stands against the NYC Mosque?
46. Obama does believe!
Abby ,   OP,KS   (08.16.10)
Miracles of all miracles, the truth at last from Obama's lips. Twisted as his clarification next day, truth came out in front of his peers the night before. As he lectured on freedom to worship he did stop short to define the purposed mosque as trophy which is defined as a spoil of war,dedicated in classical antiquity with an inscription and set up as a temporary monument on or near a battlefield placed in an existing temple, or housed in a permanent new structure. Freedom to worship the issue here, no real American believes that for a moment. Our American president only a few years after 911, Unbelievable.
47. A mosque for....... prayer?
KO ,   UK   (08.16.10)
48. Doctrinaire Marxist-Leninists, Thomas #28?
Robert Haymond ,   Israel/Canada   (08.16.10)
Would you care to give us actual examples and illustrations as opposed to your drama which, as I read it, is highly overinflated and, as a result, lacks credibility? Just asking.
49. There are Churches in Lebanon, Palestine, Syria, Iraq, Egypt
Observer   (08.16.10)
etc..... No one is against Christians or Jews building Houses of Worship anywhere in the Arab world and Muslim world. Mecca is a special case, and Muslims are not even allowed to allow non Muslims to enter it. This is the law as prescribed in the Quran and this has nothing to do with religious freedom. Can you build a mosque inside St. Peter's Basilica . Mecca, all Mecca is forbidden to non Muslims. Now regarding NYC... If American public believe Islam is the enemy, then yes, having a mosque there is insensitive... In fact, Islam itself should be banned as a practice in the US. Similarly, is the American invasion of Iraq considered an attack by the Church on Iraq?? Similar question, Is the war on Terror a War on Islam as many Muslims perceive it? Answering these questions and being consistent in finding answers to them is at the core of this whole issue.
50. Al-zahar demands
~~Lengualima~~ ,   USAGBFR   (08.16.10)
Thank you Mr. Al-Zahar the world belong to Muslims and they must do all they want. the next will be Bin Laden tell us that we must permit to build the mosque where they want to do. I hope that the sentence "equally treated" include the families of the victims of 11/9.
51. We are not even allowed to pray on the Temple mount
daniel   (08.16.10)
52. Zahar understand what addled westerners don't....
Adina Kutnicki ,   Israel   (08.16.10)
Since the landing gear of one of the planes fell atop of the mosques site, it is mandatory that the mosque be built there. It serves as a triumphant symbol to Muslims world over, that atop the site of the biggest attack on US soil EVER, Islam will reign supreme. Therefore, they will NEVER agree to move it. Period.
53. #45;Jared, the answer to question, is YES
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (08.16.10)
First Hamas is singled out because they are a terrorist group and classified as such by the U.S., EU, and many other international bodies. Second, they are dedicated to the destruction of Israel, listed in their Charter, and confirmed by recent statements made this year, 2010. Third, maybe you do not watch the news, but I've seen several interviews with Muslims, that have taken the position, that the Mosque should not be built at that particular location, It not a question of if they have the legal right to do so, they do. It seems to many, just to be in poor taste and even an incitement.
54. to #37
truth ,   new york   (08.16.10)
ummm..... yeah..... hamas does represent the muslims. they voted for hamas.... overwhelmingly.
55. To: No. 37
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.16.10)
Are you forgetting the wild rejoicing that occurred throughout the entire Islamic world in the aftermath of September 11? Especially in the West Bank and Gaza. Sweets were handed out, rifles fired into the air, and women wept while kissing pictures of Osama bin Laden. Similar events took place in Bagladesh, Pakistan, Indonesia, Malaysia, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, pretty much all of the Islamic former Soviet republics and North Africa. I don't know about YOU, but I call that pretty damned representative.
56. does he represent the good model for him to demand?
ygalg ,   israel   (08.16.10)
how many Churches and synagogues in Gaza?
57. Hamas = Esau = spirit of Amalek
Galut ,   Selah   (08.16.10)
untill the spirit of Hate leaves Hamas ... thier prayers will not reach the ears of god.... thru the centuries the hate of esau desendants for jacob (israel) continues to exist ...the PA and hamas are currently holding that banner... peace is not the goal but rather the removal of israel...
58. Forget Mecca and Medina - try build a Synagogue in Gaza.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (08.16.10)
59. #43 and 48 reply
Thomas ,   Dixieland USA   (08.17.10)
I am E. European, I was born in the ghetto during Holocaust and my family was taken to Belsen, my father to the Russian front in Jewish work battalion.. Following WWII. I lived under Bolshevik terror. Listen up you know-it-all American Jews: the Jewish saga, all the horror from the 1917. Bolshevik revolution till the Holocaust happened in Eastern Europe not at the Wall Street: Israel was built by Holocaust survivors who smelled the stench of death while your pontificating little commie chomsky-s, zinn-s, judt-s axelrod-s, soros-s and al. spawned Marxism for the plebs (plebs, plebis Lat.) and capitalism for themselves. Please realize the 1st. Amendm. is fictional for Political Correctness supersedes it and I am unable to tell everything lest my post will be deleted.
60. Re #59
Galut ,   selah   (08.17.10)
Certianly Holocaust survivers have a unique perspective to share.... and it should be shared
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article