News  Magazine
Gaza doctor: I shall not hate
Ali Waked
Published: 17.08.10, 16:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. he descover what Israelis descovered in the 30's
ghostq   (08.17.10)
after joffa riots who killed many Israelis. I guess palis learn the hard way about the pain they cause others and themselves. so many tried to tell them the more violent they get the less they get and worse but they don't listen, so lil by lil reality kicks in, too late for seeing the light but it will explain were all the trouble begins, just a matter of time.
2. If not for the Gazan war
Shalom   (08.17.10)
he'd lose them as suicide bombers. We must thank G-d for saving innocent people.
3. :: Sarah BS and other Ynuts...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (08.17.10)
...would do well to read this book.
4. Please stay in Canada
Tony   (08.17.10)
and keep your propaganda there.
5. Dr. Abuelaish is a child of God
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (08.17.10)
"blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God"
6. He is an amazing person.
noa ,   israel   (08.17.10)
I am Israeli, and if it had happened to me, I would have hated the other side with all my heart. Most of us human beings are weak and mortal. May God bless him and lift his burden.
7. #3
Yaron ,   USA   (08.17.10)
Tool? Yes, of course...already been established as such.
8. Poorly written piece
GHook93 ,   Chicago   (08.17.10)
Shame on Ali Waked! This piece is horrendous. It distorts the poor doctor into looking like a terrorist apologist. He is anything but a terrorist apologist. He is a true peace activist. He has stated the Palestinians must be realistic and give in also. That terrorist are criminals.
9. The good doctor seems to be a ray of light...
Rafi ,   US   (08.17.10)
... in what is otherwise complete darkness.
10. what can i say but all due respect Doctor Abuelaish .
Salma ,   Palestine   (08.17.10)
But Dr. Abuelaish I wonder how you can not hate who killed your daughters?! Is it not human nature to love and hate, if not hate these murderers, so who is on the right side?! You or others ?! How many Abuelaish there is in this world ?!! hope many
11. Salma, maybe we are all on the right side?
Yitzhak ,   Holon Israel   (08.17.10)
Salma, first of all asalaam aleykum. In 1982 my best friend was killed by Palestinians. He was alone, unarmed, and ambushed by ten Palestinian youths who stabbed him to death over 100 times. The memory of this still hurts to this day. What can I say? Should I hate or choose not to hate? Dr. Abuelaish for me is a light, a ray of hope and an example of what we all need to do to stop the cycle of hatred that leads to violence that creates yet another cycle of hatred, then more violence, and so on. When do we stop all this? When do we as people caught up in this monstrosity of hate stop it all? Hate starts with each of us. So, each of us can stop the hate. If not now, when? Thank you Dr. Abuelaish for showing us all a possible way out.
12. #11 Yitzhak, your Q.s are very difficult for me:(
Salma ,   Palestine   (08.17.10)
thanks any way, i hope too to find "Israeli" light, can you help me?!! tell your "state" to end occupation, then maybeeach of us can stop the hate
13. thank you but.....
(08.17.10)
Thank you abuelaish for your superhumaninty and hope your book is goning to change how Isrelis perceive palestinians. However, please don't forget to mention the tens of families who were obliterated from the surface of of the planet in that war! What guit they've done to deserve all of this suffering? Please speak out on behalf of the those dead and spread the message!
14. faith is what got us into trouble in the first place.
ygalg ,   israel   (08.17.10)
less faith and more rationality would make a world better place.
15. The most awful tragedy possible
Canadian Dude ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.18.10)
Friends of Israel, and peacelovers in general (even if they don't support Israel) don't deserve to suffer like this. Any sane Israeli would wish they could do something to ease this good doctor's pain and bring his children back. Yet another reason war and targeted attacks should only be used as an absolute last resort, when every other option on the table has been thoroughly exhausted and it's an urgent matter of life and death that a specific target be hit.
16. # 1 Ghostq im sorry where is Joffa ?
Avi ,   Israel   (08.18.10)
Geee i guess you must have a great geographical skills ? Still what shold we expect from someone that obviously dosent live in Israel.
17. 5 Steve: Not unless they accept Yahweh as Lord and Yeshua as
(08.18.10)
Messiah. He may be a child of Allah, but not Yahweh. It is one or the other.
18. 12 Salma, Palestine: The Lord Yahweh, the creator of the
Rivkah   (08.18.10)
universe, gave Jerusalem and land far greater than present day Israel to the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob forever. He gave land to the descendants of Esau (you) and Ishmael and others. Anyone who is living in land Yahweh gave to the Jews is the occupier of stolen lands. The Jews are not occupiers of stolen lands. The latter rains returned when they returned to the Land Yahweh gave to them. Look at a map of the 56 or 57 Muslim nations and see the little sliver of land the Jews have and the huge vast lands the Muslims have. Maybe you can begin to understand that the Jews don't have much, but they are on land Yahweh gave them. Yahweh is not a liar and He does not change. Palestinians will be destroyed if they do not back off and leave the Jews alone. Palestinians have 56 or 57 countries to migrate to where they can speak Arabic. They should go there before Yahweh judges them.
19. Salma, I hear you. But, it takes 2 to make war
Yitzhak ,   Holon Israel   (08.18.10)
Salma, I understand your anger. Please read Dr. Abuelaish's book. His message of "I Shall not Hate" is for Israelis and Palestinians alike. He has every reason to hate, so do I, and so do you. Trust me, I more than understand this. I also want the occupation to end, but I need to feel that when our army leaves the West Bank, then that territory won't become like Gaza. The hatred is on both sides, and it is this hatred that fuels the violence by both sides. It takes two to make war. It takes two to make peace.
20. to #16 that is the original name of the place
ghostq   (08.18.10)
near Tell Aviv, that is how it showed up in old testament and new, Petrus preform great mirakle there and if you don't know your own city it just show how delusional you r, BTW lod is not Lod the original name is LYdia was Roman city which also mention in the new testament. go learn about your own city no wonder you r left winger your lake of proper info and education is missing.
21. Gazans caused his pain, NOT Israel
iObserver and News ,   US-Israel   (08.18.10)
Forgiveness is wonderful when it can be achieved, however, the doctors words of forgiveness are tempered with an obvious lack of respect for Israel and the Jews. His reasoning and speaking ability reveals a very child-like demeanor...very unrealistic. Forgiveness is for a questionable crime against others where emotions and motive collide in a moment of weakness and the person shows true remorse. The Palestinians have NO remorse for the pain and suffering they've caused: in fact, they enjoy it. As such, any reasonably sane human would see that forgiveness in some cases is not even a consideration. The IDF did NOT intend to harm the doctors family but the doctorsown kin, people and culture DID intend to kill innocent Jews and CAUSE pain. Unfortunately, the doctors pain is drowned out by his own peoples and religions hatred for others. Such is the plight he stayed in and with. But Israel does NOT forgive nor CAN they forgive, on behalf of our perished, the hateful acts of the Palestinians. Israel has the logical, existential right to continue to crush Palestinian hatred at every turn without having to apologize or explain. It is obvious for any intelligent person to see this existential right to secure a peaceful life. If these people were doing this in the US, American citizens themselves would have taken the law into their own hands and obliterated them....dropping them into the sea or Mexico. And not a damn lunatic in the world would have a say or an investigation. When it comes to survival and Palestinian fanatacism, all parameters of engagment must be taken off the table and Israel should destroy their self-sworn enemy every chance they get. The hate and murder by Palestinians has gone on too long. It's time to put our money where THEIR mouth is: enough is enough. The doctor dug his own daughters graves living among an insane people. Indeed, he must forgive "himself"....if that is at all possible. Loss of life is always tragic: but putting it at obvious risk as he did is just plain stupid. Hope he can 'cope' with his choice. It was really expensive.
Back to article