Yes , Proud to belong to the Jewish people , but not proud of those who don't contribute to the State , don't servbe in IDF , and so on . No so proud either of how many chapters in Josue ends . Also torah based ? Yes , very propud of the contribution of all those secular Jews who contributed so much to HUMANITY , and their contribution was'nt torah based either . I told you already i think , for me the torah is ONLY the history of MY people , nothing else . שבת שלום

Why is it that your favorit ennemies are the Haredis?I don t bother with most tbs here who insult the Haredis,because i think they are not worth wasting my time.But you don t enter in this category,as you seem to me, more clever than them.As you could also find criticable things in the secular world,and never mention them,i am asking myself if you once were hurt by Haredies.If so ,don t put them all in the same pot.There are also very fine Haredies.

My favorite enemies are NOT the charidim as a whole . # 1 are FAKE people , people who pretend to be Jewish but are NOT in my eyes [ paqid and josh ] I don't like people who try to impose their lifestyle on me . I don't like , and you for a part agree , people who only study , don't join the IDF , live at our expenses and do not contribute to the State , certainly not financially . Those two categories are charidim . As you are new on this site , you probably did'nt see my appreciations for Charidim who contributed , and still do it , to all of us . So let's hope that we don't need Zaka , Ezer Mitzyion , Yad Sarah , and other's of this kind , but they are here in time of urgency . All those of course founded by Charidim . That they do it because they think to be rewarded "ba'olam Habbah" is not important , they DO IT . If there is an article about seculars acting in a way i dislike , i'll also tell it . And i react also to some who HATE all the charidim , and sometimes are disgusting . No , i was never hurt by a charidi , even those who shouted "shabbes" at me did'nt touch me , to low level , and i have a "peau d'elephant" There is much more needed to hurt me .

Thank you Charles for your friendly answer.I am happy to learn that you are not ,as i feared, antiharedi in principle.