News
Next Turkish blockbuster revisits Marmara
Ynet
Published: 04.09.10, 10:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
26 Talkbacks for this article
1. I want to see Israel producing tv series about The Armenian
ARMENIAN HOLOCAUST ,   CURDS MURDERED   (09.04.10)
Holocaust and how Turkey Murdering Curd Just For Oil With No Mercy!
2. What has Erdogan done...
Omri ,   Israel   (09.04.10)
3. Just wondering
CJ   (09.04.10)
When are we going to see: Valley of the Wolves: The Armenians Valley of the Wolves: The Kurds Valley of the Wolves: Northern Cyprus Valley of the Wolves: Greece
4. Turks and Palestinians have nothing in common
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (09.04.10)
Turks are not Arabs, and have nothing in common with Palestinians - different culture, different language, and different history. They are completely different people. Thus I find it hard to explain this sudden surge of pro-Palestinian sentiments in Turkey recently. Interestingly enough, it was the "Palestinians" who stabbed Turkey in the back at the end of the Ottoman empire here. So, is this craziness in Turkey all because of this crazy Islamist Erdogan? He is leading Turkey straight into Islamofascist hell. And if we can't punish Turkey for making ghastly movies like this, maybe our American friends can.
5. #4
Omri ,   Israel   (09.04.10)
Turks have the same religion as Arabs and that actually means a lot. Turkey has the highest number of Pro-Iranians in the civilized world (including the arab countries). Its not surprising that the public there is relatively anti-Israel.
6. Turks or Kurds - our choice is obvious
Dov ,   IL   (09.04.10)
A relevant comparison: http://www.jpost.com/Home/Article.aspx?id=186542
7. "Palestinians" live in sub-human conditions because of Arabs
michael redbourn ,   Arad - Israel   (09.04.10)
The film makers are either ignorant or think that everybody else is. The PA does not permit the children of Balata to go to local schools. It does not permit the people of Balata to build outside the one square kilometer. The people of Balata are prevented from voting in local elections, and the PA provides none of the funds for the necessary infrastructure of the camp — including sewers and roads. Balata and the other refugee camps are showcases of contrived misery. They are Potemkin villages in reverse. Naïve peace activists and unsophisticated Western clergy are led through such camps to witness the refugee drama, with Israel conveniently and prominently cast in the role of villain. And the same shameful behavior is repeated in every Arab country. Michael
8. Script Writer of Turkish 'Valley of the Wolves' is CIA
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (09.04.10)
'Valley of the Wolves' was initiated to degas boiling Turkish Public opinion against US maltreatment of Turkish soldiers in Iraq Then occasionaly it is used to degas for other issues. Even Shore Stone come to kiss in the play to support CIA screen play I never watch 'Valley of the Wolves' and I will not this either.
9. How about "Valley of the Poison Gas"
Ehud   (09.04.10)
Quietly - because this is less interesting in the eyes of the "international community" - an investigation is running following "allegations" the Turkish army used poison gas attacks to kill Kurdish (Iraqi) civilians in 2009. Yeah, right, the year during which Erdogan lectured us about excessive force in Gaza. Read about it in "Der Spiegel" and "The New York Times". We will keep the subject alive as it should be!
10. Valley of idiots
Sceptique ,   France   (09.04.10)
This new hatemongering movie proves only one thing: that some Turks are not able to recognize antisemitism when they see it. And while Erdogan will support this stupid world-view, relations with Israel will be strained.
11. Ehud #9
Goody2Shoes ,   United Kingdom   (09.04.10)
Ehud mate. It was Saddam that gassed the Kurds. Your propogamda is something that evil swine goebbels would have been proud of. Have some shame will you! Also the Marmara was not filled with terrorists (as the WHOLE world knows). There is footage on Youtube that the IDF missed in stealing that shows the vessel before and during the attack. Why dont you go take a butchers at it mate. At least the Turks did not steal Brittish passports, hang Brittish Seargents in the Olive groves, bomb the King David hotel (Stern gang) and sink the USS USS Liberty. Oh and I hear the IDF also stole laptops, mobiles etc off the vessel and sold them on.
12. #11 You comparing stealing laptops to killing 45,000 Kurds?
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (09.04.10)
The chemical attack on Kurds in Turkey did happen last year as reported in world press and rumors about it abound here with many grotesque details disclosed by individuals who participated in it. Both Arabs and Turks have been massacring Kurds for centuries. Turkey has committed war crimes against Kurds for the last 25 years in which it slaughtered 45,000 Kurds. The Israeli soldier who stole laptops is being prosecuted and will go to jail for several years but nothing is going to happen to Turkish war criminals. Be happy in UKistan with Sharia courtesy of Pakistan. May you have more London Tube and Glasgow Islamic Doctors events.
13. #11 No difference terrorist and shahids!
Rehavam ,   Israel   (09.04.10)
or you argue that there was NO shahids on Marmara? and this 'Valley of the Wolves' only possible in "Vally of Stupid Turks"...
14. We need a movie about the Armenian Genocide / Kurdish persec
Elly ,   Vienna, Austria   (09.04.10)
We need a movie about the Armenian genocide, persecution of Kurds, Greeks and Greek Cypriots.
15. yes, you right.. Dead terrorist=Shahid
Mariana ,   Greece   (09.04.10)
16. To Imposter 12 Turkish Army is heroic legend not like IDF
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (09.04.10)
Turkish army never use Chemical weapons, and there is no chemical weapon in Turkish army inventory Highly possible when turkey bombed Terrorist bases their ammunition containg chemicals fired or it is totaly not true claim without any solid base. Turkish army did not kill 45 kurds it was total number of Turkish citizens killed during crashes, military loses are included. Turish army is a heroic legend, donot compare to IDF. As for you Imposter: I just find out who you were. I never post using other persons' names. You are the one who is afraid to confront me in your real talkback name for long, you dodge away most of the time talkbacking to me I noticed this. you are the poisonous Ivy! from Ivy League You coward!
17. Marmara
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (09.04.10)
I guess that very quickly we can expect a soap opera "Marmara, Love Boat" and maybe, sometime in the future even some porn staff, Marmara, Queen Of Deep (Waters).
18. Turkish press
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv / israel   (09.04.10)
Part of the Turkish press is awash with stories concerning jews/israelis which even a 5 year old would not believe.
19. Dont insult wolves.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (09.04.10)
20. Stop blaming Turkish people for leaders statements
Mark ,   usa   (09.04.10)
Do you balme the entire US citizens for Bush, or Obama, do I blame entire Jewish people for BiBi, leaders are one person, they are ellected to do the job, and not many choices people choose lesser of two evil, so people STOP blaming the citizens of the country for the leaders mistakes, they have just as much power os you do to change things, I am asking Israelies if you want to change your leader tomorrow can you do it, NO, so Stop bad mouthing Turks constantly, I never seen so much hate coming from the public of Israel, and Turks were always supported the Jews, and onr leader look at all this hate,STOP
21. #16, is someone getting under your skin?
(09.05.10)
You seem to have a very short fuse, quick to accuse others but unwilling to take in any criticism. The one you call impostor knows real history, unlike you revising history without a basis to suit your current aims after annihilating hundreds of nations since your unwelcome arrival from Central Asia, Asiatic! You belong to somewhere else, Europe doesn't want or need you!
22. Fitting for a work of fiction
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (09.05.10)
Look, kudos for the guy knowing how to make buck with a work of fiction. The flotilla should be settled by now. The videos show that the passengers started the fight, the organizers admitted the goal was NOT to deliver aid, but, to break the blockade. So this should be a CASE CLOSED story. But it will be kept alive as a new myth of oppression. It has become a classic case of Pallywood revisionism. We all saw what happened, everything Israel did was legal, from the blockade to the enforcement of the blockade. The only issue for debate is did the IDF use "disproportional force", everything else is settled law, with Israel conforming to ALL international laws and standards. With regards to "force", that is simply Monday night quarterbacking. From the videos, clearly, the IDF soldiers were mobbed by terrorists armed with knives and metal rods the size of baseball bats. The IDF came aboard with paint-guns as their weapons of first choice. Proving beyond a shadow of doubt that their intention was to minimize civilian injury. When the combatants, terrorist, passengers, humanitarian activists, or, what ever you want to call them, escalated the conflict to one of deadly force, only then did the IDF begin shooting. Bottom line Israel is NOT guilty of anything. But heck, it will make a great movie, and foster the David and Goliath conflict they want to portray. Pretty remarkable considering that over 99.5% of all the land in the Middle East is controlled by Muslims. That at present, Hamas, Hezbollah/Lebanon, Iran and Syria have all ganged up on Israel and have threatened to destroy Israel, even signing agreements to help each other (if one is attacked they all jump on Israel). Sounds like Israel is David not Goliath, right?
23. #11: you are just as "human" as the British
(09.21.10)
were at the time of King David bombing, refusing to let in what was left of Nazi victims after WW2. You and many of your people are not better than those Nazis. You deserve the Arabs who have actually taken over your country. I wonder when will your queen be forced to wear Burka...
24. #20: Muslims have taken over Turkey and
Vardina   (09.21.10)
From then on Turkey has become and Islamic terrorist power. How can anyone not hate terrorists headed by Arduan! As to Bibi: We support him. How can you compare him to terror supporter and jew hater Arduan?
25. #22: You are very naive hoping to convince
Vardina   (09.21.10)
Muslims by telling the truth. They do not know the meaning of the word. By the way, using knives and stabbing people to death are considered "peaceful negotiation" in ther places in addition to sodomizing....
26. #4 Israelis have no thing in common
Mamud ,   Lebanon   (11.16.10)
Some whites some blacks like chess board.
Back to article