News
Sha'ath: PA will never recognize Israel as Jewish
Ynet
Published: 08.09.10, 23:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
142 Talkbacks for this article
1. But the open Palestinian/BHO declaration
Arie ,   BaGolan   (09.08.10)
that a Palestinian State would be Judenrein is fully acceptable
2. The cat is out of the bag
CJ   (09.08.10)
The Arabs are the same Arabs and the sea is the same sea. Bibi uncovered their faces, the Arabs still want to destroy Israel, they seek no peace. Those are the 'moderate peace partners'.
3. Israel IS a Jewish State
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (09.08.10)
IN 1948 the UN defined Israel as a Jewish State. Why is Israel wasting time sitting and "talking" with these idiots. We should be doing whatever it takes to protect ourselves and our people. Our interests do NOT overlap their's and it is time that is realized!
4. Israel existed 3500 years before Islam!!!!!
Jason   (09.08.10)
All arabs out!
5. I say rip down arab villages and send everyone packing to
John ,   Texas   (09.08.10)
jordan.
6. NO SUCH THING AS WEST BANK! ONLY Judea & Samaria!
Shalom ,   Judea   (09.08.10)
7. Not important - give them what they want
Peace Now ,   Israel   (09.08.10)
8. What's the point of these talks
Rachel ,   US   (09.08.10)
The Pals want a state AND the right of return to Israel? Why is Bibi wasting time?
9. Who could by the wildest
Gideon Reader ,   USA   (09.08.10)
stretch of the imagination have foreseen this coming. That the alleged "Palestinians" would raise such stupid and hackneyed objections at a "peace" negotiation. Boggles the mind and baffles the soul. Or something or other. But NOT to worry or concern. Barky Zerobama is on the job and is making this his Number One Priority; among his other 100 or so other Number One Priorities. It is for sneering, and making light of.
10. 22 Arab states a ticking time bomb. NM.
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.08.10)
11. These guys are total morons
J K ,   NYC, USA   (09.08.10)
Right, they want their state to be based on armistice lines they call 'borders' (there is a difference, look it up), to have the land emptied of Jews and they are trying to tell us that the Arabs Israel made citizens 60 years ago are suddenly in danger because Israel demands reciprocity from the 'Palestinians' No wonder these morons won't accept a deal. Again with the 100% or nothing demands and the principle of establishing a country based on getting rid of all non-Muslims. Why the world agrees to this farce is beyond comprehension.
12. These are the so-called moderates that the West gives money?
Rachel ,   N.Carolina   (09.08.10)
Stop giving my taxes to Terrorist muslim "palestinians"
13. Rachel #12 yes these are the 'moderates'
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.08.10)
These are the most moderate Arabs you will find. Their most moderate is more extreme than are most extreme Jew.
14. finally ,the truth for once!
OZ   (09.08.10)
ok ,the arabs finally cane out of thier lynig tent ,and said what we all knew well before-- basically the 3 no of khartum. there won't be peace with israel, no real negotiations, and no recognition. only a real defeat of the arabs ,once and for all will bring a forced agrrement and seperation between them and us!
15. Israel is what it is, a Jewish state
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (09.08.10)
Only the whiners will complain. With 57 Muslim countries of the 192 UN members states, the Jewish people have every right to a Jewish state. The original reason for Israel's rebirth, was for a Jewish state, period. The Balfour Declaration states, and I quote: ""His Majesty's government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people", Israel was founded as a Jewish state, it was the purpose for Israel. What the Arabs are saying is simple, Israel does not have a right to exist. The rest of their arguments are simply BS. There is no "right of return" anyway, and that fantasy needs to end. The refugees will go to their new and first country ever, it will be called Palestine. Not Israel.
16. What the "Two State Solution" really means
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (09.08.10)
The Palestinians want one completely Jew-free state NOW, and another state with some Jews in it, that they can drive out LATER.
17. Bibi Needs to Walk Out on this Farce, Obama Needs a Backbone
izzie irgun ,   zion   (09.08.10)
I am not sure which reflects worse on the palestinians, their denial of israel as the eternal home of the jewish people or their contiuned demand for the right of return .. both are losing ideas and bibi should walk out and let them and the world know that if peace does not include arab recognition of israel as a jewsih state then there will be no peace. and this occurs while obama and clinton sit around like jerks supporting this chrade instead of coming out and telling it like it is .. as of yesterday Castro became more of a man than obama is, at least he told iran the truth and to stop the games while obama contiunes to play them
18. Right Of Return?
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (09.08.10)
The Palestinians need to get over it. The so-called "Right of Return" is a non starter along with most of the other conditions they are demanding.
19. True Colors Once
Brazen   (09.08.10)
again, how may I ask can ANY talks direct or indirect proceed with countertuitive Blasphamy from these arabs? There is No chance for ANYTHING with this attitude let alone peace !!!
20. Jewish state is dangerous
Ezra ,   Florida   (09.08.10)
Since the establishment of Israel in 1948, no arab country evevr acknowledged Israel as the Jewish srtate. Now these scums are dictating the rules how THEY WILL ACCEPT the generosity of the jewish people who are trying to give them a piece of Israel and they try to dictate all the terms of HOW THEY WILL ACCEPT THIS DONATION. How about it, Obama, will there be more pressure on Israel to shove these terms down the Israeli throat?
21. #7 it is important
Omri ,   Israel   (09.08.10)
Without that they can freely make war with Israel whenever they want saying "Israel is illegal, we do not recognize it so we can do whatever we want".
22. #12
Omri ,   Israel   (09.08.10)
The west gives them money as a bribe for them not to make terror attacks. The more money one has the less he wants to go suicide in some bus.
23. According to U.N. 181, Israel is the Jewish State
(09.08.10)
"If the international community defines Israel as a Jewish state – such a decision should be approved by the UN," Aboul Gheit ..... it has already been approved very clearly some 63 years before, dear M Gheit, Look inside the Rés. 181....
24. So, Bibi...
Eli ,   Raanana   (09.08.10)
...pack your stuff and come back. No reason to waste more time with them.
25. Recognising Israel as Jewish State
JUDAH THE LION   (09.08.10)
The Palestinians and all the Muslim World MUST RECOGNISE ISRAEL AS JEWISH STATE FOREVER,Failing to this demand, then Israel should tell the arabs to go to hell.NO DEAL NO DEAL
26. PA will never recognize Israel and thats it
Dani ,   Amsterdam NL   (09.08.10)
Always the same history they will never recognize us the right to exist, this is as always Palestinians/Arabs last word, so what we can do now I create a diplomatics Tsunami al around the world explaining them the reason why is not possible to have peace talks with those who do not have the whees to recognize our right to exist,
27. This is just Obama's election show
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (09.08.10)
A badly written soap opera could offer more surprises than this poor repeat show. As a Jewish settler it can be hard to find common ground with Abbas, but I must admit that he's just as victim to this US election ploy than Bibi or anyone else. The biggest question is what do we get when Obama doesn't try to impose peace on us....(drum roll)...yes we actually get peace! Makes you think doesn't it? I'm content to let Abbas fleece the EU for every penny he can get, although it's a pity that his own people should suffer hardship through not getting an economic infrastructure in place as a side result. Truthfully, local Jews & Arabs actually living in our region can solve our own squabbles by ourselves given the chance. Oh, for all those ignorant Anti-Israelis out there, Shiloh has a solid Jewish background thousands of years before the first Muslims entered our land. However, I guess the West's Bank got its despicable name from Western interests...David, Shiloh the Shomron.
28. they'll recognize israel sooner or later
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (09.08.10)
they have no choice, especially since future aid will be dependent on their recognition. besides, they only make themselves look like fools for refusing to admit obvious facts. and they wonder why they don't get respect.
29. Let's be clear on 1 thing
Muayyad ,   Palestine   (09.08.10)
Palestinians will never (ever) recognize the state of Israel as a "Jewish" state, just as we don't expect you to recognize Palestine as an Islamic or Christian state. Just the same as Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan have no official religions. The only acceptable recognition of Israel already came in 1988 - and that is of "the state of Israel". Anybody who thinks more can come out of the negotiations on this subject is simply dreaming. You're reading the opinion of a liberal, Wester-educated Palestinian.
30. Care? Why?
Rachmiel ,   MburgUSA   (09.08.10)
This is incitement so bad that I have to comment on it a second time. When have these guys cared a wit about anyone else other than themselves and only then because they have to? Christian, Jewish, anyone else other than themselves are at best, at best, third class people and only suitable to make way for Islam. And now we should care? Why?
Next talkbacks
Back to article