News
Clinton: There may never be another chance for peace
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 08.09.10, 20:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
1. mind your own business
Marcel ,   Florida   (09.08.10)
Go take care of your own mess. You've had 17 years to screw Israel up with your lies and false peace,enough is enough.
2. last chance is no chance as long as Israel insist on ....
Belal ,   Atlanta USA   (09.08.10)
Israel wants Abbas to accept Israel as Jewsish state. You will find only 2 Palestinian leaders who would agree to that, one that who died already, the other has never been born yet, another word, stop dreaming. If Palestinians agree to that condition, that means abandening the right for return which is impossible. no Palestinian leader have the right to do that, it is not his decsion alone, it is my decsion too and lots of people who lost there house and property like my parents did.
3. Strike "another chance for"
emanon ,   USA   (09.08.10)
As long as the arabs hate us more than they love their children, there will never be peace. It is in their nature to hate. They can't even get along with each other.
4. Totally delusional thinkers are in charge in America.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.08.10)
5. real estate broker at work
vitenberg ,   FRANCE   (09.08.10)
no more comment
6. WHAT peace talks?
Christopher ,   Boston, MASS   (09.08.10)
All we hear all day is the Palestinians making threats and BHO, Clinton, and the House Jews going out of their way to pull an "Haaretz" and humiliate Israeli leadership
7. Old adversaries
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.08.10)
Guess what? Nothing old about it. Abbas' past is what it is, and nothing can change it. Instead of forcing concessions upon Israel, why not see how far you get urging Abbas to renounce the Fatah charter (which calls for the destruction of the State of Israel and the extermination and/or expulsion of the Jews)? Why not pressure him to make a public statement acknowledging the absolute right of the Jewish people to have a national homeland in their ancient home? And why would anyone think it is a particularly good idea to treat terrorist rabble as if they actually constitute a valid negotiating partner or an honest broker? Oh, and did I forget to mention the little matter of three rejected opportunities to have a two-state solution? The Palestinians do not want to have their own state -- they couldn't govern themselves out of a brown paper bag -- they want Israel. As if that would ever happen. If Hussein Obama wishes to make his mark upon history, he'd better find another vehicle. You cannot make peace with people who actively seek your destruction.
8. If there has to be a Palestinian state
Golani ,   Vineland, USA   (09.08.10)
If there has to be a Palestinian State, they the Palestinians, and all Muslim countries have to agree that Israel, as the Jewish State has to have securie boundaries and must be recognized for what it is, the Jewish Homeland. Otherwise, there is nothing to negotiate. Sarah B, I have to meet you one day.
9. to #3
Belal ,   Atlanta USA   (09.08.10)
dont talk about hate, i have seen more hatred from Jewish extremest and settlers to last a life time. look at that IDF solders who posted pictures with palestinian presoners. please dont talk about hatred.
10. Good Belal. Then you will never have a State....
Zeev ,   Bat Yam   (09.08.10)
We have ours already and we know it is a Jewish State. Keep fighting and you'll have nothing. Like always. Seems like you decided to live in Atlanta. Funny. I moved from there to here.
11. #1 - Why don't you mind your own gentile business.
(09.08.10)
12. geezz.. how i love them both...
eporue ,   europe   (09.08.10)
hillary and obama... they are so smart, intelligent, clear thinkers and to-the-point-rhetorics :)
13. it is depend on you Ms.Clinton !
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.08.10)
can you stop supporting "Israel" ?!!
14. To: Golani at No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.08.10)
Sure. I'll buy you lunch.
15. The Jewish State, Israel
Jan ,   Houston, Texas   (09.08.10)
Peace for peace, land for land, threats for threats. If the Palis set conditions, so must Israel. If the Palis cannot accept Israel as a Jewish state, then we cannot accept their new state as a Muslim state...period. If Arabs are allowed to live in Israel, so must Jews be allowed to live in all Arab countries, old and new. Israel should threaten to walk out if their minimum demands cannot be met. ISRAEL, the JEWISH STATE FOREVER!!!!!
16. Last Chance ...lol lol Israel dont get forced into it !!!!
Gr ,   USA   (09.08.10)
17. to Golani, #8
Kurt ,   Austria   (09.08.10)
Sara B. is absolutely right and any person in the world understand that Muslim countries elsewhere and in Middle East particularly NEVER will live in peace neither with Jewish nor with Christian state. Examples? Balkan states, Lebanon and many others. Muslims want to destroy Israel and next step - Europe.
18. "there may never be another chance for peace"
tom ,   toronto, canada   (09.09.10)
"there may never be another chance for peace" - in obama (and clinton's) political lifetime. if these talks fail, the chances don't look so good for obama's re-election in 2012, and hillary will be somewhat past her "sell by" date in 2016. "and there arose a new pharaoh in egypt, who did not know joseph..."
19. Balal, never
Eyal ,   USA   (09.08.10)
No return, never will happen, you are dreaming, otherwise this means you want both Palestine and the ultimate goal Israel. You can't have both, it's a crazy dream. You want to keep fighting, than be it and you won't have Palestine, which you won't anyways. Perhaps if you talked to Egypt and ask them if the Jewish refugees can have back their houses and money they lost when Egypt kicked them out? This will never happen, neither your dream of having 2 states Palestine and Israel, you greedy dummy. The next war will come and your stupid non-educated dream will completely vanish, so be it.
20. # 13
Birdi ,   Israel   (09.08.10)
can you stop posting here ?
21. Belal # 9
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (09.08.10)
So Belal, when is the last time you saw the IDF go beserk over a cartoon? You throw hatred at everyone and as soon as somebody throws the least little amount back at you, you can't take it. Quit being such a cry baby.
22. #9 - Right, Belal...she posed for pictures....
Zeev ,   Bat Yam   (09.09.10)
She didn't CHOP SOMEBODY'S HEAD OFF like your kind do. Of course what she did was wrong. But nobody does KILLING like your kind. Nobody. And by that I mean arabs and muslims.
23. #9; Belal, are you kidding?
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (09.09.10)
You mention the pictures taken by IDF soldiers, as if they were a horror. Have you ever seen your brothers beheading dozens of innocent victims. The people jumping from the Towers on 9/11, followed by the Palestinians cheering those acts in the streets. The recent Hamas parade celebrating the "heroic" murders of 4 Jewish civilians, one a pregnant women and a mother of six. You speak of seeing enough hatred and blame the IDF? Get your priorities straight. It's that bizarre moral equivalency you have? You whine about nothing, then your silence is deafening at the real horrors, perpetrated by your people, or at least those you apparently sympathize with.
24. #2You may go on dreaming of "return". We
(09.09.10)
gave a lot of time and patience. The Jewish state will live forever and you will dream forever.
25. Sham
NVO ,   Jerusalem   (09.09.10)
Look at any Arab map, and they do not recognize Israel. That said, what good will any peace talks do with the USA when they want to divide Jerusalem anyway? When they finally do part the land, WW3 will start for "they parted MY land"=Joel 3:2. Prophesy yet to be fulfilled.
26. Israel Should Dictate the Terms
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (09.09.10)
Ever notice that the Pales speak from both sides...either you agree to our temrs, or else. The pattern continues..and is boring., Yes, the Pales were offered a state..beginning in 48. We all know what happened..10 wars..with Israel still in existence.Arafat and Abbas behave as if they won..and hold the ground. Are they delusional or just on something? The opposite..would they be talking now? Read M. Orens Six Day War for insight. Here in LA..a small gorup of people protested an LAPD shooting of an armed drunk. 3 days of protests to date..with the police using horses, tear gas..batons, making arrests. Israeli police allow continued protest of a violent nature..firing rubber bullets. Abbas (and Erekat) refuse a Jewish state..and demand right of return, a non-starter. Yet they want to start where Olmert left off. What chutspah. Last chance, oh come on. Nothing is final in the M.E...just another chapter in the goal to rid the area of every Jew. That's the bottom line. Talks break down,okay, Israel should annex parts of the W. Bk. bomb Hamas 4-7, remove any Muslim who practices sedition or treason. Hang Bargouti and Arabs with blood on their hands. Stop playing around. Israel should dictate the terms. In the end, that is what they will have to do anyway.
27. Hamas/Hez/Iran Are Being Honest
Dav Lev ,   Burbank.CA   (09.09.10)
Why doesn't Bibi just say it, Israel always and forever a Jewish state. That it. You don't like it, stuff it. (More politely). No Jewish state, okay,no Muslim state on the W. Bk. Look, two states were created, oneJewish, the other Arab (among 22 states). Jordan isthe real Palestine ( Eastern half). Israel has 1m in its army, 5,000 tanks, 700 warplanes, thosands of rockets.,.and 400 nukes..and it acquiesces to Abbas? Oh come on. Israel is living like ghetto Jews..cowering before the Europeans and Russians. Jews were there before the Arabs..the Arabs stole our biblical land. The Mufti planned to exterminate every Jew. All the wars since were fought to make the area Judenrein. Why is Israel being so polite and diplomatic/? At least Hamas/Hez and Iran are being honest about their goals.
28. peace talks
steve james ,   san diego, usa   (09.09.10)
Secretary Clinton cannot be more wrong! Land appeasement will never satisfy Israel's enemies. The more land given the Palestians, the closer they'll be to Israel's total demise. How can this administration be so naive given the history of this conflict.
29. Don't Tell Us
Dan ,   Titusville, FL   (09.09.10)
Tell the Palestinians that they need to make serious and MAJOR concessions NOW so that we can talk. No Palestinian concessions now...NO TALKS and institute the Jordan & Gaza Two State Solution.
30. Shana Tova
herb glatter ,   jenkintown pa usa   (09.09.10)
Sarah B and others Happy Healthy New Year
Next talkbacks
Back to article