News
Algeria bans Korans bearing Star of David
Roee Nahmias
Published: 11.09.10, 18:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. Magen David on Qur'an Most Appropriate.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (09.11.10)
Considering how much Mohammed borrowed from Judaism to construct his new religion, it's really very appropriate to have a Jewish Star on the Qur'an. If Mohammed did the same thing today, he would be sued for copyright infringement & plagarism. Of course, he didn't do such a good job, he got a lot of it confused & mixed up. All things considered, I think we should be grateful to the Algerian bigots - personally, I wouldn''t want our religious symbols on such a nasty book.
2. So they want Jew Free?
Jethro ,   Marquette, MI   (09.11.10)
Sound Familiar.
3. STAR OF DAVID + QURAN = MUSLIM JEWS :-)
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (09.11.10)
I MET TWO IN TURKEY- JEWS WHO ARE MUSLIMS...BUT THEY WERE AFRAID TO ADMIT THEIR ORIGIN...ANYWAY WE ALSO HAVE MUSLIM JEWS :-) SHABATAI ZEVI AND GANG, YOUNG TURKS CANT DROP OF THE STAR OF DAVID :-) I GUESS THEY WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO SHAKE OF THE STAR :-) LOOK IF YOU ARE JEWISH YOU ARE JEWISH- YOU JUST CANT CHANGE THE CALL.....I TRIED TO SHAKE THE STAR OF WHEN I WAS PERSECUTED ION SO MANY WAYS..BUT I AM STILL AROUND.. WHERE CAN YOU RUN , WHERE CAN YOU HIDE,EVERY THING THAT YOU TOUCH HAS A TOUCH OF JEWISHNESS IN IT ! TODAY I AM FREE, TOMORROW i DONT KNOW :-) MY TORAH WAS STOLEN AND RETURNED WITH THE ARAFAT SHAWL, NO EXPLANATION GIVEN TO DATE, AS AS A JEW I HAVE TO STAY WITH THAT KIND OF ATROCITIES FOR THE SAKE OF PEACE OR ALL :-) EVEN THE MODECHAI ABERGEL TOLD ME TO SHUT UP ( NOT TO TALK ABOUT IT ) AT THE JUNCTION NEAR THE OXLEY SYNAGOGUE
4. What do you want to bet
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.11.10)
... that these hypocrites will burn the confiscated Qu'urans?
5. I think it is good thing. Almost millenium
leo ,   usa   (09.11.10)
ago it took one khalif to cut the number of Quaran versions down to one. Removing Mogen David is just a beginning. Later they will start altering Quaran's context to remove every mention of People Of The Book from it. The more of different versions of Quaran Muslims will have the better it is for the rest of us. Let them fight over who is better Muslim for eternity.
6. If the world were free of religion...
hozudo ,   springfield, usa   (09.11.10)
Where would we get all these irrelevant controversies? We might get so bored as to actually have to start discussing real issues that really matter. Such a tragedy that would be...
7. star of david in koran?wait a minutes...
Anna maria Sedda ,   Italy-Rome   (09.11.10)
why should muslims steal a star of King David to put it in a Satanic book?i don't get it... Can someone explain to me ,please?
8. Hatred & Ignorance
Rube Vogel ,   Jerusalem   (09.11.10)
Anybody who has made a trip to the Islamic Museum here in Jerusalem knows that the symbol we call the "Star of David" occurs in tons of Islamic art. As usual, ignorance and hatred trump everything else.
9. They will have to demolish the
Ariel ,   Modi'in, Israel   (09.11.10)
Dome of the Rock (otherwise known as Al Aqsa) because it is adorned with Stars of David all over. Wouldn't that be a novel idea!! The Muslims destroying Al Aqsa?? That would save the Jews from having to do it....
10.  ***Sarah*** at No. 4
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (09.11.10)
This was a direct hit... MARVELLOUS...!!!
11. For once, Arabs are right
Frank ,   Canada   (09.11.10)
Putting a Magen David on a Quran is an insult to Jews.
12. #1 - everything up to the violence came from other faiths
William ,   Israel   (09.11.10)
Every single thing, from the history of Moses and Jews heading to God-given Israel, to the birth and followings of Jesus. It's only when he added violence, pedophilia, rape, and subjugation, in order to appease the trial elements in Arabia, did the true light of Islam shine through and it was accepted. Quite often, Muslims revert to the later, violent parts in lieu of the early, peaceful parts, because it justifies their beliefs - e.g. "kill a Jew" vs "Jews will return to their land given to them by G-d and woe to those who wish to stop them".
13. #2 - yes, but they call it "ethics of the State"
William ,   Israel   (09.11.10)
makes ethnic cleansing sound official.
14. #3 - we've got a ton in Judea, Samaria
William ,   Israel   (09.11.10)
An Israeli researcher found many families who were Jews before the Arab invasion and were forced to convert. They admitted they were afraid to consider conversion back because it did bring a death sentence to the entire clan. Other clans referred to them as "Jews" and weren't nice about it.
15. can you enlighten us
sohaib ,   Edinburgh Scotland   (09.11.10)
how did you get to the conclusion that the coran is satanic, or are you of those that talk out of ignorance in a confort zone blogs such as this one where every one agrees with the hatred you hold towards Muslims. if Algeria is taking out the star of David away it is their business they dont want a symbole of an opressor in their holy book is this not sensible?
16. Bani Israil changed to Al-Isra
Ismail Suleiman   (09.11.10)
Is the next thing that they will do is remove Quran references to the Children of Israel "Bani Israil" and the prophet Yacoub (PBUH) also referred to as "Israil" in the Quran? Many English translations of the Quran also have changed the name of the chapter "Children of Israel" to "The Night Journey". "Bani Israil" in Arabic is now "Al-Isra" in Arabic for the 17th chapter of the Quran.
17. sohaib # 15
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (09.11.10)
You have it backwards. Your holy book is a symbol of oppression, not the star of David.
18. Thanks Be
BH Obama ,   The Crescent House   (09.12.10)
I was afraid this would be another attack on Islam and I would have to speak out. But since it is an attack against the Hebraics, I can stay out of it.
19. Arab States= Racism & intolerance class 101.
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.12.10)
20. Quran is an altered version of Torah.No holy stars on unholy
books   (09.12.10)
21. Today's Oxymoron - Algerian Ethics
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (09.12.10)
According to the Algerian government, the symbol on the cover "is not in keeping with the general ethics of the state." What ethics?
22. :: Soahib - #15, stay backward, no need to be enlightened
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (09.12.10)
Backwardness suits you better.
23. 15, you see sohaib
David ,   New England   (09.12.10)
It says that Yeshua is not the Son of God and was not Resurrected. Paul says in the Christian Bible that if he or an angel preaches a different gospel then they are to be accursed.
24. They finally get a kosher kooran and they throw it away.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.12.10)
25. William, I bet you have...
Persian CAT   (09.12.10)
read neither the Torah nor the Koran. Otherwise you would be regurgitating such sewage.
26. Terry, what are you going to do about...
Persian CAT   (09.12.10)
your "religious symbols" on illegal cluster bombs?!
27. Will they burn them?!?!
Robby ,   San Jose, USA   (09.12.10)
28. STAR OF DAVID OR SULEIMAN'S SEAL ?
Michel Slonimski ,   Paris, France   (09.12.10)
A telling story indeed ! What Arab Muslims in Algeria and other places seem to have entirely forgotten is that the so-called "Star of David" was a Muslim symbol, known as "Suleiman's Seal", until very recently. It was even the national symbol of Morocco until 1956 and as such was displayed on the royal Moroccan banner. Indeed, it fell in disuse only when the Jews, in desperate search of symbol of their own to oppose to the Christian cross, picked it up in the 19th century, and when the Zionist movement turned it into a national symbol. It is quite a common thing for antisemites to renounce their heritage when it is "tainted" by some association with the Jews. Incredibly, Hitler banned Germany's national script - the Gothic script - in 1941 because he believed it looked to much like the medieval Hebrew Rashi script.
29. why was the magen david on the koran in the first place
zionist forever   (09.12.10)
The Magen David is not actually a historical holy symbol for jews but it has been adopted as one by diaspora jews over the last couple of hundred years. I don't know though what it has to do with muslims and why the thing should have ever been put on. Is this some attempt to convert jews to islam to put what are considered jewish symbols on the koran? Banning the books and giving money back was the right decision.
30. #25 - oh, poor sad you. Indeed I have read them
William ,   Israel   (09.12.10)
and the Bible as well. I laugh every time some Muslim or rabid Anti-semite tries to quote the Torah and ends up referring to the Talmud instead. Or when they cite some obscure text and insists it drives the entire Jewish mentality. One thing does ring true, despite violence written in the holy books of all three of these religions, only Muslims enact it today and justify it through the Koran. They hold it up each time, open pages, when they cry for blood or make their last-video before committing yet another war crime. There are many who counter those Muslims who say Islam inspires peace that the Koran is the absolute word of Allah and the call for violence inside MUST be adhered to.
Next talkbacks
Back to article