News
Palestinians selling land to Israelis face death
Associated Press
Published: 20.09.10, 15:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Talk about depraved and barbaric
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.20.10)
Sale of land to Jews is a capital crime? Puts a whole new meaning to the word "primitive."
2. This law passed in 1997
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (09.20.10)
"The Palestinian Authority's justice minister, Freih Abu Meddein, announced in early May 1997 that Palestinians who sell land to Jews will face the death penalty" Agence France Presse, May 5, 1997. The fact was Arabs began to cash out. The Jewish settlers were offering 2-3 times the value of the land, so many Arabs began to sell their property to Jewish people. So in East Jerusalem and the West Bank land began to sell at a alarming rate. It scared the PLO. So they passed a law with the death penalty. Nothing like freedom and private property rights is there? BTW, if there is a peace treaty do the Jewish people get their money back? So in the in the New state of Palestine we can assume private property owners really will not have property rights, will they? Since they don't even have that now in the PA controlled areas. With the PA allowing vigilante killings, to people they consider to be collaborators or traitors, just for selling their land to who they want? Did you notice this quote in the article: "In the past there have been vigilante killings of Palestinians suspected of selling land." "Of Palestinians suspected", Wow, just suspected. Interesting legal system. I guess if you have an old enemy accuse him of selling land to Jewish people, and the good towns folk, will kill the "suspected" Palestinian for you. It should a wonderful Nation the Palestinians set up. No wonder why the refugees don't want to go there.
3. RACIST LAW like the no Jews allowed to build law! Arabs buy
Jae ,   Lynn US   (09.20.10)
lad and build in Israel, no death penalty. So you see who is the real violent racist enemy and who is defending themselves against the political mumo jumbo new identity called palestinians, who never objected to Jordans rule before 1967 and didnt call themselves palestinians en masse, they were just arabs. Its BS and they can change jordan back to the palestine mandate and have palestinian nationality, however non historical , there.
4. no.2
hebrew prophet ,   israel   (09.20.10)
Hi Mark sholud be rather interesting knowing where Abbas currently resides and how he actually acquired his present property ,maybe someone can enlighten us on this subject ?
5. Jews jailed for selling land to Arabs
Daniel ,   TA   (09.20.10)
Imagine the world outcry and horror if that had been the headline. As it is, the world will see this as a "valiant fight against oppression." It does not matter that Jews were willing to pay 3 times the value for the land. If Israel stops building in Judea and Sumeria it is foolish.
6. Free The Palestinians ...
Christy ,   Boston, US   (09.20.10)
from the PA and from Hamas.
7. Bogus headline
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.20.10)
The truth is that it is a crime to sell to Jews regardless of nationality. Muslims and Christians Israelis face no such penalty.
8. I think it can be exploited.
leo ,   usa   (09.20.10)
People who want to sell can contact Israeli hotline for help and ...
9. i have some land that i wanna sell to jews near nablus
(09.20.10)
anyone interested ???? this is serious!!!
10. @ Ghristy Boston
Daniel ,   TA   (09.20.10)
Why? You reap what you sew. Those Arabs have only planted hatred and a total unwillingness to take responsibility for their own actions for over 100 years, Why would they ever be free of that until they change?
11. Land laws
Elmer ,   USA   (09.20.10)
I just did a very quick check - It appears that it is illegal, under Palestinian law, for a Palestinian to sell land to *any* foreigner. The penalty is life imprisonment. However, if a Palestinian sells land to someone from an "occupation" entity (meaning *any* Israeli), the penalty is death. (Both penalties are beyond the pale.) In Israel, it is legal to sell private land to a foreigner. This amounts to about 7% of Israel. It is illegal to sell land in the rest Israel to a foreigner (with some minor exceptions). I will guess that the penalties are very light. Again, that was just a quick check. I welcome any corrections.
12. It is About Sovereignty and the Settlements
Mark of Lewiston ,   Lewiston USA   (09.20.10)
Any land sale that could conceivable prompt an Israeli claim of sovereignty is what is banned. Negotiate a deal where no sale of land will change any sovereignty and that recognizes that Palestine's sovereignty is absolute within the borders of Palestine and the law goes away.If Israelis tried to extend Israeli sovereignty to properties owned by Israelis in Florida or New York, the US would have similar ban. Can Saudis or Jordanians buy land in Galilee and claim it as Saudi or Jordanian Territory?
13. worse on the Jewish side
observer   (09.20.10)
they can NOT even Consider selling Jewish land.
14. prove your sources #13
better observer   (09.20.10)
but there is no need to prove that you are insane, it is too obvious to any normal person
15. PA leaders are tyrants
Brod ,   USA   (09.20.10)
Executing people for selling their land should not be tolerated by the Free World. Israel should help the people rise against and topple such tyrannical leaders.
16. kinda shows how one sided they are !
Galut ,   Selah   (09.20.10)
and any negotiations will face the same one sidedness... they probably celibrate if israel sells land to them....
17. bitter observer #14, are you Jew?
observer   (09.21.10)
The exact geographical definition of the term 'Land of Israel' is much disputed in the Talmud and the talmudic literature, and the debate has continued in modern times between the various shades of zionist opinion. According to the maximalist view, the Land of Israel includes (in addition to Palestine itself) not only the whole of Sinai, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon, but also considerable parts of Turkey. The Halakhah forbids Jews to sell immovable property - fields and houses - in the Land of Israel to Gentiles. In Syria, the sale of houses (but not of fields) is permitted. Leasing a house in the Land of Israel to a Gentile is permitted under two conditions. First, that the house shall not be used for habitation but for other purposes, such as storage. Second, that three or more adjoining houses shall not be so leased. These and several other rules are explained as follows: ... 'so that you shall not allow them to camp on the ground, for if they do not possess land, their sojourn there will be temporary.' Even temporary Gentile presence may only be tolerated 'when the Jews are in exile, or when the Gentiles are more powerful than the Jews,' but when the Jews are more powerful than the Gentiles we are forbidden to let an idolator among us; even a temporary resident or itinerant trader shall not be allowed to pass through our land unless he accepts the seven Noahide precepts, for it is written: 'they shall not dwell in thy land'. Influential rabbis, identify the Palestinians (or even all Arabs) with those ancient nations i.e. Amalekites, so that commands like 'thou shalt save alive nothing that breatheth' acquire a topical meaning. after all, It is forbidden to defraud a Jew by selling or buying at an unreasonable price. However, 'Fraud does not apply to Gentiles, for it is written: "Do not defraud each man his brother".
18. Observer , 17 . Those are Torah laws
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (09.21.10)
Not Today Israel's ones , while the PA laws are for TODAY .
Back to article