Opinion
What about Jewish farmers?
Orit Struck
Published: 06.10.10, 10:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
31. Sarah B ?
Matt   (10.07.10)
"Also -- please learn how to spell. You are embarrassing yourself (although you are not quite intelligent enough to realize it). " What did I not spell correctly ?
32. #27 Rivkah- China will invade Norway
bob ,   NZ   (10.07.10)
If you study the ELS Torah codes more carefully you'll see that the Australian government under Mrs Gillard warned China that should China invade Australia the Australian government will give every Australian citizen his/her gun back. The Chinese therefore decide to invade Norway instead
33. to no. 29 - I was expecting someone noone like ...
Avi ,   Tel Aviv   (10.07.10)
you to comment. I can feel the sickness you and your kind suffers!!
34. :: Sarah BS - #18 - What rubbish!
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (10.07.10)
Don’t pretend you know the first thing about pruning olive trees! 1) Olive trees (like most fruit trees) are pruned in the Spring, any gardener will tell you that. 2) The vast reports of settlers cutting down trees happen in the summer and autumn. 3) Every news report and investigation conducted by Yesh Din or International Orgs rubbish your lame claims. For example this news item: http://tiny.cc/cdqqn tell me Sarah BS how on earth can illegal Israeli settlers uprooting 300 olive trees belonging to Palestinians and replanting them at their illegal outpost be a ‘Palestinian organize a media event’? Your entire post is full of BS and you cannot back up any of your so-called claims with any established facts.
35. #28
Kibbutznik   (10.07.10)
Do you have a point? Are you attempting to refute anything, do you disagree or are you just an angry individual? There was a time when manners meant something and impoliteness in debate was the mark of a weak position.
36. setelments are not farmes
hala ,   jenin   (10.07.10)
it is building houses near villeges on there farms but here in west bank all the villeges are araby and work in culture have farms olive trees and grapes farms so wher is the jewish farmers in west bank ????
37. 34 - she is a looney not worth the aggrevation.
sam   (10.07.10)
38. Farmers
Eugene Graczyk ,   Sausalito, CA USA   (10.11.10)
I respect the need to protect ALL farmers from harrassment and harm. That includes Jewish farmers. The issue is far more complicated, however. For settlers to regularly raid Palestinian groves, taking the annual harvest and harming trees is simply wrong and illegal by any definition. There should be no argument that this must be stopped and prosecuted. If you have hard evidence, prosecute. If you are only talking about confiscated lands that are protested by former owners, that is another matter. If anyone malicisously harms another citizedn, regardless of faith or party, they should face immediate and effective justice.
39. if not now .... when?
yoheved ,   north miami beach, f   (03.08.11)
"if I am not for myself .... who will be for me?" ..... "and if not now ..... when?" ..... everyone has a G-d given right to defend themselves ... especially Jews on their own land .... if the police won't defend Jewish farmers ... they need to defend themselves ... no shame about it ...
Previous talkbacks
Back to article