News
Dogs to be used in next flotilla raid
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 07.10.10, 17:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
54 Talkbacks for this article
31. num 24
Libneniyyeh ,   Canada   (10.07.10)
How astute and well-informed you are! The dog, fyi, is mentioned in the Koran as one of the noble companions of the People of the Cave - always there to guard them as a loyal companion. Trust me, an honest Muslim fears no one but his Creator.
32. Agree, but......
David ,   Raanana   (10.07.10)
Pit Bulls pleaseee!!! :-)
33. Matt 26
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (10.07.10)
No, the so called peace activists should act peacefully or stay home. If they bring guns then they aren't peace activists and they themselves should be shot. If these morons would respect the legal blockade then the dogs could stay home.
34. Arms race: the ships will bring cats for the dogs to chase
Schreiber   (10.07.10)
Or juicy steaks. Or cute female poodles.
35. How does one say "element of surprise" in Hebrew
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (10.07.10)
I agree with Matt in LA. Laying out the IDF playbook for all to see undermines the advantage one gets from the element of surprise. Looking back on the Mavi Marmara, I don't know how they might have landed the dogs. Oketz dogs are smart and well trained, but they don't know how to repel. And I have no doubt the savages they encountered on the deck would have beat them with the steel pipes they'd cut from the railing. There are any number of non-lethal tools that might serve better using ultrasonic sound, microwaves, etc. But for heaven's sake, shut up about them!
36. I agree with #10, but you have to give the gov't credit
Schreiber   (10.07.10)
They are CONSISTENTLY DUMB. It's not like they are smart sometimes and dumb at other times. They are serial blunderers. There are 21st century methods of stopping and disabling ships. But the top brass, or most likely, the Defense Ministry, has no idea. My own personal theory is that there is a method to all this madness and stupidity: the constant mistakes and retreats during conflicts, the porous border, the whole mess.
37. Better idea!
Naor ,   USA   (10.07.10)
How about we send down Barak to raid these flotillas. Then we can keep the important soldiers and dogs safe. In the mean time, the rest of the IDF can mine the Gaza Coast.
38. Comment to #35 regarding "shutting up"
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (10.07.10)
I do see your point, but I think you are missing the point. The whole idea is to make it known that dogs are to be used, that is part of the beauty of this approach. It is as I've written already a very clever tactic.
39. Better to use wolves
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (10.07.10)
40. so DOGS are more effective than "IDF" soldiers!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Salma ,   Palestine   (10.07.10)
time to dismantle your army.
41. to salma- no dogs are more
Barney ,   USA   (10.07.10)
effective than pali terrorist sympathizers. idf could handle without ever leaving land if they weren't so wrongly worried about world opinion. hard to take on the enemy with both hands tied behind your back but even at that the idf has kicked ass
42. Re 26
Andrew Brehm   (10.07.10)
Yes, and the world will see again that "peace activists" are armed and want to kill.
43. Yes . Shoot he Dogs.
Matt   (10.07.10)
If wild dogs are released on an international vessel in international waters then the law would stipulate for them to be shot immediately. If it is the known and stated intention of certain parties to release these dogs then in fact it gives a legal and justifiable premise for marksmen to go onto the ship. Its a stupid idea to release dogs on a civilian vessel.
44. stupid to release dogs
sleepless   (10.08.10)
on a civilian vessel, wise to release trained smart dogs on a vessel full of terrorists and blood thirst murderers. What kind of peace loving civilians would kill animals and shoot them? Why would they have guns?
45. stupid question.
Matt   (10.08.10)
The guns would be to shoo the dogs. It would be the only legitimate reason to bring guns on. IDF wants to give them a right to carry guns. Clowns!
46. #43 Don't you get it. The dogs sham is a hoax
Eran ,   Singapore   (10.08.10)
IDF will use gorillas and Shwarma nextthis time. But keep the surprise. Don't tell nobody.
47. unbelieveable- another PR disaster
bob ,   NZ   (10.08.10)
Dog lovers will be outraged and will blame Israel regardless of what the activists do to the dogs. I certainly would. I'm already pissed off at the mentality of people who would suggest this idea Activist lovers will be outraged if a dog bites or mauls an activist I couldn't give a sh*t myself but others might Gruesome photos of snarling dogs and terrified activists might flood the media and make Israel look bad even if nobody gets hurt. What a bunch of idiots
48. German shepards
Cliff ,   USA   (10.08.10)
Of all the breeds in the world, the dog in the pic has to be a German shepard?
49. so DOGS are more effective than IDF soldiers !!!!!!!
JUDAH THE LION   (10.08.10)
Of course you and your brothers & sisters would love the IDF to be dismantle.The IDF using dogs to protect themselves
50. Dogs
Marilyn ,   USA   (10.09.10)
If you want to stop someone, the first thing you do is step in front of them. In this case block the boat with other boats. In the case of when dogs attack it is the human reaction to shot them. So I'm not sure what the point of having dogs on board would be, besides for Israel to get in trouble for crimes against animals.
51. Dogs to be used in next flotilla raid
Rachel Zats ,   Ashkelon, Israel   (10.09.10)
I completely disagree with this idea because as I remember the activists were armed with guns, even an attack dog can be stopped by a bullit and what a waste of training for these dogs that are more useful in other situations, the IDF will be sending them to a dog blood bath and then think of the media response to that. If you thought it was bad first time around, the world media will have a frenzy with this.
52. Attack Dogs?
Eric ,   Singapore   (10.10.10)
Attack dogs now? Commandos storming ships with automatic weapons not enough to take down vessels filled with civilians? Or tasering peace activists repeatedly in the heart. How about using torpedos from submarines? Stay classy, Israel. Paranoia seems to be widespread in Israel.
53. peace activists
Marilyn ,   USA   (10.10.10)
The people in the last boat did not make a declaration that they were partial pacifists or full pacifists. For me, peace means a commitment to not having wars. This is just one step of process to evaluate if a person gets the right to be called a peace activist. Also need to evaluate an overall statement of intent and beliefs and also perhaps personal references and a police report for each person. (The idea of peace is important, and cannot let the people believing in it down). If they pass all this then they get the credentials and gain the right to be called peace activists.
54. irony
m ,   usa   (10.12.10)
does no one find it ironic at all that they're using german shepherds?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article