News
Helen Thomas on being anti-Semitic: 'Baloney!'
Associated Press
Published: 12.10.10, 18:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
80 Talkbacks for this article
1. Thomas should have been thrown out ...
Don Rosenberg ,   Palatine USA   (10.12.10)
years ago. She has always been anti-Israel and has shown it many times. Israel can't be criticized? complete BS. Israel is always criticized and held to a different standard. She's an idiot and should go live in iran with her Bro's.
2. you ppl can't handle the truth. she is right
John ,   NY   (10.12.10)
3. Hellen Thomas criticizing "Israel" existence is antisemitic
David P. ,   Capitola, CA   (10.12.10)
what do you mean can't survive? in the USA you're free to criticize whomever, whatever, whenever, it's this freedom which is the key to our survival
4. She's in luck it is almost Halloween
Ilan ,   Ariel   (10.12.10)
She could temp as an ugly old hag.
5. Disingenuous Thomas
Wade ,   NYC US   (10.12.10)
says that Jews do not deserve their own country, but don't call her antisemitic. Thomas promotes the lie that Jews stole land, and she ignores Jewish land ownership and Jewish spiritual attachment to the Land of Israel. She ignores that millions of Jews were born in Israel, when she calls for deportation- but don't call her antisemitic!
6. baloney
blash ,   Jerusalem   (10.12.10)
She thinks Jews need to go home to their parents' mass graves? LOL maybe she should go home to Lebanon, I hear there hasn't been a civil war there in a LONG time... /snark
7. Helen is simply ignorant and knows almost nothing...
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (10.12.10)
...about Israeli demographics. She obviously has no idea that over a million Israelis originate from Morocco alone. And she wants to send them "back" to Poland and Germany? I think her friends are simply too scared to sit down and try to educate her - which leaves her indeed looking like an ignorant racist. Sad.
8. She truly is "baloney"
Christopher ,   Boston, MASS   (10.12.10)
She has been criticizing Jews for most of her career, much of it front row center at the WH press conferences. But even an overt Antisemite like Thomas knows there are limits to what any self-respecting public will accept. And calling for Jews to go back to Hitler's ovens went over the line.
9. Who's next? Scott Spears?
Moise   (10.12.10)
10. Variation on a Nursery Rhyme
Chatich   (10.12.10)
There was an old woman who looked like a shoe She had so much hatred, she knew not what to do When someone asked "Helen, what about Israel"? She said "those dirty Jews, let them all burn in hell" Now, suddenly, ol' leatherface has no more job. "Another victim of those zionist yobs!" But fret not do you need to, you crusty old hag. Surely jazeera will hire you for their rag. And then you'll be able to speak as you please. As all will subscribe to your verbal disease. For just as you wish it, you weathered old prune, A new audience to your hatred surely will swoon. And all will be right with your world once again, When you're employed to spit venom at Jews with your pen. So tell us, dear helen, who then will you blame, When the only path left for you goes straight down to the flames? ps. say hi to saddam and yasser when you see them, biatch!
11. Helen Thomas. Bigot?
Michael F ,   New York USA   (10.12.10)
Next thing we'll hear is "Some of my best friends are Jews." Her bigotedness was known to the press pool and now we all know about it.
12. WELL AT LEAST THOMAS STILL HAS
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (10.12.10)
Her looks .
13. Ms. Thomas...
The White Shadow   (10.12.10)
... you are a liar and a shill.
14. Thomas should have maintained her "low profile"
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (10.12.10)
I, for one, thought we'd seen the last of the old crow. These comments only remind us why she had to go. The notion that one can't criticize Israel in the US and survive is sheer nonsense. Remember James "F*** the Jews" Baker? How about Lugar and Hamilton? Jimmy Carter, Walt and Miersheimer have made millions off their criticism of Israel. I believe it was Tony Snow, once White House press secretary who, in response to one of Thomas' diatribes (disguised as a question) thanked her for the Hizbullah perspective.
15. Helen Thomas is a victim of her own stupidity and ignorance
Alexander ,   NJ, USA   (10.12.10)
For a lady who's greatest accomplishment is sitting on her ass in the White House press room longer than anyone else would care to imagine I have no sympathy for her ignoramus remarks "Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine." She has simply bought into the Antisemitic rhetoric the Arabs have unleashed in the global arena the same way the Nazi's did before they began their final solution. If this bigot doesn't understand the simple fact that the Jews are as native to Israel/Palestine as the Native Americans are to USA/America then it's time for Helen Thomas to get the hell out of America and go back to Lebanon. Asinine journalist such as herself are all too abundant in the media today, it is no wonder the media is against Israel when people like her are in the driver seat.
16. Forever synical and contrite.
JHL ,   USA   (10.12.10)
this halloween mask is still the most anti-jewish former media pig ever known.She has never had anything decent to say about Isreal or American policy in the region.For too many years we had to sit by and witness her snide and stilted comments aimed at our executive officers.Good riddance filthy hag.
17. 'I want to be remembered for integrity'
split ,   USA   (10.12.10)
You're and you'll, Helen ,...
18. Hele Thomas
Raphael Grynpas ,   Brussels - Belgium   (10.12.10)
Dear Sir, I find chocking that you relay the defense of an anti-Semite. If she does not realize the pettiness of her say, it doesn't change the fact that they are as petty as any antisemitic outburst. Sincerely yours, Dr. R. Grynpas.
19. Jews to gas chambers?
Golan ,   Modiin   (10.12.10)
is not anti-Semitic? Calling for Jews to not be in the position to defend themselves (def. of Zionism's every group) is anti-Semitic!
20. Thomas
Aryeh ,   Arad,Israel   (10.12.10)
"Hag"
21. Helen Thomas
Zionist ,   Israel   (10.12.10)
My problem is not with you 'criticizing' Israel. No one is perfect. My problem is that you were taking away our right for the country, who the hell are you to do that? Go back to Lebanon, then speak of us leaving Israel. I was born in Israel and so were my Parents. as for my GrandParents, their families' dust is still in Poland, and we will never go back. Thanks.
22. @4 Nothing against hags
David ,   Zichron Yaacov   (10.12.10)
She is not a hag, she is a cackler.
23. :: John - #2
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (10.12.10)
You don't seem to be able to handle the truth that she is an Antisemite and wrong. Like her you come up with fantastic tale that have no basis in reality or truth.
24. Helen Thomas
Henry Federman ,   Tillson USA   (10.12.10)
Helen Thomas on not beeing antisemitic,if it quack like a duck,walk like a duck,IT'S A DUCK!
25. Helen Thomas IS anti-Semitic!
manicdrummer ,   Madison, WI, USA   (10.12.10)
Why does she believe Jews should move back to Poland and Germany? Israel is Jews' ancient homeland. Now that they have it back, she wants them to give it up? No way!
26. Appologize to God
Charles ,   Western Wall   (10.12.10)
Hadrian changed the name of Judea to Palestine after the Philestines to mock the Jewish people. Palestinians should get out of Israel if anything. They can live there if they recognize it as homeland of the Jewish people.
27. Thomas ignorant
Dr Jack ,   Canada   (10.12.10)
Helen Thomas is not only an old anti-Semite, but also an IGNORANT!! At the time her parents moved to the USA, there was NO Lebanon, only the Turkish empire!! Should she return there??
28. Liberal media is full of unexposed Helen Thomases.
Chaim ,   Israel   (10.12.10)
Thomas' claim her statements aren't anti-Semitic is ludicrous. She seeks to deny Jews our Homeland soley because we are Jews. That is the very crux of racism. There is absolutely no doubt that the liberal media is full of unexposed Helen Thomases. She is a typical media liberal. In other words, a very thinly disguised hateful racist hypocrite.
29. bitter old witch
(10.12.10)
how can she call for a key US ally to be effectively dissolved as a nation and expect to maintain a job in the whitehouse. She was basically saying Israel should not exist.
30. Just the opposite
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (10.12.10)
Israel is the most criticized country on the planet. People do it all the time and what happens - absolutely nothing. Now if you criticize the Arabs you will get terrorism and rioting in the streets. Stupid racist old hag.
Next talkbacks
Back to article