News
US: Resumption of Jerusalem construction disappointing
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 15.10.10, 20:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ooooh. Who cares ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.15.10)
what the "king" of an invented kingdom thinks? He's about to get a boatload of repatriated Jordanian citizens, and would thus be well advised to worry about building in "Jordan" to accommodate them, and forget about what the sovereign State of Israel does with respect to its exercise of eminent domain.
2. :: Arabs should stop building in the Jewish land of Amman
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (10.15.10)
Arabs occupy and illegally control 99.8% of the Middle East and much of it is land stolen from Jews.
3. This is disappointing?
(10.15.10)
Wait until November 2, Mr. President. That will be disappointing.
4. jordan decide for his own housing plan...
Anna M Sedda ,   Italy   (10.15.10)
and the fact that his father pass to him a false king seat(people did not vote for him but he was imposed to the people..) does not mean he can decide in someonelse home what to do...
5. There is a State, Its Called Jordan
Dav Lev ,   Burbank.CAUSA   (10.15.10)
If I recall, the Kings father was pleaded to not to attack Israel in 1967. He, to be unified with Egypt/Syria, didn't listen, and lost the W. Bk and East Jerusalem ( which had been made Judenrein after 1948 and held illegally). Jordan attacked in 48, 67 ( remember the shootings of those religious girls by a Jordanian soldier). What right does the King have to tell Israel anythng? Israel should go on the offensive: Jordan was created illegally out of Jewish territory. and should be the home of the Mandate Arab Muslims. To Israel: these 250 units are the tip of the iceberg. next its all of Jerusalem, right of return, 49 borders, treaties with Iran..and Rev Guards stationed in the Strip.Wake up, call their bluff, and call up 200,000 reservists for good measure. Let them die for their imaginery state.They already have one, its called Jordan.
6. Mr OBAMA
....DACON9   (10.15.10)
IT AINT YOUR LAND AND IT AINT THE ARABS WHO CALL THEMSELVES PALISITINIAN. ITS JEWISH LAND DECREED BY THE RULING BODIES IN 1947/48 AND DECREED BY YOUR BIBLE AND ALL OF THE OETHERS BIBLE ..DECREED BY THE ONE GD OF ALL THE BIBLES AND MANKIND IT IS JEWISH LAND
7. USA!, cut off military aid to Israel ...
observer   (10.15.10)
until a time that Israel was prepared to negotiate in good faith with Palestinians on the basis of human rights, international law, and UN resolutions."
8. If Jordan is relinquishing their claim, then not disputed
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & New York   (10.15.10)
If Jordan is relinquishing their claim, then it is no longer disputed territory, Thus the land is Israels, as the dispute was between Israel and Jordan according to the Israel / Jordan peace treaty.
9. Well, at least they're not condemning it.
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (10.15.10)
I suppose it's progress if the US only finds Jews building in the Jewish capital to be "disappointing" rather than meriting harsh condemnation. Are they reconsidering their attitudes toward Israel (the Palestinians are giving the US nothing to work with), or are they just holding their fire until the elections (18 days from now)?
10. Us resumption
jeremy ,   hula valley kibbutz   (10.15.10)
Don't care what the white house or State Dept thinks or feels. Foggy bottom is just that and so is the Obama Presidency. May they both go away soonest
11. lIKUD ARE AT THE END OF THE ROPE
palestine dove ,   afula   (10.15.10)
Palestine state is coming soon with 67 border with east juresalem as its capital the whole world will recoginze it and the peace train shall roll Day dreamers extermist well take a trip into political coma just like the other right wingers who never learn how to fly
12. The American Admin. is disappointing!!!!!!!!
State dept is arab ,   appeasers   (10.15.10)
13. Ho Hum Ho Hum
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (10.15.10)
Let's look at facts. 1. Israel observed a 10 month building stop. 2. Israel begged the Palestinians to start negotiations 3. Obama may or may not asked that they start negotiations. 4, Right before the freeze is scheduled to end the Palestinians decided to "negotiate" 5. The Palestinian negotiations include absolute denial of Israel as a Jewish State 6. The Palestinian State would be defined as Arab and Moslem 7. The Palestinian State would be Judernrein 8. Israel would be expected to keep her Arab citizens. Israel after 10 months authorizes building in Jerusalem and buildings authorized prior to the freeze have construction resumptions. Israel is considered intransigent !!! Give me a break. Anyone who really thinks that the Palestinians didn't plan this in advance--I have a bridge to sell you. The only surprise is that Netanyahu appears, to be holding strong!!
14. LOL! Jordanians crying about "occupied Palestine"
Darren ,   Oakland, CA   (10.15.10)
If the Jordanians were so interested in a free "Palestine", they would have left the West Bank in 1948 and set up a Palestinian state along the '67 borders. This, of course, flies in the face of almost 100 years of treaties, international law and the reality that Jordan is itself the de-facto Palestinian state by means of sheer demographics. Even Crown Prince Hussain is half-Palestinian! Then again, what exactly is the difference between a Palestinian and a Jordanian?
15. "Teleprompter" Obama doesn't get it - no more fake "talks"
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (10.15.10)
Obama's little secret is out - The PLO has been exposed as a fake "peace partner" by its announcement that it won't recognize Jewish Israel, won't compromise on its idiotic "right of return" to Israel, won't compromize on refugees, won't compromise on borders or consider land swaps. Obama and Clinton have been fraudulantly claiming "apartment construction" is the obstacle, when the actual obstacle is PA and Abbas refusal to negotiate anything, just insist on all their maximum demands. Obama has been dishonestly squeezing concessions and "gestures" from israel and getting nothing in return at all. Why would Israel extend its "freeze" gesture to enhance negotiations when it stands receive ZERO from the negoitiations?? America can not afford to have a liar and four-flusher in the White House, he has completely discredited American diplomacy - who will ever trust him again. Obama, caught, as a deer-in-the-headlights by the exposure of his lie - proof that Abbas NEVER accepted his "2-states-for-2-peoples" policy - is reduced to mechanically droning on about apartment construction, as if anybody cares what he says. This kind of corrupt White House conduct is exactly what the impeachment process was designed for.
16. Palestine will be Free
Palestinian   (10.15.10)
1- UN and hopefully someone like Belfour for some sort of declaration 2- Palestinians around the world any where and every where take care of business to let the whole world know that Palestine will be Free.
17. ONE CAN PLEASE
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (10.15.10)
One can please all of the people all of the time ,and some of the people some of the time but one cannot please none of the people some of the time...
18. 2 states: Israel & Jordan
Sandy   (10.15.10)
Jordan is 80% of mandated Palestine, and Israel (from river to sea, is the other 20%. The San Remo conference recognised the international, legal right of Jewish settlement from river to sea. Jordan can "continue supporting the Palestinians" by conferring Jordanian citisenship on them. They can continue to live where they are, as foreign residents of Israel, and get on with building a constructive economy and futrue for the region...
19. US disappointed: How About Abbas, No Jewish Israel for Him
izzie irgun ,   zion   (10.15.10)
Last week i wrote that obama might be getting it .. but today we are back to what a jer \k he is. The issue isn't 240 permits to build, its that Abbas and every other arab refuse to recongnize Israel. Why should we even talk to them unless they meet the basic requirement for peace ... recognizing the historical right of Jews to a homeland called Israel. As for going to the UN, what a waste, no one is sending troops to change reality so getting a country in name only will do nothing for them except make them look weaker and like bigger fools. I keep asking, where is the arab mandella ... 100 years of apartheid and that man took over without 1 bullet. Abbas is just too stupid to be the man that mandella, ghandi and others were. And that is why the palestinians are doomed to go no where and accomplish nothing.
20. Obama hates Israel,hates Western Civilization
RayS ,   USA   (10.15.10)
Obama ,does everything he can to ubdermine all things that stand in the way of Muslim hegomony. No surprise. His life history demonstrates this. He not only hates Israel, he hates the United States, Great Britain, and Western Democracies in general. The American people are realizing what they have for a President and it will show in the November ekections. Bibi should politely pay no attention to him of his State Dept hacks.
21. Build, Build, Build
Brod ,   USA   (10.15.10)
Israel should continue building and building. It is your land-Israel's liberated historic homeland of Judea and Samaria-Land of Israel.
22. TO #2 Matty Groves
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (10.15.10)
so let me get this straight: any douche bag like yourself (or like the millions of russian christians who immigrated to palestine) who converts to Judaism would have the right to claim all the lands of the middle east as his? but what if a jewish douche bag who owns a stolen land in tel aviv decides to convert to another religion, does the property remains his? your logic gushes with purple crap.
23. Hallelujah for all of the new construction!!!
Ken Quinn ,   Amsterdam   (10.15.10)
24. Leaders of Israel,thanks for your choice...
Mikhael ,   Msa,Kenya   (10.15.10)
Jerusalem the ancient and modern capital of Israel is a fact.Arab day dreamers and their false friends will have to swallow that bitter pill.NO.to Arab state in Israel,they have enough in North Africa and most of middle east.The Arabs don't view others as worthy to exist.But Israel is the small axe ready to cut the big trees to size
25. israel is a temporary border for Zionst
syria eagle ,   homs   (10.15.10)
the right borders will be an enclave between baja california and arizon bordes time to relocate becuase you driving ahmedinajad mad you wouldn't like him when he is mad he gave an offer to leave now in peac or leave later in pieces
26. Relax and enjoy the drama
David Ben-Sun ,   Granite falls, USA   (10.15.10)
These two bands of domesticated primates have been throwing feces at each other for thousands of years now, and they won't stop until the last one is dead. So just let them go. They'll wipe each other out, and the sane non-theists can have our planet back.
27.  Obama is soooo dense! The talks are going nowhere!
Harry Wright ,   UK   (10.15.10)
So why bother about Israelis building in their land! Let him bother about Abbas refusing to recognise Israel as a Jewish state. That is the obstacle. Houses can be an item of negotiations. Recognition of each other by BOTH sides is the only CORE issue. Obama must get to the core for any progress to be made. This man is a dunce or what!
28. To: No. 26
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.15.10)
Aren't you the rude and uninformed one. The fact of the matter is that the Jews would not harm a single hair on the head of a single "Palestinian," if they would only leave us alone. Alas, the "Palestinians" are violent terrorists; would you prefer that the Jews allow themselves to be herded into gas chambers again rather than defend themselves? That's not going to happen; if the right of Jews to defend themselves in their homeland offends genetically defective knuckle-dragging anti-Semites such as yourself, perhaps you should contemplate suicide.
29. observer's post
Anonymous   (10.15.10)
ever stop to think unilateral peace is impossible?
30. give peace a chance
Mun ,   san rafael, usa   (10.15.10)
I am palestinian american, under the age of 30, with a degree from u.c. berkeley. i want peace. im tired of arguing about this conflict. i just want to say that currently, nearly 70% of democrats in the u.s. want a palestinian state. Do israeli's not understand this? Do you understand that my generation, the new generation of americans see each other with rarely a hint of racism when it comes to real issues? Obama is just the start of the new democrats.do not test the ire of my generation. i see democrats in power for at least 70% of the time for the next 50 years. We are the only superpower left. If americans want a palestinan state, we will make it happen. I do not hate jewish people, i consider them to be brothers and relatives. We all come from the same region and forefather abraham. I respect the right of the people of issac to have their own nation. Regardless of how much land you guys end up with, ultimately you have to live beside arabs for eternity. eventually you have to make peace. As regards to my own people, you have to start adopting and believing in the parts of the koran that speak highly of jews and christians. YES there are parts where it says jews and christians will ascend to heaven with muslims if they believe in god and a final judgement. palestinians, make peace! the rest of the world is progressing technologically and advancing into space, and all were doing is fighting over dirt. The koran says the whole world is his mesjad (mosque). Make peace. enough!
Next talkbacks
Back to article