News
Kids run over by settler leader questioned
Ynet reporters
Published: 17.10.10, 13:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. Gregg
IZL   (10.17.10)
Yet, you still live in Haifa... Israel can't exactly do without an army. Why do you bother to live in this uncivilized country? I bet that civilized country of yours never had war. Certainly they taught you politics in that civilized place of yours? F was your grade?
32. Matty
IZL   (10.17.10)
Well, we should instead teach our children to give flowers to the Palestinians as they throw stones at us... An eye for an eye.
33. Israel's justice body has to be revised
observer   (10.17.10)
In September 1992, the Klogman committee presented its findings to the government. Among others, the committee asserted that the take over of Arab property in East Jerusalem by the settlers’ organizations was conducted by the use of false affidavits, misapplication of the Absentee Property Act, illegal transfer of public property to ideological bodies, and illicit transfer of tens of millions of shekels in public funds to the right-wing organizations. http://www.alt-arch.org/images/yemenite2.jpg In April 2006 the Ghozlan family is driven out of their house by Elad. They were the same family who sheltered the Jewish residents of Silwan during the 1929 Palestine riots. The original letter of gratitude in Hebrew: http://www.alt-arch.org/images/yemenite2.jpg The chief perpetrator in both cases was no one other than David Be’eri [Davida’le]. When the same perpetrator, but in a nationalistically motivated hit and run case is hold the sole witness in the same case, then Israel's justice body has to be revised.
34. :: IZL - #32
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (10.17.10)
In the two clips I posted links for it shows Israeli kids stoning an international observers (ie: not a Palestinian) so your question/counterpoint is rather redundant. Either way teaching children to hate and commit violent acts (as shown in the video clips I supplied) is wrong and it is also highly hypocritical for the likes of Brian Cohen to get criticize others when his own people are doing the exact same thing. By this logic you are advocating copying what the Palestinians do or are guilty of. This mentality only proves that there is no difference between Israelis and Palestinians.
35. He just a kid leave him alone
daz ,   uk   (10.17.10)
I wonder if the police give as much care and attention to arresting the settler kids who are nothing but thugs, my guess is not
36. #1 - so kids threw stones first...for their survival??
William ,   Israel   (10.17.10)
Amazing kids. They actually have the ability to see the future (according to Salma), and threw the rocks at this Israeli's car because of what they knew he would do in the future. Ah, only in an Arab court would this ever make sense...but not in the real world, Salma. Sorry.
37. #4 - survival is against human morals??
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
more like sending your kids out to commit acts of violence and teaching them to be racists from birth. And interestingly enough, while "settlements" began after 1969, Arab hatred on this level involving their youth has been for almost a century. But with your ilk, that's acceptable because it's their culture and you're so tolerant, aren't you?
38. #7- ease up on Salma...
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
she also considers killing pregnant Israelis at point blank range to be considered "defending one's self". The entire "Palestinian" population agree on that one.
39. #9 - Almost all peace movements are based in Israel
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
Name one group inside "Palestinian" territories that promote co-existence or peace? When you find one, then you can return and comment. I believe that answers your question about who teaches peace and who teaches war.
40. #1 - let's see Arab reactions if the kids hit Arab cars
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
I'm sure a lot more than just a "questioning" would be the result, for the youth and his father. A few fingers would be lost and a few organs badly cruised, but according to Toney, they are the poster children for morality.
41. #12 - I'm a bit confused. Doesn't Lennon's peace...
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
also include NOT slandering your fellow human? Now, it seems obvious that you hold disdain for settlers and consider yourself above them for whatever reason. But your claim that settlers preach hate and war is very much founded in ignorance. I wonder....have you ever actually met a settler? visited a settlement? Or do you allow yourself to be led by a few news pieces and make your decision of that very limited perspective of reporting?? John Lennon would not be happy about your chosen path of self-induced ignorance and bias.
42. #25 - Which country would that be, Gregg?
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
Switzerland is a civilized country and ALL citizens join the army for a mandatory period. Other countries that have mandatory military service: Albania, Armenia, Austria, Belarus, Bermuda, Brazil, China, Colombia, Cyprus, Denmark, Egypt, Finland, Germany, Greece, Iran, Israel, South Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Russia, Serbia, Singapore, Taiwan, Turkey, and Ukraine. That's an awful lot of "uncivilized" people, Gregg, don't you think? Of course, Israel wouldn't need a mandatory military service if it wasn't at threat 24/7 of being annihilated by its neighbors for the past 62 years.
43. #33 - how do you know Beeri's actions were nationalistic?
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
Seems like the Arab kids' actions were nationalistic or just plain steeped in racism - not really much of a difference among Arabs, I suppose. I know one thing - if they threw stones at my car in an ambush, you can be sure I'd hit the gas, and not for nationalistic reasons either.
44. #34 - Matty on "eye for an eye"
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
Please, Matty. You lambaste IZL for considering an "eye for an eye" in dealing with Arab racist violent actions but you still haven't stated that what the "Palestinians" do is violent, illegal, immoral, and a crime against humanity. Throwing stones, throwing fire bombs, snipering civilians are ALL grossly horrible crimes but I still haven't heard you once denounce them for it. Should you really be the one pretending to be the voice of reason here? Certainly not. I hardly believe that Israelis and "Palestinians" are the same. Just look at their advancement over the past 62 years and the crap they put on prime time TV to see the difference. That alone discredits you from any "objective" opinion you might try to promote here.
45. #35 - you mean the settlers girls they fondled?
William ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
Yeah, it seems like some police are a little more pre-occupied with settlers kids than Arab kids. But since the settlers usually respond this way to police anyway and not every Arab car they see, I can't follow how you arrived that they are all thugs, especially coming from the UK where I doubt you ever traveled to Israel to met a settler or visited a settlement. But boy does your ilk get pissed when people share their opinions about the UK, no matter how ill-informed they are. You have become what you truly despise in others.
46. The truth came out
Lital ,   Israel   (10.18.10)
those children are more then criminals they are terrorists , so why do you still show the picture of the injured criminal? he isn't the victim!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article