News
Netanyahu orders change to loyalty oath
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 18.10.10, 23:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
45 Talkbacks for this article
31. one more revison
Pinny ,   Bat Yam   (10.19.10)
Leftist members of Meretz, Shinui Labor and Kadima must also swear an oath of loyalty to the Jewish Democratic State of Israel All Arab MKs who swear falsely must be convicted of perjury and treason if they are passing classified information to the enemy and traveling to enemy countries as well as any treasonous statements made by them. At that point they should be expelled from the Knesset, stripped of citizenship and deported!
32. Who cares what the Goyim think?
Ben ,   Gush Etzion   (10.19.10)
Do they care about the no Jews allowed in Jordan law? Did they care about the Nuremberg Laws? Did they care about the Wannsee Conference? When Hitler introduced the Nuremberg racial laws in 1935, he received telegrams of congratulation from all corners of the Arab world. Later, during the war, one of his most ardent supporters was the Mufti of Jerusalem. Jews were never permitted to live in Jordan. Civil Law No. 6, which governed the Jordanian-occupied West Bank, states explicitly: "Any man will be a Jordanian subject if he is not Jewish."5- 5Jordanian Nationality Law, Official Gazette, No. 1171, Article 3(3) of Law No. 6, 1954, (February 16, 1954), p. 105. Do they denounce the US Pledge of Allegiance?
33. RE: losing American citizenship
Zvika ,   Jerusalem   (10.19.10)
The decisive opinion will be that of the U.S. State Dept. and the judicial system, not how folks here responding to the article understand it. Frankly, it is a serious matter that ought to be carefully examined.
34. #3 Avi from Geneva
Michael ,   Haifa   (10.19.10)
In following Avi's brilliant suggestion, I think that all the Swiss should also be obliged to take the oath
35. Knesset
Maurice ,   Israel   (10.19.10)
Avi, Let's start simply with our lawmakers, members of our Knesset.
36. why? can you please explain?
nadav ,   tlv israel   (10.19.10)
37. this is like hamas iran redrafting its hijab law
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (10.19.10)
the redraft: not only western women will be forced to wear hijab, but we'll also force religious muslim women to wear hijab! who is this retarded nitin-yahoo think he's fooling?!
38. basic flaw...
(10.19.10)
We are all (pro & con; left & right) starting out from a flawed position. We all think that merely saying the words of a loyalty oath will keep all of us honest, forthright and true to the State of Israel. Tis a good thing to think that way; itsays that we all believe in the basic goodness of our fellow man/woman. But we all really should know that well not all men/women who swear to this or that reeally mean what they are saying! Two examples: Take for example Doctor Baruch Goldstein...he swore to uphold the physician's oath and well we all know about the massacre he carried out in direct violation of his oath. Take for example the former MK Bashara an MK for crying out loud swore loyalty to Israel and where is he today...over there in the Nasrallah/Hisballah camp. So really people let's get real and realize that saying the words doesn't really mean anything...it is about one's actions!
39. why should it cause a problem with american/other citizenshi
eporue ,   europe   (10.19.10)
ps, to RECOGNIZE the jewish/israeli state as such ? an MKs oath, or a soldiers oath, might have a different wording ?
40. @37 He's not fooling anyone....
Yossi G. ,   Jerusalem   (10.19.10)
just making sure refugees go to the new palestine (if there ever is one), that could possibly include a confederation with you guys, since you are already 70% pal. That's the most logical solution.
41. This Israeli/Jewish loyalty issue came out of nowhere...
seadog1946 ,   Shooters Island, NJ   (10.19.10)
initially, a flaccid right wing attempt to forestall a Palestinian demand on the right of return which has firmed into internation debate. First, it's the ever evolving citizenship oath issue... what's next? A mandatory bris?
42. #41 Bris is mandatory! but I understand ur point...
(10.19.10)
well I understand your point if it is to say that basic freedoms are being denied by a psuedo-fascist government. Is that what you meant to say? and really bris is mandatory it is right there in the bible!
43. dual citizenship?
opensoc   (10.19.10)
44. Losing American Citizenship?
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (10.20.10)
The AACI is checking this issue out. Frankly it hadn't occurred to them 'til a friend of mine wrote. She received a letter from their legal advicer thanking her and saying it was being looked into, and the next day one from the AACI National in Jerusalem saying a meeting of the board would be called over it! They are quite concerned.
45. #42 you can serve in the army, pay taxes, and feed....
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (10.20.10)
...fundamentalist Jews who won't work even if you aren't snipped. But I wouldn't put it past this government to pass a law over it.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article