News
Vatican body asks UN to 'end Israeli occupation'
Reuters
Published: 23.10.10, 14:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
209 Talkbacks for this article
121. Rights to the land...and reasons Christians are leaving
Solomon ,   Bklyn   (10.23.10)
1. Yes, let's put aside the Bible, even if it is a great history book. Jews have EARNED the right to the land. They bought the land and cleared it (1800's). That's when most of the Arabs came to the improved economic situation. And with all the wars the Arabs have started, and Israeli had to win, Israel has EARNED the right to the place, the Arabs have LOST any rights they may have had. 2. Palestinians "are suffering the consequences of the Israeli occupation" NO. They are suffering at the hands of the Moslems, regardless of any occupation. This began with the Lebanese Civil Wars.
122. Vaticans are being paid by Islam
Eyal ,   USA   (10.23.10)
Millions of Dollars or they wouldn't go over the limb like this. Silver speaks louder than belief. Catholics are plain fake and not Christians what so ever, just show us the money and throw a few young boys while you're at it.
123. Look who is giving chumash lessons!
i ,   jerusalem   (10.23.10)
#116: not hacks, thugs, a true criminal org with accent on money and control , and child and woman abuse as a sideline.
124. Vatican must stop the "occupation of Rome "
Anna M Sedda ,   Italy-Rome   (10.23.10)
we Christians are fed up with this Pope and this pedophile priest and bishops and we urge them to spend more time in bibblical school than watching sex videos...
125. Christians urge the Vatican
Anna M Sedda ,   Italy-Rome   (10.23.10)
to take down the orrible wall that "separete" Vatican city from Rome",to get rid of the Army" and soldiers that are at the entrance,the guns and swords they carry and to build bridges to Italy....beside,nobody lives in the Vatican State,Is the only "empy state" .The Vatican is a big joke!!!!!!!
126. to 50 Sara - I doubt Gil is a Catholic name
Abe ,   AZ   (10.23.10)
Even if it was learn to control yourself, you have a sewage for a mouth, please take care of your issues. You have the unique ability to turn a Jew into an anti Semite.
127. Pope and a billion Catholics in USA
Fred ,   Philly USA   (10.23.10)
Israel cannot use the Biblical concept of a promised land or a chosen people to justify settlements in Jerusalem or territorial claims in Judea and Sammaria. Recourse to theological and biblical positions which use the Word of God to wrongly justify injustices is not acceptable. We Christians cannot speak about promised land for the Jewish people. There is no longer one chosen people. All men and women of all countries have become the chosen people. The concept of “the promised land” cannot be used as a base for the justification of the return of Jews to Israel and the displacement of Palestinians. The justification of Israel's occupation of the land of Palestine cannot be based on sacred scriptures. Palestinians "are suffering the consequences of the Israeli occupation: the lack of freedom of movement, the wall of separation and the military checkpoints, the political prisoners, the demolition of homes, the disturbance of socio-economic life and the thousands of refugees." It condemned terrorism "from wherever it may proceed" as well as anti-Semitism, Islamophobia and discrimination against Christians. Vatican
128. To: No. 68
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.23.10)
And your travesty of a religion teaches that I will go to hell because I do not accept a schizophrenic with delusions of grandeur as my "lord and savior," is that right? Yeah, pretty much. Oh -- by the way -- I am Jewish. I do not need your permission to speak. Go slap your wife around some if it'll make you feel more of a man. To me -- you've got a long uphill evolutionary climb before I can think of you as anything more than a silly, squeaky mouse.
129. To: No. 114
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.23.10)
If I were you, I would take a long hard look at myself and wonder why is it that the consistent acceptance of death over apostasy has always been preferred by Jews forced to make a choice? I mean, I do realize that Europe had 300 years of "today I'm Catholic; tomorrow I'm Protestant; the day after I'm Catholic again, etc. etc." and it made no difference to them, despite major dogmatic differences. The only thing I would want to be if I could not be Jewish is dead. That's called being principled and devoted to one's faith. Is that what has always made you goyim so jealous of us? Too bad. We have our country back now; you can't hurt us anymore, no matter how badly your ego and sense of self-esteem needs it.
130. Vatican is groveling after the Pope's comment about how Isla
Lisa ,   Canada   (10.23.10)
I am Catholic, and I am shocked this was said by Bishops. Israel is Jewish land and holy scriptures are proof enough of that. I suppose the Vatican is groveling after the Pope's comment about how Islam is spread by the sword. Sad that political correctness has invaded the Vatican. Too political and should remain true to biblical values.
131. Please Ignore Popes Hitler Youth
Reality Check ,   USA   (10.23.10)
If you are stupid enough to beleive years in the Hitler Youth have no influence on one's thinking.
132. And who'se sitting on Italian Land ,Huh ?
R.Seener ,   London England   (10.23.10)
133. 114 , they did it as communists , not as Jews
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.23.10)
and you know it . But the church did it as a church , with clerics heading the executions , burnings , torturing of Jews . And this in NAME of the "holy church" .
134. what a giant bag of douche
pini ,   usa israel   (10.23.10)
All I can say
135. Hey why do you not speak instead of the 'chosen children'
Ron ,   Melbourne, Australia   (10.23.10)
A favourite past time with Vatican clergy. Yes, we known you morals ...
136. Settlements in Jerusalem? Is that guy on drugs?
Yaniv ,   Israel   (10.23.10)
137. synod idea
Lion ,   adelaide australia   (10.23.10)
this report contains errors, concerning the land of Israel , Judea and Samaria. There is no doubt as to whom this Land belongs, it is present day Israel. Israel is still the Chosen People of The Almighty G-d and Promises made to them, will yet be fullfilled. Not all who say the are Christian are so , as can be seen during the past 1800 years or so. G-D Bless Jersulem and Judea and Israel
138. Bishops blaming Israelto save Christians from radical Islam
Joe ,   Canada   (10.23.10)
For years the Vatican refused to open an embassy in Israel for fear of the consequences on the fate of the christians in Muslim countries many of which barely tolerate them when they do not persecute them. As radical Islams gains ground Christians' insecurity worsens as can be seen in Irak, Gaza... the bishops feel compeled to try protecting their flock. But instead of blaming the root cause of the problem, on which they know they have no leverage, they find it easier to slam Israel in the hope it will gain them a few browny points of PR with the Muslim world. The bishops go as far as stating that they condemn terrorism "from wherever it may proceed" as if in this matter, radical Islam terrorism is on the same plane as the implied Israeli terrorism so as not to hurt the "sensitivities" of the radicals & it gives them an indirect justification for their deeds as a retaliation in "self defense". The bishops are deluding themselves if they believe that their words will have any effect on the retrograde obscurantists in the growing ranks of radical Islam.
139. Vatican body
RC ,   USA   (10.23.10)
The Pope and his bishops should start meditating on what the Bible says. The Pope and the Vatican are not above יהוה, for it is Yahuwshua that holds the keys and not the Pope (Revelations 1:17 – 1:18, 3:7). Jeremiah chapter 31 states that יהוה is going to rebuild Israel and vines shall be planted in the mountains of Samaria. Jeremiah 31:10 “Hear the word of יהוה, O gentiles, and declare it in the isles afar off, and say, ‘He who scattered Israel gathers him, and shall guard him as a shepherd his flock.’ If the Vatican wishes to align with the Arabs then they are going against the Word of YHWH. The Pope is not infallible for he is just a mere man, and just like Peter erred and Paul had to withstand him to his face (Galatians 2:11) the true Christians will withstand the Pope when he errs. The Muslims have enough land to share with the Palestinians but they wish to eradicate Israel and are using the Palestinians as an excuse. They refuse to accept the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and their time is running out.
140. The Church was given
Eyal ,   USA   (10.23.10)
Millions of Dollars or they wouldn't go over the limb like this. Silver speaks louder than belief. Catholics are plain fake and not Christians what so ever, just show us the money and throw a few young boys while you're at it.
141. When will he return Temple Items?
Ita   (10.23.10)
Talk about pot calling the kettle back. He should return the STOLEN utensils from the Bais Hamikdash (holy temple of jersusalem) before opening his mouth!
142. #128 - wife slapping? WTF...
seadog1946 ,   Shooters Island, NJ   (10.23.10)
there is no need to project your personal issues/problems onto us goys/donkeys... you should seek guidance from your Rabbi/encounter-group. In the interim, take your meds or wrap a tefillin around your head to keep it from exploding.
143. Who do they think they are?
Rick ,   Houston, USA   (10.23.10)
This apostate group of "religious" people have no clue as to what the Scriptures say regarding Israel. They are white washed tombstones full of dead mens bones. They are a disgrace to Christianity.
144. the catholic church needs to stay out of it....
Galut ,   Selah   (10.23.10)
the scripture says ALL nations that come against Jerusalem in the later days will NOT fair well .... those that bless the jews will be blessed those that curse the jews will be........... time to read and heed the scripture
145. They still mad about jews killing their god
Usa   (10.23.10)
A truly evil entity.
146. The nazican speaks
Usa   (10.23.10)
Curse them father for they have sinned.
147. Respect my church.
Luiz Felipe Haddad ,   Niteroi, Rio, Brazil   (10.24.10)
I regret very much the outrageous and offensive comments, from many readers, about the synod of catholic bishops and about our Pope Benedict. I know, happily, they don't represent Israelian public opinion, but my sadness is great. However, some day, those readers will recognize that we, true Christians, want only Peace with Justice for all people in the suffered Middle East. God bless you. Luiz Felipe Haddad.
148. STOP with the Vatican's privileges in Israel
Michel ,   Jerusalem   (10.23.10)
Why to grant them privileges, taxes exemptions ..???
149. Who cares?
H John ,   Mumbai, Birmingham   (10.23.10)
Who is Pope or his Synod to talk against the basic biblical fact? It is definitely another end-time sign. Everyone is against Israel. But the Bible says although the entire world comes against it, he will deliver Jerusalem and Judah from them. Catholicism is large in membership of adherents. But this is not politics, so neither Israel nor true Christians should care about what Catholic Church says.
150. To: No. 142
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.24.10)
My issues? Not hardly. I just thought I would address the "lord and master" attitude which you so typically project in a manner which you might possibly understand. Just another barking goy, you. Sit, roll over and play dead.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article