News
Shulamit Aloni: I feel like stranger here
Yoav Zitun
Published: 07.11.10, 17:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
31. Not so much a stranger ...
Andy Levy-Stevenson ,   Efrat, Israel   (11.08.10)
Just strange.
32. Shulamit Aloni.
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (11.08.10)
A great democrat, a great humanist a great Israeli and a really great woman. Brava Shulamit !!!
33. Aloni feels she is a stranger here?No wonder she is Disloyal
Ari ,   IRomania-Israel   (11.08.10)
"Aloni, referring to the amendment, said that in every country a person is a citizen. "Jews in Britain are British," she said. "They have the same rights as Catholics and Protestants." What Aloni forgot to mention is: 1. The official Religion in England, is Anglican. Which makes the state kind of Theocratic. Even though there is Freedom of Religion. THat makes it very similiar to ISRAEL. 2. What Aloni forgets is that those English Jews or English Catholics etc Have sworn Loyalty to England as English Citizens. The Loyal act approved by the Kneset is a BIG MISTAKE. Loyalty Oath Should be for every citizen.Not Only for new comers weather Jewish or not. ยท. Yesterday Arab MK Soabi Declared: "I am a Palestinian an Arab and an antizionist and aCitizen." Question a citizen from Where? China?France?Italy? A member from What Parliament: Egipt,Lebanon,Jordan? This wreched woman pretends to be A Citizen of Israel and a member of the Israeli Parliament with no sense of loyalty?She pretends to be An Israeli Citizen with LOyalty to the future Palestinian State? I like that Honesty. So let her move to Ramallah where maybe the Future Palestinian State will be founded. Where her Loyalty lays. She canot continue to be an Israeli parlamentarian or citizen with her loyalty lies in another country, weather existent or not. Leftists and Arab Israelis are confusing Freedom of Speach and Religion, to Loyalty. Loyalty should not be choosable. And that does not make Israel a Facist or Apartheid State. Israel was Founded as a Jewish and Zionist State by the Sionist Movement from Left and Right. The Hagana, the Palmach,The Ishuv the IIrgun etc were Zionists. As Hertzel said "We have founded the Jewish State. It was Founded by the Zionist Congress. In the declaration of Independance drawn by Israel in 1948. Freedom of Speach and religion were declared, and also the Jewish caracter of the State. THe Question of loyalty is implicit in the Act and is forceable to all citizens. Yes we remember the first leftists of movements such as Hashomer Hatzair and Mapam who were loyalists to the Intrrnational Comunist Party of Russia , they were in favor of a Binational State with the arabs. But their equation failed. The Arabs did not want to be part of a Binational State with Jews. Still these heirs of those leftist want to give away our country based in a Stupid Dialectic of false principles. SHULAMIT ALONI you are a LIVING DEAD, go back to your tomb and rest in peace. And this goes also for the Antizionist Haredim specially those of Naturei Carta and the Satmar Hasidim. To use the State and all the benefits derived from it and be disloyal and Anti Israeli does not fit in same shoe. I hope YNET does not give a brush and Publish this comment.
34. #32
Dan, ,   TelAviv ,Israel   (11.08.10)
Agree with you 100% ,she is the grand dame of all that is noble in Israel. Viva Shulamit.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article