News
Nasrallah provokes Iran: No such thing as Persian civilization
Dudi Cohen
Published: 10.11.10, 20:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Nasrallah is absolutely correct while saying this:
leo ,   usa   (11.10.10)
"Today there is no such thing as Persian civilization in Iran. There is an Islamic civilization in Iran. There is (prophet) Muhammad's religion in Iran," --- I wonder if non-Arab Muslims of the rest of the World understand this about themselves. --- Nasrallah may be smart man, but he is useful idiot none the less.
2. somebody get this guy a history book
zionist forever   (11.10.10)
There have been plenty of wars with the Persians in the bible. The Purim story took place in Persia. If he wants to look beyond bible stories he should look to the secular history books. Persia was once a superpower of its day and fought wars with many countries. Iranians are persians not arabs and there are still some persians who are not muslims. Problem is the country is run by islamic nut cases who believe in the suicide cult and want to enforce Sharia law.
3. Technially, he's right...
Persian CAT   (11.10.10)
Both Khomein and Khamenie are "seyyeds", which means descendants of Mohammad, as signified by the black tubans on their friggin heads. AND THAT'S WHERE THEIR "ARABNESS" STOPS!
4. A leader who has stood up to the most...
Persian CAT   (11.10.10)
viscous attackers and beaten them cannot be an idiot. The joke is on you, boy.
5. He's right - Persia died in 1933 - became Iran
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (11.10.10)
6. Persian CAT, idiot and useful idiot are not the same.
leo ,   usa   (11.10.10)
Whatever Nasrallah said can be exploited against him and that makes him useful idiot from Israeli perspective. You may see it differently, of course.
7. #1 - Nasrallah is completely wrong!
michael redbourn ,   Arad - Israel   (11.10.10)
Persian history is said to have begun with King Cyrus the Great, who unified Persia and conquered vast tracts of land. He is also famous for liberating the Jews from captivity in Babylon around 538 BC, as is amply recorded in the Bible, in the Books of Isaiah, Daniel and Ezra. As far as I know, the Arabs enter history around 305 AD, with the Nabataean Inscriptions; but their real entrance into history was the appearance of Mohammed (570-632 AD) Arabs conquered Persia in the seventh century, spreading Islam. The fact that Iran is mostly Muslim doesn't change the fact the Persians came on the scene about 800 years before the 'Arabs'.
8. above
moishe   (11.11.10)
the man is an illiterate or a liar. he has not read the history of Persia/Iran. the people that follow him must be just as stupid. pity!
9. Nasrallah
BH ,   Iowa   (11.11.10)
There's no such thing as a "palestinian" civilization.
10. People always say Iranians are Persians...
San Franciscan ,   Los Angeles, CA, USA   (11.11.10)
But few know that the percentage of the Persian population of Iran is only around 40-50% max. Roughly 1/3 of their population is Armenian and at least 1/4 are Kurds. The rest are ethnic minorities. Further, 40% of their population is under the age of 30. Iran is a much more complex place than just Neo-Persia.
11. There was a Persian civilization before Islam.
Terry ,   Eilat - Israel   (11.11.10)
Persia was a great & cultured empire before falling prey to an evil ideology brought by barbarian conquerors. This totalitarian ideology has done it's best to destroy an ancient civilization bringing only stagnation & backwardness just as it destroyed the other ancient civilizations it conquered. Most lost their identity completely, such as Egypt & Syria & most of N. Africa. But the memory of the great Persian civilization still endures & someday, will reject it's conquest by an inferior culture.
12. Persia
moshe bar noach ,   london canada   (11.11.10)
Through out the last 1300 or so years of Islam, there have been many Muslim rulers who where born of Christian Mothers... check it out!!
13. leo, I do see it differntly...
Persian CAT   (11.11.10)
I betcha he doesn't give a rat's behind about "Israeli perspective".
14. WHO THE HECK CARES
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (11.11.10)
I could care less, as far as I'm concerned they share the death cult mentality. They are together as hate mongers and have no place in the civilized world. They get along because the enemy of my enemy is my friend attitude. When their common enemy, whoever that may be at time, is out of the way they go back to killing each other. A simple look around the world can see more Muslim on Muslim violence than anything else in the present day world. So who really cares? Just another reason for them to fight each other when the time is right. It is the main reason why it's so funny that people think if the Israeli-Arab conflict were to end, that we would have peace on earth, what a joke. Only the fools and the antisemitic believe this nonsense. they lie about everything anyways, so who knows where these guys are descendants from. After all Arafat invented a history from Palestine that proved completely false. As he was born, raised, and educated in Egypt. Yet invented some BS history that some idiots still believe today.
15. Nassrallah extinguishes Persian History! LOL!
Factfinder ,   US-Israel   (11.11.10)
Well...if ya plan on bein' a Muslim....ya may as well know right from the start that ya ain't gonna have any family history left once you convert! LOL! Yer just another goat in a herd...history re-written for you with the words from some idiots mouth! I find this so funny and amusing but extraordinarily frightening that westerners actually cooperate and support people like this who'll exterminate world history in one breath! But THIS IS ISLAM and what they've always done. Just look at Rachel's tomb: according to the idiots at the UN...it's actually a mosque with "ancient Palestinian history" attached to it! (I just can't help but burst out in laughter at these people!). To them, it's their way or NOT! (ie: violence, bloodshed, hatred and the murder of innocent people). Only Israel remains alone in their commitment to sovereignty: Obama sold out the US and Israel: and H. Clinton showered us Jews with her own Krystal-Nacht by announcing Jerusalem as a 'settlement' today. May these two lunatics lose their jobs immediately...ESP now that they've fulfilled the prophecy of Israels isolation! LOL! Chai Yisrael. Persia....you accepted Islam and lost your entire history, culture and character...you probably deserve it.
16. Another shining example of Arab mindset
Cameron ,   USA   (11.11.10)
LOL though....talk about rubbing his Persian paymaster's nose in the dirt.
17. #14 who cares...
roxanne ,   haifa, israel   (11.11.10)
i think this is a wonderful story! we don't want to see iran and hezbollah in a good relationship. comments like nasrallah's will damage diplomacy. HOPEFULLY.
18. Persian CAT, Nasrallah is not expected to care what
leo ,   usa   (11.11.10)
Israelis think. We are talking about how his words can be used to affect others. Nasrallah has already said a lot and if he has more words of similar wisdom I wouldn't mind hearing it.
19. michael redbourn @ 7, it is not the matter of
leo ,   usa   (11.11.10)
Nasrallah being right or wrong. It is matter of how Arab Muslims view national aspirations of non-Arab Muslims. I suspect Arab-Muslims see the rest as semi-dhimmis at best. I am sure non-Arab Muslims will not like it. I only fear they just do not understand the measure of insult leveled at them and that must be explained.
20. #17; roxanne, nothing would please me more
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (11.11.10)
But don't count on it. Like I said in the earlier post, the enemy of my enemy is my friend. That is the rule they will follow. Right now Israel is their first priority, then they will go back to killing each other. Nothing could please me more, than to be wrong on this, and you be right.
21. Nasrallah provokes Iran
RC ,   USA   (11.11.10)
Ha-Ha, maybe what Nasrallah is trying to say is that once a country is overrun by Islam it loses its ethnicity and is converted to Arab. So I guess Turkey and Indonesia are Arabic also since their main religion is Arab originated. That is why the Muslims must bow towards Mecca, Arabia is their master. Nasrallah is just telling the Iranians who their masters are in a subtle way.
22. Persian CAT, how do you like the replies?
leo ,   usa   (11.11.10)
Now, do you understand what is being "useful idiot" really mean?
23. leo, there's a lot more going on...
Persian CAT   (11.11.10)
between Iran and Hezbollah that a single out-of-context YouTube thingie can negatively influence. Apparently this "thing" is being exploited by Israel, but both the Iranians and the Lebanese are smart enough to tell who their real enemies are. Yes, I do know what "useful idiot" means. Nice talking to you and keep the "usefulness" alive.
Back to article