News
IDF officers get photo of dead child
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 28.11.10, 07:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
31. to #22 Kate, you forgot how england refused
jason white ,   afula,israel   (11.28.10)
to let Jews escape the nazis by coming to mandate palestine. Or refusing to bomb the rail lines to the camps. Or how the survivors of the camps were to be sent back to germany after the war. Not to mention how the british turned over strategic positions to the arabs in 1948 and british officers commanding the jordanian legion to try to destroy Israel. The allies were allied with the nazis to destroy the Jews.
32. Not Spaniards
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (11.28.10)
The people who send these letters are not Spaniards, but Israeli Jewish Leftists funded by foreign governments. According to these people, a Jew who tries to defend himself is a criminal. Because self-defense is the most basic human right, like Goldstone these Leftists deny that Jews are human. Shades of the '30s. Israel will cease to exist unless the Israeli "justice system" stops legitimizing these people.
33. # 30
Linda ,   Poltava, Ukraine   (11.28.10)
Kate, read my talkback again: there is a great difference between Eastern (where Poltava is located) and Western Ukraine. The Nazi collaborators (Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists, or OUN) have been primarily Western Ukrainians, from the part that was not under USSR rule before WW2. Eastern and Western Ukraine are two different civilizations.
34. Many of European countries
Bar ,   Hertzliya   (11.28.10)
have absolutely NO rights to accuse Israel for defending its people and territory from the barbarian Arabs who don't understand any other kind of communication but war, mainly the colonizers like Portugal, Spain, France, Italy, England... What to expect from Spaniards? They tried to exterminate the Basques (and still try in every possible way to reduce their rights and freedom), and we can't forget they're Arabs. Almost 8 centuries of Arab occupation can't be erased so easily from people's minds...
35. From Spain/Desde ESPAÑA
Meyo ,   Spain   (11.28.10)
Are you not able to think it was not probably a Spaniard who sent the letter?? Believe me, we do not like what is going on there with Gaza but we have our own problems. Inquisition happened some centuries ago, you should hear what the Pope Benedicte XVI has said about us just a couple of weeks ago. And the only God does not agree with Hamas of course, but neither with your actions against Palestinian.
36. IDF officers get photo of dead child
guess it ,   spain   (11.28.10)
Although the operation was hard, it's only a new campaign of those who deem they know the Truth, but the truth is that Spain is undergoing a campaign by the officialist party PSOE and biased media to show a tale of good&bad. The proposal is hidding another themes. I can't support wars, I can't support cruelty, but I have to admit the zone's situantion does not allow stopping such operations.
37. Oh
Elieazer Dov Bear ,   Somewhere Israel   (11.28.10)
well I guess the Arab league exploiting the Arabs called Palestinians so they can take revenge for their humiliation has nothing to do with this right? I guess The big Hamas leaders who have hid their families in other countries while they turn Gaza into a hell whole isn't a part of this either. I guess Hamas launching missiles at civilians is OK as long as no one gets killed right? These people take these actions than the innocent get taken along for the ride and it's all on us. Maybe if the Arab league and the leaders in their proxy militias would think things through than such things wouldn't happen?
38. Wrong Side Got The Letter
emanon ,   USA   (11.28.10)
How do the arabs explain using women and children as shields?
39. Murdered children picture
Froy   (11.28.10)
If the soldiers have no conscience problems, they shouldn't be so upset to receive the pictures showing the atrocities they perpetrated. They can post them in their Facebook profile and title it "the best times of my life".
40. Form Spain, I support Israel against terrorism!
Pablo ,   Madrid, Spain   (11.28.10)
41. To Kate from London, regarding Ukraine
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (11.28.10)
I completely agree that during the Holocaust, many Ukrainians gladly helped out the Nazis in the extermination of Jews. However, so were the Poles, the Lithanians, the Latvians, the Croats, the Greeks, the French, the Dutch, etc... I don't really believe you could single out a single nationality. Nearly ALL of Europe was badly antisemitic. And nowadays, at least with Ukraine, things are different. Unlike in Western Europe, Israel gets a lot of sympathy from the Ukraine - not only from the government (and from both of the opposing political parties, interestingly enough) but from the people too. It is no coincidence that many Ukrainian tourists came to Israel in recent years. Indeed antisemitism is still alive there, but show me a European country where it is not. Our problem in this forum lies with true antisemites like "Peter, Vienna" or "Matty Groves" or "Mikesailor". But Linda is all right. Her post at #17 was actually supportive of Israel. However, you are quite right about this Frederic Charles...
42. My sympathy to these soldiers. This is hard to bare.
rebecca ,   Modiin   (11.28.10)
This war, non of our wars, were started by us, but were a reaction, to terror, killing, attacks etc. Yet in each war our soldiers took as much care as possible to prevent the deaths of civilians. But they do still happen. Had our soldiers been the animals we fight against these pics would not hurt them. BH it does, and I feel for the soldiers, our sons and brothers.
43. #22, #30 Kate..Unlike #15 who hasn't a clue to...
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (11.28.10)
...what's going on Israel, Gaza and the West bank.....Linda is with us. You should read more of her posts on these YNET threads You got a bit carried away and threw the baby out with the bathwater. Kindly apologise to her and have a good week : )
44. sue in court chase down every leftit pig israel pig involved
ralph   (11.28.10)
45. #39 Froy - Conscience
Solomon ,   Bklyn   (11.28.10)
The soldiers DO have conscience problems, unlike Hamas, Hezbollah and the PA. But they do what is necessary to defend their families, hoping civilians do not get killed. Are they to throw up their hands and say 'kill me and my family as I am afraid of hurting your children as you hide behind them while you are trying to kill me and mine'? Blame the Arabs for having no conscience and not caring about tragic deaths like these...except for propoganda.
46. Nr. 14; Frederic Charles from Paris
Serge ,   Antwerp, Belgium   (11.28.10)
What do you expect ? That Israeli have their citizens targeted with rockets without trying to eliminate the terrorist groups that shoots them. There will be peace when Palestinians decide to negotiate. Did you notice that Mahmood Abbas is trying everything to evade negotiations. Never mind Hamas that wants total destruction of Israel. Your submissive morality suits Europe.
47. Kate #22, England should be prosecuted for war crimes
Yosi ,   Gilo   (11.28.10)
During most of wwll they knew about the killings by the Germans yet what did they do handed Jews back to the Germans Now that is what is called collaboration Kate my dear don't open your mouth it smells real bad of hypocracy
48. He Who Casts The First Stone
Brazen   (11.28.10)
should first take the plank out of his eye. Ask the Basques if they have pics of their MURDERED child at the hands of SPAIN?
49. Froy 39
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.28.10)
I could make a lot of suggestions for your Facebook profile but none of them would be printable.
50. well said Froy #39
observer   (11.28.10)
51. #39 To Froy,The Lying Hypocrite
dan ,   UK   (11.28.10)
Your the typical example The World hates Israel today..You and your kind of lies helped Murder 6 Million Jews. You will be responsible like the rest of the anti-Israeli Propagandist, if or when the next Holocaust happen.What you wrote was loaded with Accusations and vile characteristc of a People who only do their very best to safeguard their Own Innocent..as for the Dead arabs,Blame that on the real Perpetrators,HAMAS,Who Deliberately use them as Shields..you have Desecrated their memory by Blaming their deaths on Israel,while absolving their Killers Hamas.I can tell that Facts matters little to people like you,Hypocrite! Your twisted,Take your hatred and go blame those who are really Responsible.
52. This is sick!!!
Ginette Golden ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.28.10)
Typical Hamas propaganda... WE STAND BY YOU AND WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU, OUR WONDERFUL I.D.F.!!!
53. Moslem Palstinins use their kids as soldiers in holy Jihad
sick culture   (11.28.10)
54. These letters are from Spanish Fascist Islamists
not from Spanish   (11.28.10)
55. G-d doesn't need an explanation, he already knows
William ,   Israel   (11.28.10)
G-d is already aware of the filth we're dealing with here, who use such children as human shields while they target other children. It's why he keeps protecting Israel and supporting our many victories over the terrorists whom, if given time, this child would be forced to glorify in school. Find the return address and give a picture of Hamas men carrying children and shooting civilians, entitled "this is how I would explain it to G-d. How would you explain to G-d your endless hate in his world?"
56. #18 - when will you pay for Mumbai murders?
William ,   Israel   (11.28.10)
Hopefully, very soon...and I mean Pakistan as a collective, not just a few scapegoats in the Paki military.
57. #39 - how do you know it was caused by Israel?
William ,   Israel   (11.28.10)
Hamas set off a ton of IEDs which resulted in most of the building damage during Cast Lead, not IDF shells. And Hamas just announced that 900 of those killed in Cast Lead were infact their fighters and not civilians as they claimed. Somehow, your side seems to have dismissed that because it gets in the way of your hate agenda. Sad.
58. Kaukab Al Dayah
Kate ,   USA   (11.28.10)
This was four-year-old Kaukab Al Dayah (female), killed in her house in Gaza City, bombed by an F-16 on 6 Jan 2009 during 'Cast Lead'. Is it possible that Israelis, not to mention Israeli journalists, have never seen this photo? Most of the rest of the world has!
59. The guy is also swindler
observer   (11.28.10)
At Flatbush Yeshiva, IDF Colonel Ben Zion Gruber discussed the challenges of fighting terrorism while also following the high ethical standards of Jewish Law. With video footage of actual terrorist activity from intelligence cameras, Colonel Benzi explained how Israel's warfare policies differ from those of all other nations. So, what is the Jewish law he teaches? Rabbi Shapira of the settlement Yitzhar yeshiva, in his book "Torat Hamelech"; “When we approach a non-Jew who has violated the seven Noahide laws and kill him out of concern for upholding these seven laws, no prohibition (by the negative commandment; thou shall not murder) has been violated,” “In any situation in which a non-Jew’s presence endangers Jewish lives, the non-Jew may be killed even if he is a righteous Gentile and not at all guilty for the situation that has been created,”
60. The war criminals are on notice
IRAN#1   (11.28.10)
Justice will be awaiting you soon by the citizens' of the world.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article