News
WikiLeaks: Israel wanted PA to take Gaza
Ynet
Published: 29.11.10, 00:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. Well, DUH
Richard Wicks ,   Sunnyvale, CA   (11.29.10)
This is the big leak from Wikileaks??
2. that was already reported in the past
david ,   new york   (11.29.10)
i remember reading that at the time. what kind of leaker leaks information that is already publicly known?
3. #1: It´s enough!
Oscar ,   Argentina   (11.29.10)
It´s the confirmatory confession that USA is a dishonest broker for peace talks.
4. Wikileaks is BORING
R ,   Israel   (11.29.10)
I was expecting something unexpected, a lot more interesting, even exciting. So far I'm majorly bored. Even reality shows, scrouge of the new millenium, are more exciting. If Wikileaks were TV, I'd be flipping channels like crazy.
5. It must now be clear: Gaza is a political entity on its own
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (11.29.10)
and if it ever wishes to rejoin the rest of humanity, it must do so based on the application of UN Security Council Resolution 242, AS IS, and become once again part of Egypt. Any attempt to change this reality is akin to attempting to dry up the sea!
6. You don't ask Egypt, you tell Egypt
William ,   Israel   (11.29.10)
Once Hamas is cleaned out, it's back to being your (Egypt's) problem again, the way it was in 1967 and still should be. After all, they were Egyptian before 1967 and so shall they return.
7. They know Gaza belongs to Israel, deep down inside.
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.29.10)
Isn't that interesting? Both Fatah and Egypt refused to take Gaza. Could it be that they know Gaza belongs to Israel, deep down inside?
8. Wikileakes..CONFIRMS..PA...ABBAS...Israeli Stooges...
Ali ,   villanova -PA- USA   (11.29.10)
This is NOTHING new... ABBAS the BAHAI stooge has always been a PUPPET..and will always be.. The Israelis NOW will remove him..
9. barak says it would be "unacceptable collateral damage" but
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.29.10)
just ask the Israeli voters how many iranians could die to keep the Jews in Israel alive. My guess is that it would be an unlimited number.
10. No new information really just hard proof now of facts
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (11.29.10)
Israel must make some hard choices soon, with all options bad. A stronger PA is needed to bring Hamas under control but that is also dangerous. A stronger Christian Lebanon is needed to control Hizbollah but that also could be dangerous. A peace deal is the best solution for Palestinian problem but if they latter turn against Israel then its the worst option. The problem with status quo is that it will lead to more war and the destruction of Israel, along with much of the ME, with Africa, India and China moving it to take control.
11. activists
yaniv ,   uk   (11.29.10)
all you so called human right activists are fighting for freedom to Gaza yet the muslims so called brothers ( egypt-P.A authority) didnt even wanna take control of Gaza yes GAZA there own people.. I wonder why??? this to happened in 67,73,81 and 2009
12. weak luck ...end
(11.29.10)
13. Hmmm
Cameron ,   USA   (11.29.10)
So, in effect, Israel tried to avoid hard street fighting & casualties in a true ground victory over Hamas by trying to enlist Egypt & the PA to do it for them? Definitely has a "pimp" quality & aspect to it all.
14. Nothing New!
Salma ,   Palestine   (11.29.10)
Waiting for the SECRET documents and not for documents known to the vast majority of people !
15. victory???!!
fady egypt   (11.29.10)
where is this victory?? calling an retreat in the face of terror a victory? calling failure to stop the rocket fire a victory? calling a failure to disarm hamas a victory? calling failure to return shalit a victory? if any one call cast lead a victory is insane
16. barak expected victory?
moron ,   galut   (11.29.10)
does that mean he failed?why wasn't he fired?gaza is egyptian and jordan is 'palestine'
17. #15: the whining of hamas proved Israel won.
robert renders ,   belgium   (11.29.10)
18. wikileaks is made up and not true. a show createdbymedia+IT
(11.29.10)
19. #17 is Hamas whining gold standard to compare any victory wi
observer   (11.29.10)
20. #15 - rocket attacks were stemmed and Hamas pacified
William ,   Israel   (11.29.10)
That's the truth even though PRC lets an occasional rocket off. We see the panic in Hamas when they rush to stop the rocket attacks by PRC or IJ instead of condoning or funding them. Hamas also just graced us with the knowledge that Israel was 100% correct in their assessment of the casualties of Cast Lead - over 900 killed were Hamas men....that means less than 36% were civilians - remarkable in a tight urban setting, with terrorists using human shields and booby trapping homes with IEDs. But that's ok, Egyptians still consider the massive ass-kicking in 1973 by Israel as an "Arab victory". Nicely done.
21. no. 19, today you must be on your stongest meds
better observer   (11.30.10)
Back to article