News
Hamas: We won't recognize Israel
Ali Waked
Published: 14.12.10, 21:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why is Obama and Mitchell wasting our time?
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (12.14.10)
As long as Hamas will not accept Israel's right to exist at all, and the PA will not accept Israel's right to exist as the Jewish state, there is no point in holding negotiations. Both of these groups are saying loud and clear that any deal signed (even if it meets 100% of Hamas' requirements) they will not acknowledge Israel's right to exist and there will only be a ceasefire not a real and lasting peace. This makes the whole process a waste of everyone's time.
2. We know you won't recognize Israel...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.14.10)
That's where the entire conflict originates and that's why it will continue. Why anybody can feel any sympathy for these haters is beyond me, unless they are just as hateful themselves.
3. Jerusalem is the capital of Israel and not a "settlement".
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.14.10)
NOT NEGOTIABLE! EVER!
4. More Palestinian lies and doublespeak
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (12.14.10)
Of course Hamas will accept a Pal state in the '67 borders. It means they can fire rockets from east Jerusalem into west Jerusalem, and from the west bank into Tel Aviv and Haifa. Read his lips - Hamas wants war, not peace. As for Erekat, he is a known liar (infamous for his claim that Israel massacred 500 Palestinians in Jenin, but the UN and major human rights organizations investigated and found that there was no massacre). Erekat whines and cries about "settlements", but fails to explain why when Israel froze settlement construction a year ago, he refused to come to the negotiating table. Lies, lies and more lies. And these are our "peace partners"???
5. Would Peres recognize Hamas ?
Nora Tel Aviv   (12.14.10)
You bet.
6. ereckat and mitchel
moshon   (12.14.10)
Mitcehl is a professional mediator of the first order like holbrook was. However, short of palestinian change of hamas and refugee card, it is intractable and will only flare up again after a deal is forced. From my point of view, I want golan and jordan valley and a cold arrangementl. Livni wants a hot deal relinquishing golan, west bank and e.jerusalem. She then would run to the US and EU who will do what they do in lebanon-nothing. Average israelis probably say- what are you talking about-livni, olmert, barak.... these are highly trained people. No their training doesn't help. They forget history. The holocaust necesssitates israel to have muscle and defensible borders. I am not like livni, olmert, borg and oz rebelling against orthodox parents. Look at 73 war. Thank god we had golan. Ereckat was trained at bradford university in negotations and he wears down opponents with his constant refrain which amounts to total bs. Hear what he says inprivate.
7. i have news for you haniyeh
(12.14.10)
israelis and basically the entire world do not give a damn about what you think or say. so, keep your vocal cords in tact and stop screaming. no one is paying any attention to scum terrorists.
8. JERUSALEM
ABRAHAM ,   ISTANBUL - TURKEY   (12.14.10)
Jerusalem is not capital of İsrael...
9. Istanbul and Abraham from turkey
David ,   Haifa Israel   (12.14.10)
you freak muslims stole that capitol from the Byzantines! return it! Jersusalem is our capitol!! stop killing kurds and armenians then lecture us!
10. you won't recognize Israel, we won't recognize you!
(12.14.10)
11. #1 one more thing
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (12.14.10)
You must also remember the consensus of both the Hamas and Fatah terror groups that Israel must accept unlimited Arab immigration.
12. we won't recognize pale-stine,so stay in Jordan!!!
Anna M sedda ,   Italy-Rome   (12.14.10)
13. Too late!!!
Daniel ,   Brazil   (12.14.10)
Come on... are you kidding me!!!! 62 years later and after realizing that they have not achieve much since then, now these guys want '67 borders. Wake up people.. we are in 2010. They rather live in a @#$hole, than live in peace with Israel...keep on digging!!!!
14. TRUCE
ZICHRON   (12.14.10)
A TRUCE IS DESIRABLE AND THE ARABS CAN STAY IN ISRAEL THEY DONT HAVE TO BECOME JEWS OR ZIONISTS . BESIDES THEY WILL BE NEEDED IN THE WAR AGAINST THE HIDDEN GHENGIS KHAN IN IRAN
15. Israel doesn't need his recognition anyway...
Rami of Israel ,   Israel   (12.14.10)
16. #8 Abraham
Maurice ,   Montreal   (12.14.10)
...and Istanbul does not belong to the Turks! It used to be Constantinople and was stolen in 1453 by Sultan Ahmet.
17. # 16 Canada belongs to the Aboriginal peoples
1867 ,   First Nations   (12.14.10)
18. Europe is safe now israelis should just go back
Converts ,   Convertia Europia   (12.14.10)
19. To # 5 Nora
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bue.Aires_Argentina   (12.14.10)
I bet you that, if Hamas recognized Israel as a JEWISH and DEMOCRATIC STATE, IMMEDIATELY both the Government and the People of Israel will recognize Hamas. Anyway, I think that you are an "Agent Provocateur"- I'm not so sure that you are living in Tel-Aviv too. Do you think that you are successfully cheating us? No, my friend, you didn't cheat anyone in this talback. You are dead in your attempt to do that.
20. Ersatz "Palestinians"
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.14.10)
The ersatz "Palestinians" are a vanquished people. They do not get to set terms and conditions for anything. They get whatever crumbs Israel may graciously decide to throw their way .... or not, in Israel's sole discretion. Erekat's latest little gem: "When the Israeli government was asked to choose between peace and settlements it clearly chose the settlements, and therefore the steps it has taken have sabotaged the peace process." He kind of overlooked the fact that the PA had ten months of a settlement freeze in which the PA did absolutely nothing. It is ludicrous to fault Israel for that. They had a ten month freeze, failed to do anything constructive in that time and then had the absolute NERVE to demand yet another freeze! Someone really needs to drive home to these ersatz "Palestinians" that they do not call the shots.
21. WHO CARES!!! nobody wants a pali
Barney ,   USA   (12.14.10)
state including the so called palis. this would mean they would no longer be able to live off of the"refugee" aid they are so accustomed to receiving and their corrupt leaders would have nothing. After all they are incapable of being productive blinded by ignorance and hate. No Jews or Israelis want another terrorist entity on their borders. The solution-build out the land of the Jews and let the "palis" live with their many failures to embrace peace and the lot in life it bought them.
22. Give Hillary Clinton and "Lady" Ashton an ultimatum...
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (12.14.10)
either the both of them loudly and publically denounce - within 24 hours - the Hamas declaration of "never recognizing Israel" and state that they do not support creation of any Palestinian state with refuses recognizing Jewish israel, OR Israel will cut off permanently strawberry and produce exports from Gaza and return import restrictions to what they once were - no macaroni and no cars and no luxury goods to "improve the lives" of what is in essence a miniature Nazi Germany. Isreal should not make these peace gestures if the int'l community demanding them does not reciprocate to Israel - denouncing anti-peace activitiues of the "palestinians" they want cared for. Not in Israel's interest to tolerate this kind of one-sided diplomacy.
23. Peres Does recognize
Brazen   (12.14.10)
hamas as TERRORIST group wishing for the demise of Israel with its ANCIENT RICH history and thousands of years of inhabiting and conquring canaan.
24. number 8
pini   (12.14.10)
ya thats why its not called ishmaeleralum. oh wait no its derived from judah, like us jews, oh ya and we built it and were forced out of E Jerasulem by the shitty arab legion. Hmm how illogical of us.
25. War is needed
Brod ,   USA   (12.14.10)
What needed is war to defeat Israel's surrounding enemies for good. Talking about fake peace when their heart, mind and soul do not know peace is a waste of time. The 'peace' of the fanatical Islamist-Jiahdists is the usurpation of the Land of Israel. Israel should not be fooled into this kind of peace. It is a trap, a tactic to get Israel reduced into an indefensible enclave so that they can finish Israel at a later stage of time. The Land of Israel belongs to the Jewish Nation since ancient time. Usurping the Land of Israel has always been the goal of the Islamist-Jihadists since they sprouted like Locusts from the Bottomless Pit of the Arabian Desert in the 7th century. What Israel needs to do is kick out Mitchell and Blair from the Land of Israel. Let these scoundrels preach peace to the Islamist-Jihadists. It is doubtful if they will be successful. It is more probable that they will be beheaded by the Islamist-Jihadists. War is needed to settle the conflict for good. It should not be a long one. A quick one which is less then 6 days can do the job. It is time to get rid of Hamas and the PA usurpers. And if Hezbollah joins the fray, it is time to rid them too. The same with any of the surrounding belligerent states. The Free World is sick and tired of the Islamist-Jiahdist world. Israel should defend itself against its surrounding Islamist-Jihadist enemies hellbent on its destruction.
26. HOW TYPICAL
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (12.15.10)
They won't accept Israel, but want a state anyways within the 67 borders,. In your dreams!! You'll accept Israel or you will not have state, you stupid morons. But I'm thrilled you said it at the mass rally. It shows the world your true nature. Why Israel really doesn't have a partner in peace. Therefore no reason to continue the "peace" talks. Thanks, sucker. Please keep telling the world your true intentions, and it's not peace.
27. That is the basic foundation for any talks. RECIPROCAL
Harry Wright ,   UK   (12.15.10)
recognition. Without that, any "peace talks" is just spin. Giving them a state while they are at war with Israel is a recipe for disaster and a total farce. They are not ready for statehood. Such a difficult concept to understand!
28. Haniyeh says group won't recognize Israel
Galut ,   Selah   (12.15.10)
so Why should Israel recognize a palistinian state? ? Haniyeh only wants a foothold ..better stated a HUDNA for a future push to eliminate ISRAEL very disingenuinious !
29. I hope they never do
USA   (12.15.10)
Because Israel must never recognize Hamastinians.
30. Hamas
John ,   Sunbury USA   (12.15.10)
This is THE problem! If Hamas can not or will not recognize Israel than there will never be peace and the pals should not and will not have a Country! End of discussion. Construction is not the Issue.
Next talkbacks
Back to article