News
S. African politicians 'beaten up by IDF'
Ronen Medzini
Published: 17.12.10, 12:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
53 Talkbacks for this article
31. To: No. 27
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.17.10)
Hurling rocks is your idea of "being polite?" Are you delusional, or do you keep stepping in it just to amuse us? For your sake, I hope you're wearing hip waders. That would be a good thing.
32. #23 Roy - good post!
Schreiber   (12.17.10)
33. SA MPs Beaten Up -- Not Enough
izzie irgun ,   zion   (12.17.10)
As i see it given south africa's attitude towards Israel if all we did was gas and use stun grenades then it wasn't enough .. how about some good old fashion batton beatings and a couple of attack dogs. then sent these anti semites home so they can go praise terrorists and destroy whats left of the country that mandella built. if the Plaestinains had a mandella we would have had peace by now .. and if SA had mandella back we wouldn't be seeing or hearing people like tutu and this scum spreading a bunch of lies for propaganda purposes. He would have demanded the truth not these phony lies.
34. #28 thank you : )
Salma ,   Palestine   (12.17.10)
ants are so wonderful
35. They weren't carrying signs indicating govt immunity??
William ,   Israel   (12.17.10)
How silly of them to blend in with a crowd of people, many of them terrorist exploiting events like this for violence, and participate in a non-legal violent action in a foreign country. Interesting how they feel vindicated to participate in such activities against a fellow State, with consent from their home govt, then flash the diplomatic immunity card when this get tense. How about you take it on the road and see if immunity works for you in Tibet or Burma.
36. #7 - read wikileaks further. it also shows disgust
William ,   Israel   (12.17.10)
with "palestinians" and utter distrust in their intentions and goals. The cables also show Germany's strong devotion towards Israel and finally coming face to face with Muslim aggression in Europe and the failed integration/coexistence experiment.
37. #27 - the world does notice "Palestinian" violence
William ,   Israel   (12.17.10)
which is why, besides a few misguiding Leftists and NGOs, the world yawns at your claim of "IDF Brutality". I saw a great opinion poll in the US which showed a majority believe "Palestinians" are inherently violent and about 30% who consider you terrorists. Make sense since your idea of a "peaceful protest" is molotov cocktails and a sniper picking off civilians.
38. #34 - hey, maybe that's an idea for your new State
William ,   Israel   (12.17.10)
underground. I will donate 1,000 kg of sugar for your new hive.
39. #27 Wants the IDF to Serve Cookies to Anti Semites
izzie irgun ,   zion   (12.17.10)
Let me get this straight .. the people who kill women and children, fire rockets at school yards and ushered in a the age of terrorism wants politeness in return . ..and talk about politness, i never got a thank you for the chanukah card i sent to Hanyieah .. Salma, perhaps could you find out why since Palestinians value politenss so much
40. llegal SA "immigrants" without visas should be incarcerated
bernard ross ,   st anns bay jamaica   (12.17.10)
and deported
41. Did you know Mandela's Grandson is named "KHADAFI"
(12.17.10)
42. #40 allow South Africans to visit PA territory helps Israel
observer   (12.17.10)
they came with intention of proving that Israel doesn't ghettoize Palestinians. innocent!
43. then, no. 42, Israel MP's should support Afrikaner
better observer   (12.17.10)
Resistance Movement in South Africa. They arrived there in the 17th century, that is 200 years before the Bantu tribes that are now the majority started moving south from the Congo jungles because of jobs made available by the industrious Dutch Afrikaners. This gives them priority over the land and only the KoiKoi (Bushmen) have a longer history in that country but are still held in a state of Apartheid to this day by the Bantu government of black invaders. But do not bother to answer, your brain can only digest what suits your insane agenda.
44. Most South African MP's are just freeloading, corrupt, war l
Jonny ,   Cape Twon   (12.17.10)
Most South African MP's are just freeloading, corrupt, war lords, who try and steal everything that they can. Perhaps Israel should send some parliementarians to the townships to witness the "Non-Service delivery protests, and watch the police at work.
45. Trust me they were well paid to be "victims" of IDF "attack"
Alan ,   SA   (12.17.10)
As a South African I can tell all readers that there is a non stop littany of howls from "important" new SA big cheeses about some or other slight on them by some or other Israeli Body -be it ELAL or IDF or Mossad or something Israeli .Even a slab of Elite Dark Chocolate may be misconstrued as the manifestation of Israeli Racism This is a well paid activity .... Payment from some or other Muslim/Arab Fund. They are corrupt liars!
46. Salma, have you thought
Yossef   (12.18.10)
going to a therapist? I don't want to offend you, but spending so much time with people you hate is a sign of something going wrong. No ? When I read these talkbacks I am happy to share sometimes something with Rami or you -- not recently btw :( -- It makes me optimist that we may find a way, going to some same direction and meeting us somewhere. Kind of positive in this sea of negative. These people from South-Africa are far from their home, any other country would have send these people, first to jail and second in a plane back to SA. You know what? I'm thinking to boycott SA. I have been invited in SA next year, related to my job. I am wondering if I will finally want to go, maybe not. Why should I help people who come in my country to lecture me with such an arrogance.
47. #19 Not Blywen(thatsDutch) but Bleibt (thats Yiddish/German)
Alan ,   SA   (12.18.10)
48. S.A. on High Moral Ground?
Michael   (12.18.10)
As a South African I know what the government is all about. Since the Whites gave them back "their" country they have been the laughing stock of the world. People shouldn't pay any attention to what a black member of parliament says. They are all half doped anyway, and just look who they have as a President??? In S.A. the joke never ends!
49. Why dont you name the MPs...?
Russel ,   TLV   (12.18.10)
50. fake news from a country full of criminals who discriminate
rachel ,   usa   (12.18.10)
violently against immigrants from neighborting countries ....as if they did not have enough problems in southe africa , they need to mind their own business ....History will remember all this .
51. #38 hahah that was funny
rachel ,   usa   (12.18.10)
52. the clown @34
Moragh   (12.18.10)
You should know Salma... right?
53. You should know how foreign Africans are treated/beat in SA
(12.18.10)
Dont let these so called MPs tell stories.They are paid to create incidents with Israeli anythings in SA.The SA Muslims and Muslim States are showing them how to make money from demonising Jews and Israel there .They should stick to making their Millions in SA from Government Tenders-not crawling around Ramallah
Previous talkbacks
Back to article