Opinion
Clinton a danger to Israel
Moshe Dann
Published: 18.12.10, 18:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
31. Mr. Moshe Dann is correct, however
Marcella   (12.19.10)
(To Ynet: I have edited my previous submission of this talkback) ------------------------------------ Blaming only the USA for Israel's situation perpetuates the notion that Israelis are like Jews of the past, powerless and dependent on the lord's understanding and sense of fairness (if any) and compassion (if any), hoping that whatever he decides, it won't be too harsh on the Jews. That is reflected in the current Israeli policy of "salvaging what we can" from the US onslaught. This is not why the Jews re-established the state of Israel. Not for a condition of permanent servitude and powerlessness. The IDF is full of heroes but completely helpless as government after government submits to orders from abroad and surrenders Jewish land recovered thanks to the blood of thousands of Jewish fighters. The Israeli Foreign Ministry website says: "The final status of Judea and Samaria - determining the borders between Israel and the Palestinian state, and those parts of Judea and Samaria which are to be correspondingly under Israeli and Palestinian jurisdiction - is yet to be resolved and is currently the subject of negotiations between the Government of Israel and the Palestinian Authority." While that statement is inaccurate - there being no negotiations but a heavy-handed treatment imposed on the Jews of Israel - no amount of diplomatic cover and use of words such as "negotiations" and "peace" can cover up an outright fraud. Why blame just the State Department and the White House when the Israeli government has already agreed to the partition Jewish for the creation of another Arab state. ~~~~~~~~~~~ THE GREATEST DANGER TO ISRAEL is the attitude among some influential politicians that Israel is not a sovereign state on solid historical, legal and moral foundations - whose land is not to be handed over at the whim of foreign countries. Countries which, by the way, have been directly or indirectly implicated in the extermination of millions of Jews - if only by closing their doors to the victims. Israel needs to stop acting as a vassal state. Discussing conditions of surrender after a righteous victory is injurious to the Jewish spirit. Sanctions, criticism and pressure are nothing compared to the horrors Jews have been subjected to throughout history. The holiness of the land of Israel should override any concern with the opinion and the tantrums of foreign politicians. ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Israel is free. It may be under siege, but the Jews of Israel are free! No more submitting to extortion of Jewish land and heritage. The government must be made to understand that there cannot be any more surrender.
32. clinton israel
john orighoye ,   spain   (12.19.10)
peter said to the Lord i will die for you and the Lord told him before the cock crows two times you will deny me three times. and clinton said if iran attacked israel she would oblitrate iran even before iran was ready to attack israel clinton denied israel hundred and tweenty times.18/12/10
33. Hill
Michael,Canada   (12.19.10)
Surprise???What to be expected from this whore(spiritual at least)
34. #17 A 'fool', is one who speaks his entire mind.You are now
left dumb&'foolish' ,   Sorry bout your luck   (12.19.10)
35. Sigh-----I'm just surprised that it took this author this
long to figure that ,   out! Rueben,Israel   (12.19.10)
36. this piece of human garbage is a danger to her own country
chaim.s ,   brooklyn ny   (12.19.10)
this criminaly insane self hating traitor, is a bigger danger to her own country,
37. Smart guy #17...
Abie Dee ,   U.S.   (12.19.10)
So smart guy, what do you suggest that Israel do ? She has offered the Palestinians a state of their own on 93-96% of the west bank on 2 occasions, only to have the offers refused as insufficient. Their gov't in Gaza says it will never recognize a Jewish state.I believe that this is a first in history, where those who initiated wars and lost them, not only refuse any compromise but are now the ones making the demands. No country on this planet would put up with such nonsense.
38. #24: Good Morning, STONE.
Israeli 2   (12.19.10)
You are right, Stone. You are speaking to those who want Israel's demise. But you know what STONE? This is only in your dreams. In reality, you arer bitter because Israel is very strong, independent and proud of being the best in the world. Simply the BEST. My suggestion to you and people who dream like you is to let the Arabs know NEVER EVER try attacking Israel again because otherwise more territory would be coming over to Israel's possession which was hers to begin with anyway.
39. Her new Jewish son-in-law
oxo ,   USA   (12.19.10)
Hilary's new son-in-law should smack some sense into her.
40. You don't seem to understand that she is the AMERICAN SofS
Norman E. Fox ,   Minneapolis, USA   (12.19.10)
I am an American Jew that has always supported Israel, but lately some voices there are disgusting me. For example, statements that Obama is anti-semitic, or this rot about Hilary. Obama and Hilary work for America, not Israel. And though some of you think Israel is the only cause in the world ... it is not. Obama and Clinton are trying to find a solution that will work for everyone ... but they aren't necessarily going to dance your tune all the time .. and I wouldn't vote for them if they did.
41. Israel needs to downgrade it's relationship w/ USA
Adam ,   Los Angeles   (12.19.10)
Take it from someone who is an American; The United States is disintegrating economically and militarily from the world stage. This country's morals and ethics are decaying. It is in the best interest of Israel and other countries to stop relying on the US. This country does not serve the best interests of it's citizens and they the American government will not be there for it's allies either. The US government does not go to war for the right reasons but only to make money. That is what this country is all about - Not democracy or freedom but making money, serving the interests of big business and taking advantage of others. Israel should start standing on their own and stop relying on America so much.
42. The present US government is a threat to Israel !
Jaacov Baumann   (12.19.10)
Therefore, get back to stand on your own feet ! The close relationship with the US could turn into deadly hostility within the twinkle of an eye ! By then, Israel should have pulled its trousers up again !
43. Watch Clinton together with the USA disappear soon......
Jaacov Baumann   (12.19.10)
The present US government is a curse for Israel ( and its own nation ! ) and therefore will be removed by Israels God - just wait and see ! '' He who curses Israel will be cursed !''
44. when suhah arafat accused the jews of poisoning palestinian
gale fishman ,   boston, ma usa   (12.19.10)
children, ms. clinton stood there, next to ms. arafat, without any reaction, and when ms. arafat finished her anti-semitic speech clinton applauded her, hugged her and kissed her. i am yet to hear an apology from ms. clinton to the jewish people for this support she handed to one of israel and the jewish people's most venomous enemies. and in the absent of such an apology, it is clear where clinton heart, in addition to her mind, stand towards the Jewish people and its national home of israel: shoulder to shoulder with her boss, b.h.obama.
45. Hillary raised in anti Israel Church
David Aarons ,   Jerusalem Israel   (12.19.10)
Hillary was raised in the Methodist Church one of the most vicious harbingers of ill will towards the Jewish faith Sadly Israel allows their church to bring thousands of tourists here to hear lectures by the anti semitic Sabeel Organization and others that call for the dismemberment of the State of Israel .
46. Two notes
Alexandre Chinovich   (12.19.10)
1st: US political system resembles hidden monarchy or family business: Kennedy after Kennedy, Bush after Bush, Clinton after Clinton. You may see Obama after Obama in 2020 . Silence, North Korea! 2nd: Many years ago Soviet leader J.Stalin said about Lenin's wife, Nadezhda Krupskaya: "Leninism is not transferred thru bed". Yes, Mr. Clinton was a wise man...
47. Hell hath no fury
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (12.19.10)
When she agreed to "stand by her man" after the Lewinsky incident, Hilary lost her honor, her self-respect and her chances to be president. Hilary wants revenge, and Lewinksy is Jewish.
48. suha arafat's $18million pa stipend
martin ,   uk   (12.19.10)
yes, this is how much the paedophilic arafart's widow receives from abbas. so how much does the p.a. have in their accounts? the u.s. state dept (no friend of israel) questionned the missing billions of tax payers dollars back in the '90s. the hateful clinton shares her jew hatred with her friends hezbullah, hamas and the PA. what else do you expect from this peroxided ugly bitch, only bettered by helen thomas?
49. new wikileak disproves much of this article
(12.19.10)
50. clinton Israel's enemy!
ed ,   reno, america   (12.19.10)
hillar as obamas mouthpeice is totally anti Israel. obama's puppet mothpeice continues to profess americas friendship with Israel while at the same time making it clear that what they really want will ultimately result in Israel's annihilation. the hypocrasy of america did not need wikileaks to show itself. but unfortunately to many americans cover their eyes and ears so they can't see or hear the truth. i personally do not concone or back the anti israel stance of obamas administration!!!!
51. Marcella #31, you are right, but.....
Steve   (12.19.10)
I essentially agree with what you have written. The lion's share of the blame lies with Israel's weak leaders. However, so long as Israel is dependent upon the United States for military aid, to one degree or another she will feel beholden and the US will exercise influence over her. That is the reason for American aid in the first instance. It buys influence; often immoral influence. That is why I have advocated, for many years now, Israel should wean herself off American aid and dependency; becoming as self-sufficient as is humanly possible. Because Israel's leaders deserve the lion's share of the blame for capitulating to immoral American pressure, this by no means absolves the United States of guilt. I hope that is not what you are suggesting.
52. #51 - Steve
Marcella   (12.19.10)
I'm realistic and I know that Israel cannot exist without alliances. The US - in spite of its dreadful history of betrayal of allies (not only Israel BTW) - is for the time being the best choice among bad choices. Granted that, Steve, don't you just cringe when you read how the US treats the country and its leaders? This is not an alliance, this is a master-vassal relationship and something must be done to change that! There seem to be no lines they haven't crossed. Or tried to. The subject of "regime change" has surfaced for quite some time now and we see US officials meeting separately with the opposition, with Ehud Barak, with the military! (see my TB 22) The country must establish diplomatic boundaries with its "ally". It must show self-respect. It must make every effort to become militarily self-sufficient, even at the cost of irritating its masters. I'm so disgusted, I had my first TB censored yesterday. So I should stop now.
53. Marcella: Censored Talkbacks
Steve   (12.19.10)
This is my view. As Mr. Dann implied in this piece but did not state explicitly, Mr. Obama and Ms. Clinton are evil. I've not seen such a dangerous US president in my almost 58 years on this planet. I know that is a harsh point of view but it is true. Obama has done a great deal of damage to the US already. That having been said, George W. Bush, for whom I voted in 2000, said and did some unconscionable things toward Israel. Bush repeatedly lied about Israel "illegally" occupying Muslim land. He lied about the enemy, laying the groundwork for the rise of President B. Hussein whose sympathies are with America's enemies in my opinion. I agree Israel, at present, needs state of the art US weapons, but let us not forget, Israel was on the verge of producing her own jet fighter, the Lavi. The US pressured her to forgo the project. America may inadvertantly force Israel into acquiring more land and resources. She should not have given up the Sinai. You don't give up strategic land that has been conquered. The US has internalized this lesson. The point is, the US wants to keep Israel on a short leash. Truth be known, what America has been trying to bring about in Israel borders on seeking Israel's destruction; like John Loftus and Mark Aarons' book, "The Secret War Against the Jews." That is why I would look to America as a "feigned" ally at best. Israel is a powerful military and nuclear presence in the region.
54. #13 Your premise is wrong...The territory is disputed
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (12.19.10)
55. Mark: I believe the territory is not in dispute
Steve   (12.19.10)
The Jews have clear title to this land. I know this idea of "disputed" territory is a popular one, yet it only leaves the door open for Israel-haters to apply further immoral pressure. The land belongs to the Jews by right.
56. Steve, the territory is occupied, therefore...
Persian CAT   (12.19.10)
it's stolen. I am not sure where the "Jews" got the so-called "title"? From Ariel Sharon and the gangs of Zionist land grabbers?! In that case you have no moral nor legal legs to stand on.
57. The Obama regime is evil and must be dealt with as such.
Chaim ,   Israel   (12.20.10)
Dann is right on target in his analysis of Clinton and the Obama regime. It is not naive. It is not misguided. It is plain evil. It's desire is to see Israel's bloodthirsty enemies defeat Israel, or atleast render Israel completely helpless. We must deal with the Obama regime for what it is - evil. We have many many millions of American friends, with whom we should work with. But never capitulate to or trust the Obama regime.
58. P. Cat: Our title is in the Bible.
Steve   (12.20.10)
We stand on the word of the Almighty. What do you stand on?
59. ISRAEL HAS NEVER EVER STOLEN LANDS
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (12.20.10)
In all her 4000 year history. Muslims have stolen every land they occupy. The regime states, and Pakistan, created 100 years ago are based on fictional borders, fictional history., corruption and robbery - in secret, with no nations voting as with Israel.
60. #58. Steve, thank for the info. I did not know...
Persian CAT   (12.20.10)
"The Almighty" was also a real estate agent!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article