News
Lieberman depicts doctrine to Newsweek
Ynet
Published: 23.12.10, 08:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. #13 - All of Israels neighbors for a start
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (12.23.10)
You seem to forget that - All of the Arab countries forced their Jewish populations to leave when Israel was established and then attacked by those same countries. - for peace with Egypt Israel had to uproot people. - for peace with Palestine Israel uprooted the communities of Gaza and have gotten 1000 attacks per years since. - Abbas will only discuss a peace deal where Israel removes all Jews from their land in the west bank, even if it was theirs under the Ottomans. And on top of that Israel is letting them keep their homes, businesses, money, etc. unlike what was done when the Jews were forced to flee Spain, England, Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, etc.
32. Lieberman doing more for PA cause then Abbas
Ezra ,   UK   (12.23.10)
Thank you
33. Israeli-Arabs do want to integrate
Rami of nAzareth ,   Israel   (12.23.10)
It is the consecutive israeli governments who refused integration and workes to keep israeli-arabs as 2nd class citizens
34. # 14 Very well said
clear   (12.23.10)
35. Gaza is the new State of Palestine !
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (12.23.10)
The time is right to annex Judea and Samaria.
36. All Israeli citizens have rights
Ilan ,   Ariel   (12.23.10)
You can't force people to decide between their homes, homeland, and national identity. Too bad that the High Court let this criminal behavior be applied to Israeli citizens in Gush Katif. While I'm sure that the HC will not let Israeli Arabs get disenfranchised will the Israeli Left support democracy towards Israelis in Judea and Samaria?
37. #14 You don't refuse to blow yourselves up, you mean
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (12.23.10)
38. Re #13
Andrew Brehm   (12.23.10)
That would be the kind of democracy that rules over people who don't want to be part of the democracy. His solution is about land transfer not population transfer so I'm not sure where you are getting "wholesale dislocation of peoples and families". And what's that comparison with dislocation and Hitler? Are you under the impression that Hitler became famous for dislocating people? Jews would have been happy to be dislocated rather than killed. I see no problem with dislocation. (And neither did the Arabs when they expelled their Jewish populations.)
39. Re #14
Andrew Brehm   (12.23.10)
"Have you asked yourself why Arabs are denied jobs in EL AL, and many other Israeli companies? Is it because we refuse to kill our fellow Palestinians, or fellow Arabs in neighboring states?" Obviously. Didn't you know that EL AL pilots are required to kill a Palestinian before they are allowed to start?
40. #13 Tony from LA
David ,   America   (12.23.10)
Rich coming from an LA boy. You wouldn't know a democracy if it bit you on the arse. What kind of democracy expel the Mexicans from their land? What kind of democracy wipes out the Native American population? What kind of democracy inslaves an entire race of people? Give me a Break!!!!! And for your information, The USA is not, nor has ever been a democracy. It was a constitutional republic, but now it is an enslaved people once again. Enslaved by the Bilderburgers and their ilk! I could go on for hours but you aren't worth it.
41. Salma and Nour from "Palestine"
David ,   Haifa Israel   (12.23.10)
the state that never existed and never will!! GET OUT!!! GO HOME TO JORDAN OR EGYPT!!! You "people" are nothing but sub humans and terrorists
42. for a russian
pini   (12.23.10)
leiberman is the smartest israeli on knesset. I vote for him as primeminister.
43. first off
pini ,   usrael   (12.23.10)
why do so many of the pallys who come on here to comment sound so damn unintelligent? Secondly whats all this "its our land" crap, who cares about the bible simple matter is WE OWN IT NOW AND YOU CAN JUMP UP AND DOWN ALL YOU WANT. OURS OURS OURS, hah hah hah
44. Lieberman is full of ideas problem is nobody takes him serio
Dan   (12.23.10)
Next elections he has 5 mandates.
45. nour @ 9
Moragh   (12.23.10)
Yep, that is the only kind of remark one can expect from Nour. Better ignored. He is a non-entity and a bitter ugly hearted nincompoop!
46. Lieberman's horrid plan could have come from Meretz.
Chaim ,   Israel   (12.23.10)
Patriotic Israel wake up! Lieberman is proposing giving away large segments of our tiny Homeland to "Palestinian" poseurs. This horrid plan could have come from Meretz. Yet many insist on viewing Lieberman as a rightist. Lieberman's honesty is refreshing but he is definitely not the person Patriotic Israel should choose as a leader. Do we really want ANOTHER P.M., taking patriotic rightist votes to implement disastrous leftist policies?
47. Lieberman, Assange, Wilders
Anna ,   Canada   (12.23.10)
They are all politically incorrect. But they are correct in all means.
48. All US jews vote for Lieberman. Long live.
Isaac ,   USA   (12.23.10)
49. Rami
Anna ,   Canada   (12.23.10)
I fully agree with your anger. The problem is a big deal for loyal and honest non-Jews in Israel because Jews don't trust Arabs in general. And if you read comments that are coming from Salma, Nour and Amir, you have to understand why. Problem with integration into the foreign society exists in every country no matter how liberal are the laws. We live in a tough time but there is always an opportunity. I wish you to meet yours.
50. I'd love to see him as PM too!
Ali ,   Scotland   (12.24.10)
This man could only help us.He would reveal too much of Israels racism and lose the veto
51. Lieberman: "or he [Arab] can move to Israel"
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (12.26.10)
That's the problem with Lieberman's population plan. Most of Israel's Arabs, faced with the prospect of coming under Palestinian authority, will move to the "Jewish" part of Israel, thus losing the land but keeping their population. We've already seen this process in Jerusalem.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article