Opinion
Academy of hatred
Ziv Lenchner
Published: 25.12.10, 14:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
1. silent? I know of no Israeli who is ever silent
(12.25.10)
I do not think I have ever known of any Israeli who has ever been silent about anything.
2. Academy of hatred?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.25.10)
Where do I enroll?
3. DAYS OF YORE
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (12.25.10)
I remember the time that we could walk in the streets at all hours of the day or night, without fear of being robbed or molested We now have illegals that are quite willing to injure and harm us on a 24/7/365 basis
4. Real racists
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (12.25.10)
'They walk our streets, shop at our malls, and try to woo our women, thereby apparently tainting our race' How many Israeli young men cruise Arab villages looking for for Arab Damsels.What would happen if to the Arab Damsel if her family found out she was hitched up with an Israeli young man?she would be killed or not allowed to ever leave her house.In many ways Israeli leftists are blind to racism on the Arab side.Maybe the leftist really see the Arabs as backward children whose social norms are uncivilized ,tribal and backward.I think the left qualifies as racist.
5. WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE?
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (12.25.10)
Between an egg and good old-fashioned hatred ? You can beat an egg but you can't beat some good old-fashioned hatred.
6. There are so few of us Jews left.
noa ,   israel   (12.25.10)
You are right, why should we let the bad ones besmirch our good name.
7. Shame
David   (12.25.10)
This growing tide of racism shames all of us, shames the memory of the victims of the Holocaust (whose suffering was the consequence of similar bigotry) and shames the memory of all of those who laid down their lives to establish then defend the State of Israel. Silence is not an option.
8. Nastiest Demonization of Jews I've seen in this generation
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (12.25.10)
Confirms that Left's Liberals are losing and really desperate.
9. Silence is not golden
Norman Gellman ,   Rehovot   (12.25.10)
The Torah reminds us many times that as we were strangers in Egypt we should treat strangers with kindness. The far right and supposedly religious people seem to have forgotten how we are supposed to treat strangers. The real problem is their violent actions against strangers is not only ant-Torah but endangers all of Israel. If we sit quietly by and do nothing this will only embolden these radicals to move on more restrictions on other aspects of Israeli life and lead us in to an ultra orthodox theocracy. We must not remain silent on this issue and counter their actions to preserve our democratic state. We should also puch for the separation of politics & religion.
10. Israel in moral crisis...now its racism
Shmuel ,   Billings USA   (12.25.10)
just another sign that Israel needs to return to what it is about...a nation under YWH...until then it is going to keep eroding into dust and ashes...many Israelis are fed up and leaving to America...repent Israel...now you are in bed with the devil Russia in arms dealing...what is next???
11. #2 Sarah B.
Zionist Forever ,   New York City   (12.25.10)
I almost never respond to articles in Ynet but I felt inclined to respond to this one. I am a 27 year old Jewish photographer in New York City. I have proudly led 5 Birthright trips to Israel over the last 4 years and after college I spent an year volunteering in schools throughout Israel teaching english. I have never been ashamed of how Israel has protected itself over the years from terrorists and people out to hurt Israel...but I am ashamed now. How can we as a people, who only 70 years ago were being attacked for only being Jewish, stomach Jews attacking Muslims for only being Muslim? Those Muslims who are out to hurt us deserve to be arrested and thrown in prison. But thats not who we are talking about here. We are talking about Muslim men and women who are just trying to live their lives, like their Jewish neighbors. Sarah B. you want to sign up for an Academy of hate? You are no better than those who persecuted us 70 years ago in Germany. I hope this is a phase. I hope this passes and Israel continues to be a pluralistic society...but I fear for my people if this racism and hate isn't stopped soon.
12. to Sarah B
R Coyner ,   usa   (12.25.10)
After reading your posts here, you don't have to enroll in the academy, you graduated with top honors long ago. Fortunately, there are still very few in Israel such as yourself who believe in racism and apartheid.
13. Search this writer's archive. All about defending Arabs
Howard K   (12.25.10)
And all against the Jews. We don't know what his attachment is all about, but one would expect him to be at least a little bit concerned about the plight of the Jews in a sea of hostile neighbors. Not so. Sample of his latest columns on Ynet: - Insulting our Arab Friends - Mixing Arts and Politics - against introducing prize for Zionist art - A test we cannot fail - against lawbreaking settlers. It's hard to take someone seriously if he chooses to repeat Arab propaganda without any attempt to think for himself. He is still a Jew, and as a Jew he is not wanted by the Arabs in the land of Israel.
14. Jewish Brownshirts Signal The Coming Downfall Of Israel
World Citizen ,   the world   (12.25.10)
It is only a matter of time. This sort of racial hatred is always turned inward over the long haul. Israel will destroy itself with hatred, just like NAZI Germany.
15. #6...what good name.? The world has always known the Jew!
Edithann ,   USA   (12.25.10)
They just found 20% more Jews in the US ...where were they hiding? I always said there were more Jews on the planet then anyone realized... or else how could they be into 'everything'! Maybe that's been the game plan all along... Isn't there something like 'BY WAY OF DECEPTION WE SHALL WAGE PERPETURAL WAR ON THE GOY? TATA
16. if you want ....
martine ,   ashdod   (12.25.10)
Mr Lenchner, we can show you what your arabs friends do to our young girls who are not enough suspicious. You'll see if they deserve your friendship. Or if you have a young girl at the age or 14 to 16, tell her to date one of them and you'll see the result with your own eyes. Then you won't write the same insanities against the religious people. Without Torah, Israël wouldn't be the country that you know. You don't understand where is the right interest.
17. 9 Norm: Right, but "courtesy of the radical, inciting Right"
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (12.25.10)
I'm dati leumi and these thugs are thugs, not my heros. But... Smearing religious Jews ("radical, inciting Right") as: "landscapers of evil " "spell of its malignant inspiration" Painting religious Jews as considering Arabs: "monsters " "apparently tainting our race" and painting religious Jews as considering these thugs: "You're our heroes" It's leftist demonization of religious Jews. Haven't see that level of vicious demonization against religious Jews ("radical, inciting Right") since... Indeed, silence of dati leumi is extremely inappropriate in the face of this vicious attack attempting to blameshift and paint the entirety of dati Jews black. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer & Orthodox Jew: Teimani, Baladi, Dor Dai Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming all who choose to keep Torah (When questions to me go unanswered, ynet has refused to post it. Ck our Web Café at www.netzarim.co.il)
18. Ynet's Ignorance about Jewish History
American Sabrah ,   Givas Shmilkeh   (12.25.10)
You want to know what racism is? Look at the xenophobic crap you post on this website. You foment the same racism and bigotry you accuse us for.You are the same people who hate and discriminate Olim like me who sacrificed everything in the US to settle here. Try showing some tolerance towards us and people who want to protect the State of Israel rather than sympathize with the Devil that wants to obliterate you from the face of this planet and take over the Middle East. Just a couple articles ago, you posted that Abbas is denying entry to Israelis in PA territory.But the Rabbis who care about the well being of the Jewish people are far worse than those who want to reduce us to shwarma meat. I suggest you do some reading about Jewish History in your own spare time and concentrate on the Jewish communities that were once in the Arab world. Then you will know what racism and xenophobia truly is.
19. 8 - coming from the king of beraring jews, that's rich
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (12.25.10)
i've never in my life seen anyone berate jews like you do. sure you spare your sharpest words for non-jews (how ironic for you) but anti-semites could get good lessons from your talkbacks. sheesh.
20. Whatever your opinion
Ari   (12.25.10)
This article is written as if authored by a talkbacker. Completely unprofessional and overtly vitriolic material such as this would never be allowed anywhere other than YNet and perhaps Haaretz
21. Both Shame and Tragedy. Read #3, #9, #11
Solomon ,   Bklyn   (12.25.10)
REread #3, #9, #11. Have you others never heard of "two wrongs don't make a right"? Have you no idea of what is the basis of Judaism: Do NOT do unto others as you would not want done to you? Hillel: "That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. That is the whole Torah; the rest is the explanation; go and learn." No matter where one lives, it should be obvious that this kind of prejudice is not Judaism. Shame on all of us.
22. #11 Zionist Forever - easy to say that from NYC
Howard K   (12.25.10)
You have no idea what's like to live with Arabs 24/7. Some Jews have to contend with harassment and even danger to their lives because of their Arab neighbors. Perhaps being on the side of "tolerance" makes you feel righteous and that's always a good feeling. But try to see it from the Jewish perspective for a moment. Just a regular family, mom, dad, daughters wanting to live as Jews in a Jewish country. The true reality is not what you imagine at all or what you saw during your visits. Israel is a very complex society. You may live there for years and still not know what goes on in another neighborhood. Jews do not discriminate unless they are threatened. That's not racism or discrimiination. It's a pure sense of survival.
23. to Sara B 2
suran ,   jerusalem   (12.25.10)
in hatered not academy .... hahaha
24. What is racism?
Tejas ,   India   (12.25.10)
I am really confused. Can someone elaborate the the term 'racism'? Is this term exclusive to Jewish people or it can be used for other human beings also. Jews who are accusing other Jews of being racist should go and live in any Arab country. They will realize what racism is exactly. I don't know where this breed of self shunning liberals come from. They need to realize that their short sighted personal and political objectives will destroy Israel.
25. #21 Solomon - Bklyn
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (12.25.10)
Yes, I've heard of it !! However, the problem is that you're in Brooklyn, j ust talking about it, I'm in Israel experiencing it Understand the difference ? Set an example, don't lock your house or car doors, to show how opened minded you are
26. to 22
(12.25.10)
it is sense of pure survival or survival of pure sense but never never a pure sense of anything becouse pure sense is a great optioh greater than any thing
27. just wondering...
marcy ,   jerusalem   (12.25.10)
why is it that hatred and racism between arabs and jews bothers us so much and we cant's remain quiet as the auther writes, yet the hatred and racism amongst the jews themselves (i.e. haraidi vs chiloni etc) gets completely ignored or even worse encouraged by the media
28. Timing
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (12.25.10)
Strange, isn't it? After Abbas refused to go back to negotiations, the press is suddenly filled with stories how Israel is a racist country, yet ignores the real racists of Fatah/Hamas. This is a coordinated attack to delegitimize and isolate Israel in preparation for the coming war.
29. #25 Ben Jabo
Solomon ,   Bklyn   (12.26.10)
I have lived in Israel in Jerusalem. The problem is being afraid of the unknown; of the 'other'. You'll tell me you know arabs, all arabs. I will tell you look in a mirror and think back what was said to us and done to us as a result of those words, those kind of feelings. I stand by my previous post.
30. You dummies fell hook line and sinker for fake post #2.
Tahl ,   Ashdod   (12.26.10)
You people must really be unbelievably gullible to believe #2 is the real Sarah B. Our Sarah has an unparalleled command of English, a nearly infinite knowledge of world affairs and the law, and an amazingly razor-sharp humor - all of which makes her at least 10 leagues above anyone else in here. This makes it very easy to spot her impostors. Obviously, the dolt who wrote #2 with the purpose of making her look bad, would never be able to match her in a head-to-head debate, so resorted to this cheap cowardly impostoring tactic. The real Sarah would never write such idiocy.
Next talkbacks
Back to article