Jewish Scene
Addis Ababa Jews see no quick route to promised land
Reuters
Published: 08.01.11, 10:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
10 Talkbacks for this article
1. They are born jews NO NEED FOR CONVERSION ...
benjamin ,   singapore   (01.08.11)
These israelites are taken for a RIDE ! The whole idea is jews want to dominate other jews. The citron come in many shapes and colors ;-) ben singapore
2. 1 week after arrival they are ina church
"Jews"TilTheyGetHere ,   china and israel   (01.08.11)
The overwhelming majority of Ethiopian Jews" throw away their tefillin and talit withing a year very few remain as "devout" as the photos show here. The whole thing is a fiasco most Israelis now know it.They are used for propaganda purposes to fill the army and strengthen the secular voting public.
3. WoW stop SCOLDING ME- received many emails...
benjamin ,   singapore   (01.08.11)
my opinion is that, if those ethiopians are xtians and jews by birth- the net conclusion is they are not within orthodox judaism.....as such their conversion by the idf rabbis is NOT VALID ! They may be jews by birth but qualified to have professed another religion that is not JEWISH OR ORTHODOX ! I am NOT SORRY AT ALL TO NOT RECOGNISE THEIR CONVERSIONs. To me they are not of the HOUSE of JACOB ! Never the less if they have served or serving in the iDF they may qualify for the citizen ship of Israel under the laws of the Nation Israel my application and imigration laws. If Mr. j is their God, there is no way they belong to us- Jews of Israel or jews of the diasporawithin the House of Jacob ! The ethipioans may go their ways, but we Jews only have ONE SINGULAR G-D- the Lrd G-d of Yisrael that called us among mnay nations to keep the 10 laws- 613 commandments to UPHOLD the law even thought it is burdensome but a joyful burden and a honorable demand. benjamin singapore
4. ABUSE OF JUDAISM
BENJAMIN ,   SINGAPORE   (01.08.11)
IT IS a trend now days that many have taken UNDUE ADVANTGE OF THE IDF and the RELIGION JUDAISM to get the citizenship of Israel that comes with mnay BENEFITS. CLEARLY those take CONVERSIONS AS A WAY TO GAIN ENTRY IS CLEARLY NOT WITHIN MY FAMILY BUT MAY ONLY BE OUR FRIENDS ! NEVER THE LESS WE JEWS SHOULD NOT TURN DOWN ASYLUM SEEKERS WHO COME TO US TO SEE REFUGE ! bUT THERE ARE LIMITS TO THOSE ASYLUM SEEKERS- THAT IS TO QUALIFY- IF THEY ARE ECONOMIC REFUGEES IT IS A DOUBLE NEGATIVE TO THEM ON ISSUES OF CITIZENSHIP. TELL THEN NOT TO ABUSE ISRAEL OR TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE SYSTEM ! WE NEED TO TAKE CARE OF OUR CHILDREN ON THE FIRST TOP PRIORITY BUT NOT THE ECONOMIC REFUGEES, PLEASE BEN SINGAPORE
5. The photo shows an error is putting tefilan on the left hand
Moshe ,   Usa   (01.08.11)
There is no shin made. These Jews may be a fraud. Moshe
6. If still pray to Jesus, they are where they belong. No Aliya
Josh   (01.08.11)
If they do not pray to Jesus, and are committed to Torah, we need more people in the land who do it. Maybe we can swap the heathens and thieves in the land who don kippahs pretending the care about Torah yet trample it, one for one. The kind that mistreats converts or act racist towards those who are committed by their oaths to G-d. Nothing would set a heathen straight faster than to walk a mile in the Falsa Mura shoes. Keep sinning and we may all be walking in disporah.
7. # 5 Moshe
Yerach ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (01.08.11)
FYI,Not everybody makes a shin on the hand when wrapping tefilin. Sephardim & Eidot HaMizrach make something that looks like railraod tracks & Chabad makes a shin on the bicep,a dalet on the hand & a yood on the middle finger. There are several other variations as well. Whether theese people are Jews are not that is up to the rabbanim to rule on.
8. 5. Tefillin
Mordechai ,   Manchester, UK   (01.09.11)
The letter shin made on the hand with the tefillin strap is only one of several customs. Not all Jews are Askenazim...
9. Double standards
C. Bendavid ,   France   (01.09.11)
Even though many of them are not Halakhik jews, Russian Jews were allowed in Israel without any restrictions. I don't see why it should be different for Ethiopian Jews. Even if some people pretend to be Jewish to move to Israel, penalizing the others is just unfair. I'd chose to welcome all of them (even the "fake'' Falash Muras) rather than penalizing all of them for few abuses.
10. future welfare reciepients?
moriah ,   sacramento usa   (01.13.11)
Back to article