News
Video: Settlers, Arabs in war of stones
Yair Altman
Published: 03.01.11, 20:53
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. Of course it was a publicity stunt!
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.03.11)
Because don't you just always venture outside with your video equipment? Yeah, right. The "Palestinians" really need to get new scriptwriters. This stuff is old and tired. "Very concerned for [his] family." Maybe he should expend a little concern for his straying cattle, eh?
2. HOW CRUDE, PALYWOOD again
Eran ,   Singapore   (01.03.11)
3. Sarah B always the Isracist apologist
LEON   (01.03.11)
Areas in the Occupied West Bank where video equipment has been distributed has seen a well documented decrease in settler attacks on Palestinians. The filming started after the incident started so what are you saying - documenting settler attacks isn't playing fair and is just a stunt?
4. Allahu Akbar?
Dan ,   Florida   (01.03.11)
Can the screaming Arab girl really believe that God is involved in a stone throwing riot. Is there any Palestinian with an IQ greater than room temerature?
5. the women who filmed from inside the house sounded
eporue ,   europe   (01.03.11)
really scared... when masked guys show up at your door, throwing stones, and armed they are anyway, i would be scared too...
6. yes i was there
rashid ,   palistinian   (01.03.11)
and i am happy to report that according the norwiginland tv and press tv from iran it was the israil what got stoned believe me i never get stoned even though my english is not very good believe me
7. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.03.11)
Seems a bit suspicious to show up at an event with video camera in hand. But the Arabs have a history of doing precisely that. It comes as no surprise. Did you read the story about the woman who supposedly died as a result of inhaling tear gas who turns out to have died of very different causes? Hmmm. Arabs and truth. Oxymoronic.
8. #6 Rashid
Malone ,   Hfx   (01.03.11)
Too funny,as usual...
9. SCREAM!!!
Yaniv ,   US   (01.03.11)
Well that was the most annoying voice ever...this probably wasnt the first time this thing has happened for two reasons, one who carries video cameras everywhere they go and two the reason why they brought cameras is because it has happened before, and so if he is afraid of his wife and kids instead of going and trying to film his house getting hit by stones (they were inside and as the video depicts their windows were bared very nicely) then the shepherds shouldn't instigate
10. # 5
(01.03.11)
tell me exactly where you live young man ?
11. :: Oh look at that...
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (01.04.11)
...illegal settlers throwing stones. Yet some Ynuts squeal 'Pallywood' and 'publicity stunt' because they deny plain facts when it doesn't suit them to acknowledge reality. How sad it that?
12. #1 Sarah B. - anyone can videotape
Yakov ,   USA   (01.04.11)
The woman may have been standing in her own house. Many people have the opinion that palestinians living in the west are very poor or primitive and cannot/do not use them for anything other than propaganda. However, we live in the 21st century--look on youtube---people in all countries have videocameras, and anyone will film just about anything. I am sure Sarah B owns a video camera/digital camera and has probably posted a video on youtube, so there is no reason to believe that someone living in the west bank cannot so the same.
13. PALISTINIAN STONES
LT COL HOWARD ,   WASHINGTON DC USA   (01.04.11)
I attempted to copy photographs of the Palestinians in the same engagement throwing rocks… But I failed to be able to reproduce them and transmit them to you. However, their numbers and viciousness seem to exceed any excesses that might be demonstrated by the Israelis throwing stones.
14. @5 WHy do you ask this dumb question?
Roy ,   Miami   (01.04.11)
If this is a threat, dont be ashamed to put your name.
15. Sarah B., does B stand for Blind?
Chris ,   NYC   (01.04.11)
The article says the video was taken from INSIDE THE HOUSE and one can clearly see the WINDOW FRAMES. Are you stupid or just a big LIER?
16. #6 Rashid - You do sound like you're stoned
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.04.11)
You really should look up the other meanings for that word, one of them being inerbriated I never believe ANYONE that say's "Believe Me", he usually turns out to be either a conman or a liar
17. LOL - This got our whole office laughing...
Dan S. ,   USA   (01.04.11)
This is what happens when there is no real work to do.. Shepherds - LOL, I'm sure they are, but in any industrialized country the herding of livestock is done in a much more efficient and straightforward manner. The fact that all these people on both sides could call up their friends as reinforcements like a bunch of kids in high school shows that people there need real work to do. If it snowed over there ever, I guess it would be a snowball fight.
18. Throwing stones at eachother? Big deal
Cameron ,   USA   (01.04.11)
Kids do the same routine, and tend to do it better. Now when both Jews & Arabs were ripping up olive groves, then we had some true ME, fanatical nutter drama. Now that is the kind of dramatic, ME "blood & soil" crazy we in the wider world view with interest.
19. #7
gil ,   us   (01.04.11)
she was terrorist scum in your post of yesterday so if she was not there was she potential terrorist scum
20. What's the point? Palestinians are upset?
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (01.04.11)
I don't understand the point of the article. Why is it news that Palestinians are unhappy that Israelis throw rocks at them? Duh? Palestinians have been throwing rocks at Israelis for decades and it has never been an issue at all with human rights organizations. A woman in my town had her skull broken two years ago by a "brave" Palestinian "resister" who is now in jail and will sit there for years to come for attempted murder. Why are the Palestinians complaining? That the Jews have better aim then them? That they don't like getting rocks thrown at them? They should be thankful it's just rocks, and not the other Palestinian favorite: flaming gasoline bombs (molotov cocktails).
21. Stupid settlers !!!
Ibn Musa ,   The World   (01.05.11)
Just as soon as the Palestinian's threw rocks, the settlers should have used their guns, it's more efficient and requires less sweat
22. #11 Matty - They're not illegal setlers
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.05.11)
They are Jews living in their home and on the land of their ancestors Check your facts (LOL), there's no mention whatever of Arabs or Palestinian's in any bible of your choice On the other hand, Israel, Judea and Jews are mentioned hundreds of times As a matter of fact, you can't find a single mention of Jerusalem in the Koran You are the one that requires a reality check !!
Back to article