MK Ben-Ari: Eradicate treacherous leftists
Roni Sofer, Yair Altman
Published: 05.01.11, 23:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
123 Talkbacks for this article
1. eradication
Michael ,   Haifa   (01.05.11)
how are you going to do it, Ben-Ari ? Set up concentration camps ? Pay a visit to Yad Vashem to study the techniques.
2. Funding for NGOs
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (01.05.11)
All NGOs need to disclose their funding sources, regardless of leftist, rightist or centralist. If foreign governments are funding any organizations here then we need to know who it is, how much they are funding it and demand an explanation from the donor country why they are doing this. NGO is suppose to mean NON-Government Organization. If a foreign government is funding it, then it is not a NGO.
Israeli 2   (01.05.11)
This is only the beginnining of one SMALL step in the RIGHT direction.
4. Ben Ari RIGHT, Ynet, opponents, left-wing traitors are WRONG
FG   (01.06.11)
5. What has happened to Israeli democracy?
John R ,   NYC USA   (01.06.11)
There are 162 countries in the world that recognize Israel. None of them maintain an embassy in Jerusalem because they believe its annexation is illegal. Every one them says Israeli WB settlements violate the Geneva Convention and are Illegal.The World Court says this. Even the President of the US said this in a recent UN speech. There are countless UN resolutions that say Israel is violating the Geneva Convention as it applies to Palestinian human rights. In Gaza, Israel actually rationed food, water ,electricity and countless non-military goods. In the WB ,500,000 Israeli settlers use more water than the 2.4 million Palestinians living there under the equivalent of water rationing. A host of human rights organizations and Israel's own government confirm this. The leftist organizations that Mr. Ben-Ari is saying are traitors are simply saying the same thing as the rest of the world. Will he next suggest Israel cut off diplomatic relations with all these countries because they are trying to destroy Israel? If they were, they would impose a strict economic embargo but they have not. The people of Israel are capable of reading and listening to all sides of this issue and making up their own mind as to what the truth is. Israel has lasted more than sixty years in that environment without Mr Ben Ari's attempt to silence or constrain the very democratic ideals which Israel was founded on, There are many countries in the world who silence their opposition because they don't like what they are saying. Let us all hope Israel doesn't become part of that list.
6. Ben Ari for PM
Dan Lini   (01.06.11)
How is this guy not the PM. Bibi governs scared. Ben Ari for PM
7. He sure is right about the left
mindRider ,   The Free World   (01.06.11)
At last someone who dares to call the Jewish selfhating left wing alleged "intellectuals" what they truly are and have always been through the ages: the worst threat to the Jewish people.
8. MK Ben-Ari: Eradicate treacherous leftists
Norway   (01.06.11)
He Is Right!!!
9. Cicero On Treason, 42 B.C.E.
Cicero ,   Malmö, Sweden   (01.06.11)
"A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and he carries his banners openly. But the traitor moves among those within the gate freely, his sly whispers rustling through all the galleys, heard in the very hall of government itself. For the traitor appears not a traitor - he speaks in the accents familiar to his victims, and wears their face and their garment, and he appeals to the baseness that lies deep in the hearts of all men. He rots the soul of a nation - he works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the pillars of a city - he infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist. A murderer is less to be feared." -Cicero, 42 B.C.E.-
10. Ben-Ari's suggestion should put Israel on quick path to...
Rafi ,   US   (01.06.11)
...become the next Pakistan (where a liberal province governor who stood up for women & minority groups was just assassinated). So good suggestion Mr Ben-Ari... Yigal Amir would be proud of you. You offer a great future for democratic Israel - NOT!
11. Do not use my tax money for these groups called Peace Now
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (01.06.11)
and etc.
12. Long overdue,better late than never
Ari Shemtov ,   Jerusalem Israel   (01.06.11)
These so called NGO groups had it too good for too long,they are a law unto themselves,they call the tunes,and the rest of Israel dances to their tunes.It's about time that Israel yanked their chain. They will kick and scream.Let them kick and scream.
13. Blasphemy
Zichron   (01.06.11)
The democratic human rights socialists built this land the religious contributed not much even in the six day war . Who were the heroes the airforce a left stronghold Dayan a secular the generals all secular and in the Yom kippur war also .Whatever the interim truce plans two or one state all jews psychological cultural and religious must be included because matyrdom votes as compensation will have to be allotted.
14. mk. ben-ari........
sjoerd van der velde ,   hoorn-the netherland   (01.06.11)
ben-ari can become another adolf hitler if he will get the chance. if i were a jew i would be ashamed of my own people. he should be prosecuted for sewing hatred towards (jewish) people who have another opinion, groups-insultion/slander/offending/hate-mongering/mongering to murder, even genocide. iam curious what the democratic israelian constitutional state will do to prevent this. that israel really is this should be proven every time anew like any other state which says it is. not just only empty words, but in practice/reality!
15. to nr. 5- john r.- nyc, usa.
sjoerd van der velde ,   hoorn-the netherland   (01.06.11)
i fully agree with this tackback of you. the term: "self-hating jew" was first used by theodor lessing in 1930 in germany in his book: "der juedischer selbsthass" if somebody/a jew is called a self-hating jew when she/he is critical of zionism and the zionist netanyahu/government/regime then i can be called a self-hating dutchman if i donot agree with the present dutch cabinet/coalition/government/regime. so what? i donot care. everybody has the right on her/his own opinions, freedom of expression and speech if we donot put to hurting, insulting, slander, revilement or/and hatred against someone, a group, a population/people which is not allowed in a reel democratic constitutional state!
16. It's About Time
iNet Fraud ,   USA   (01.06.11)
The leftists are no longer considered activists: they are indeed spreading dangerous lies, propaganda and slander which has led to violence and death by emboldening terrorists. I don't know how these sick individuals think they are changing anything for the better: they've put this world on the brink of WW3 without any exaggeration. Iran adores this psychotic twits and their idiotic agendas. Greed, corruption, lies and murder: that is what they've given the world. How anyone on this planet can't see how the leftists have become nothing short of terrorists are as bad as they are. I hope all of these filthy, lying lefties get shut down, run out of town or put behind bars: they're criminals, NOT organizations who want peace or progress. Down with the radical left!!!
17. Collaborators....
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (01.06.11)
Probes are not going solve the problem. The Left will continue its destructive activities. Put them on trial and lock them up!
18. Leftists
Michaelpielet ,   Boca, usa   (01.06.11)
These leftists should be called to justice and eliminated. They are all funded by the enemies of the state of israel. They hide behind democracy and freedom of the press.
19. Barely 10% of Kadima M.K.s support sane policies.
Chaim ,   Israel   (01.06.11)
The fact that barely 10% of Kadima M.K.s support an extremely necessary probe of leftist extremists, who undermine and threaten Israel in many ways, tells us all we need to know about Kadima. It is a stooge of the far left. It is no longer possible to pretend Kadima is a centrist part. Kadima needs to be voted out of existence as much as Labor and Meretz.
20. Common sense at last
John ,   Wellington NZ   (01.06.11)
It is high time Israel stopped being the passive punching bag of people who don;t care if Israel is destroyed from within or without, as long as it is destroyed. Traitors from within are particularly despicable and should be exposed and sent to a country where they will be at home with their hate.
21. #5 you must be new here on ynet talkbacks because we don't
rachel ,   usa   (01.06.11)
swallow at all the long list of lies and BS you are giving us. We know what is really going on . Maybe haaretz might be more for you . They will accept anything as long as it bad mouth Israel .boy are you brainwashed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
22. Eradicate the left...
marlene ,   Philadelphia, USA   (01.06.11)
The left conspires against the State. They are not only "treacherous" but TREASONOUS and should be dealt wi th accordingly. Israel's left is its own worst enemy.
23. All Leftists should be moved to Gaza!
Phoenix ,   Israel   (01.06.11)
All leftists are traitors, lovers of the ennemy and haters of their own kind. They hate Israel and they Hate to be related to the Jewish People. They should go to live in Gaza with their beloved Hamas, they will use them as sexual slaves. The leftists are garbage
24. This Is The BEST THING Israel Has Ever Done --
Mordechai Glovinsky ,   Teresopolis, Brasil   (01.06.11)
Since The DECLARATION Of Israel's Independence!!!
25. Ben Ari- You are the reason....
TzVi ,   NY   (01.06.11)
I don't pray that the Kenesset walls collapse. Their is hope. Their is hope.
26. Response to#2
John R ,   NYC USA   (01.06.11)
In America, we deal with NGO's where funding sources are also not generally revealed. They can be revealed under a freedom of information act inquiry which is cumbersome and very time consuming. A group called NGO Monitor has pursued that line of inquiry for what they deem to be anti-Israeli organizations.I have no issue with that. Most countries have NO freedom of information act so this bill would do almost nothing with respect to foreign intervention in the media. That is not my main concern. The difficulty with what you suggest is that perfectly legal contributors to NGO's will not contribute if their names are revealed( because they fear retribution). Mr. Ben Ari's anger may be very mild compared to how others may react .In fact read some of these talk back responses. It is why talk back responders names are also not revealed. The effect is that in a country where 80% of the Jewish voting population is right wing is what you would expect. You will eliminate the left's public voice. There are, based on circulation figures, overwhelming pro right wing papers in Israel. There is also ample funding for the right wing media in general in Israel. If you disagree with the left wing or you feel like they are spreading lies then by all means expose it. That is function of a free press. To expose lies and inform the public and the public is supposed to be smart enough to decipher the truth.
27. Ben-Ari is right
Adam Helberg ,   USA   (01.06.11)
No other country would tolerate such a large force within that works against the state. Everything from Neturei Karta to B'tzelem to members of Knesset who have no allegiance to Israel but work to destroy it. It's far beyond free speech.
28. Brownshirts
Dovid ,   Los Angeles   (01.06.11)
If these "Rightists" had been in Germany in the 1930s, they would have joined the Nazi party.
29. A bunch of useless doofuses
Hostage   (01.06.11)
The so-called elements that want to destroy the Jewish state that are already operating within the State of Israel are the MKs in the current governing coalition. What a bunch of useless doofuses.
30. good idea to investigate them
Larry ,   Los Angeles   (01.06.11)
It should be a requirement that all groups, left and right, to list all donations, large and small, and who is giving them... But we know that they will have it sent through a intermediary anyway....
Next talkbacks
Back to article