Opinion
The danger of Liebermanism
Dani Filc
Published: 12.01.11, 00:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. It's like putting lipstick on a pig.
noa ,   israel   (01.12.11)
32. Dani Filk ! YOU ARE THE DANGER FOR ISRAEL SECURITY
(01.12.11)
33. Filk it's time to take ur pills and to go to sleep
(01.12.11)
34. leiberman is the best
a ash ,   nyc   (01.12.11)
he is a straight talker - and realizes the truth and is not afraid to speak
35. follow the money
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (01.12.11)
It is quite amazing when a Professor (Ben Gurion University) writes such an error-ridden article. To figure out why, we should follow the money. Dani Filk is a board member of the rabidly anti-Israeli PHR group. There are allegations that PHR receives money from the Al Aqsa Fund of Ramallah (that pays suicide bombers) and the Islamic Investment Bank. If Lieberman has his way, these allegations will be investigated and if true, Dani Filk might find himself losing money. Before writing such articles, Dani Filk should learn the meaning of the word "gilui naot" (proper disclosure).
36. Pitiable Dr. Filk
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.12.11)
What Dr. Filk completely fails to understand is that the only thing that will satisfy the international community would be if Israel were to unilaterally declare its statehood dissolved. Nothing short of that will endear Israel to the world. So it's really time to stop trying to make them like us. I love the fact of an Avigdor Lieberman who tells it like it is, is not afraid to ruffle feathers and asserts Israel's absolute right to exist. I love the idea that the terrorist organizations arrayed against Israel and the assorted Islamofascist states such as Iran, Turkey and Syria are offended by Lieberman's remarks. That tells me he must be doing something right. I also think that the voices in Israel which would see Israel destroyed in the name of socialist principles which have no place in modern Israeli society SHOULD be silenced. I think they are at best, seditious, and at worst, treasonous. Dr. Filk is of a bygone era. Yes, it would have been nice to impart our dovish left-wing views upon our neighbors, but they opted for war and we had to respond in kind. Nothing has changed, except that the more powerful we become, the more they would like to destroy us. The only thing that terrorists respect is strength. A dovish Israel that whines incessantly about "democracy" and "democratic principles" plays straight into the hands of those who wish to destroy us. I remind Dr. Filk that during the American Civil War, sacred constitutional principles such as habeas corpus, freedom of the press and freedom of speech were routinely suspended as Americans fought against themselves. There was a greater goal at stake -- preserving the United States. Israel should go about the business of preserving Israel. If it means talking down the leftists, then so be it. There will be plenty of time to restore our democratic inclinations once we have gotten rid of the enemy within. I think Dr. Filk should go off some pleace truly backwards and horrific and practice medicine. It will give him an opportunity to show us his democratic and humanitarian bent in action rather than merely writing about it.
37. #22 Fake. The real Salma knows...
Eli   (01.12.11)
that Lieberman would box their ears and from that point of view it's not something to be made light of.
38. Canadian Doofus #25 what do you know about combat?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (01.12.11)
Yes I have lost a lot of friends and family due to combat over the years. I happen to know a lot about combat. Their sacrifices were to protect the rights of my people. And here we have another leftist that thinks that by taking rights away from those that disagree with his philosophy that this will somehow make things better. Only a true idiot thinks such things. Since you have issues with that and have an incredible hardship in understanding plain English I don't consider you too bright either. How does censorship bring peace? And who gets to decide who the censor is? You and that idiot Filk? Sorry but I trust neither of you. As for support - I trust that the majority of the peace-loving democratic minded people are a lot more logical than somebody who believes in censorship and a dictatorship.
39. Dr Dani Filc
BH ,   Iowa   (01.12.11)
You are a shame to Hollywood Upstairs Medical College.
40. # 38. Gee.
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.12.11)
Good answer Gee & btw you are NOT a thug.
41. Racism and all that c.....
Freha Bablida ,   Gibraltar   (01.12.11)
Yes Dr. Filc, we do really understand your concern and the prespective you see from your own experience. Argentina is a great point to advise the Israelis that if you were on the border with Chile, Brasil and all those Christians countries, you probably run the dangers of being another Chile run amock by a guy like Binochet. Lets be little careful and please treat each situation according to its specificity. Israel is not Kosovo nor is it a banana Republic, but it is a very diversified and democratically challenging even a good meaning man like Dr. Filc, if we were a very Suisse people, we probably will have to make a revolution to look like Israel.
42. Jarda, CZ
PR   (01.12.11)
Jarda dear, I don't really think you even should open your foul mouth about Lieberman and the supposed sins of Israel. You, who have an ultra-conservative quasi-fascist Gypsy-hater of the Czech Republic that raises thick walls within cities in Usti nad Labem against their own gypsy population, whenever not persecuting and discriminationg against them, that is, for example to the human race's eternal shame. Hey Jarda, this is not 1938, but the XXIst century! Do you think that we are all uninformed? You come from a despearate 3rd world country. Good luck to the Gypsy population!
43. Lieberman is the true face of Israel
Leon ,   Ottawa, Canada   (01.13.11)
Many left and right wing Israelis hate him because he says what many Zionists think. Lieberman represents Israel's future. Long live Lieberman.
44. Of course we have
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (01.13.11)
some "very strange" people here. But not in position of FM.
45. With this nonsense you manipulated
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (01.13.11)
Israel into a multicultural state of being which we jews were and are and not will be.Please realise this rubbish from where you came from.
46. This guy is simply politicing
frank ,   israel   (01.13.11)
Amazing when something happens it is blamed on the right. Vitiolic words are the blame. But when the left spouts all their nasty diatrobs, it is freedom. Frankly what flic is suggesting is freedom of speech is not something the right can enjoy and this is only the domain of the left. They take every opportunity to cover up terrorism and suggest killing jews is sort of ok because we are occupying something that is actually ours, but if the right expresses their wishes, however loud, it becomes racist and inciteful. Curbing free expression, and please this is not the case of yelling fire in a crowded theater, but rather the free exchange of thoughts and ideas, Hey you write your nonsense, why don't I have the same rights??? however repugnant you may find the majority voice, is still a freedom we should be able to enjoy. But the left is only interested in their elitist thoughts. Ok, how about having these illegals in these "camps" live across the street from YOU!!!! You mention the rep that was shot. but did you mention the muslim US soldier who killed 13 people screaming alah akbar in the US? The same crap is taking place here as in the US. They whitewashed the whole episode saying he was depressed, sick etc etc. Everything but what it was an out and out terrorist act! Whereas the rep was shot by a crazy! Pure and simple. He liked Mein Kamph and the communist manafesto...sort of both sides of the political coin....but you jump all over the right. What about the left and their vitiolic speeches every day in our newspapers??? makes me mad.....so please save your speeches for your arab news media friends better, go there for a while and enjoy their freedoms ... but that would be our fault also....would't it....
47. you are so out of touch and wrong. it is you who is the enem
ralph   (01.13.11)
48. Dani, stop the witch hunt. Be transparent.
Eran ,   Singapore   (01.14.11)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article